😍 😉
This a fork inspired by a post by
@hifijim following his inspired thread on
measurements that matter, except we all got into the weeds for the first 10 pages...all about impedance traces...
So to clear the air, I thought we could play the Impedance plot game:
Rules:
Maximum 2 sweeps per graph.
Phase is included, but if graphs get too busy, I can remove them.
1 Logarithmic Y scale MUST be included (allows one to view high and low values simultaneously)
A zoomed in trace may be requested (optional)
No red/green traces please (for our red/green colour impaired friends)
Winners:
Correctly guesses the reason for the difference between the two traces. Close enough is good enough...
GOLDENEYE award- correctly understands the difference between the two traces.
SCIENTIFIC COMMUNICATOR AWARD - explains why, in lay terms, for the differences, so that we can all follow along.
eg.
"This trace is a of a subwoofer, because of the peak in the graph is at a low frequency ie. 23Hz. Is it a very high peak, because... . The double peaks and the saddle in between them at 38 Hz suggests that this is.... The discontinuity at ~170Hz suggests either... however we need more information on the..."
I'll be adding to this this list as I collect more. Please feel free to add your own for the diyAudio brains trust to help solve your impedance plot problems... Remember, the only way to learn is to make mistakes. So feel free to have a go!
First up:
GOLDENEYE! for
@PKAudio's
post. How did he do it? Any Scientific Communicators among us?
previous Leading scorer:
@stv,
partially correct on both traces. very close- please try again!
ITEM 2:
GOLDENEYE award to
@mbrennwa . Yes, correct on all counts. But why only
possibly in a sealed box? Was there any doubt? And why/why not? What happens when one omits damping?
ITEM 3: courtesy
@Hörnli
ITEM 4: same product, different samples.
2nd graph courtesy of
John Krutke
ITEM 5: Coming up....
PS. Once you win a prize, please go to the end of the line and wait for other people have a go. Better yet, post your own confusing/tricky plots for us to play/learn from....