Hello, after a long time, I've finally built a working amp based on the designs discussed on
THIS thread.
What I can say right away is: I was impressed with how the circuit showed great stability on a breadboard and with no compensation network, no thermal feedback and exhibited symmetrical clipping and no visible crossover distortion even at insufficient bias.
The circuit (all components used are exactly the same):
Shown below is the early prototype (with much reduced parts count):
Final prototype (25000uF per rail):
I see you doubled the output devices for only 50W output, why was that?
With only one pair, the THD was limited to 0.005% @1W and 0.030% @50W, adding an extra pair allowed me to have much better THD at full power and also increased the Damping Factor from ~300 to the values shown below.
Now let's jump to the measurements:
- Frequency Response: 4Hz ~ 147kHz
- Noise (Max Vpp): <20mVpp
- Noise (Max Vrms): <4mVrms
- Slew Rate: >30V/us
- Max DC Offset: <3mV
- Damping Factor (50W/8R/20Hz): 1820
- Damping Factor (50W/8R/100Hz): 1870
- Damping Factor (50W/8R/1kHz): 1870
- THD (1W/8R/1kHz): <0.002% (limited by signal gen. THD)
- THD (50W/8R/1kHz): <0.006%
- Phase Shift @20kHz: <10.2°
- IMD (1W/10kHz+11kHz/1:1 ratio): <0.004%
- Input Sensitivity: 360mVrms
- Voltage Gain: 34dB
Some extra considerations:
— Sound card used was a Creative Sound Blaster X-fi HD (SB1240);
— You can get more than double the SR by changing the compensation network and the low pass input RC filter, I only chose these values so I could show that the amp is stable with unrealistic capacitive loads;
— I only chose a TL081C as DC servo because I didn't want to use my expensive JFET input op amps (also it'd be a pain to solder because they're all SMD) but I encourage everyone to use something better, the datasheet says it's immune to latch-up but THAT'S A LIE, and a HUGE problem if your finished design doesn't have output DC protection;
— I couldn't realiably measure damping factor at and above 10kHz because my multimeter does not have the bandwidth (I don't think most of the do anyway) and my scope doesn't have the accuracy (I was measuring at full power output) for measuring high voltages with mV precision, but I have strong evidence that the DF doesn't stray far from the 1800:1 across the entire audio spectrum;
— I didn't measure IMD at full power because the generator was the same external sound card that was analyzing the output signal and I had no way to isolate the input to prevent a ground loop (at low power it was fine because no high currents were involved and the grounding layout worked fine). For those interested, it measured 0.045%;
— The heatsink used is working on its limit, I had to set the idle (
cold) current very high to achieve the idle (
hot) current I wanted. Before I realized this, the insufficient heatsink size made it so that after 30min the idle current had fallen way below what I had set initially. I recommend choosing a bigger heatsink;
— You can extract more power from the circuit by making the driver stage a single BJT emitter follower instead of the discrete Darlington emitter follower I chose, at the cost of higher loading of the VAS;
— The amp was not tested with 4R loads because my transformer can't supply enough current, thought the circuit can probably handle 4R without problems.
Applying capacitive loads:
- 1nF and lower: no visible change
- 10nF: no visible change
- 100nF: small oscillation over the negative part of the square wave
- 1uF: very large overshoot but stops immediately, doesn't break down into a chaotic oscillation
*Details for 100nF and 1uF loads are shown in the attached pictures.
I will not be supplying the .asc file (unless someone really wants) because I don't have most of the models, I just renamed the components on the schematic above to match what I used in real life.