Slewmaster - CFA vs. VFA "Rumble"

Thanks for answer.
I know the fact about thermal. I try to spread ops as much as i can with available space. But i don't be anxious about that.....as the Vrail will be +/-50VDC. I planed to build a MJL3281/1302 (i have good matched triplets). The package on the picture is the TO264 one so i have a little bit space, they are not so close as in the monster version. For the BJT OPS i have quite generous heatsink (265x140x75mm with 16mm base). The other version i will build is the Vfet one with TO247 margin space will be more consequent. This version will be mount on 300x120x40mm with 10mm base). In both case i think thermal will not be an issue.

The picture under show the 3 situations : TO264/MT200/TO247

Marc

I would just make a 2 pair out of your design. The 2 pair mt-200 (or
semelab MGxxxx) would be a healthy 200W+ OPS.

In the space where the middle pair is - place the OP inductor.

I plan on keeping 2 of my old 5 pair OPS's in 3 pair mode - they are
nearly perfect thermally on a 3U.

I really want someone to build the new 5 pair OPS , even "blow us away"
with the maximum ( a 80V rail 5- pair MT-200 ultra monster).😀

OS
 
I would just make a 2 pair out of your design. The 2 pair mt-200 (or
semelab MGxxxx) would be a healthy 200W+ OPS.

In the space where the middle pair is - place the OP inductor.

I plan on keeping 2 of my old 5 pair OPS's in 3 pair mode - they are
nearly perfect thermally on a 3U.

I really want someone to build the new 5 pair OPS , even "blow us away"
with the maximum ( a 80V rail 5- pair MT-200 ultra monster).😀

OS

That will not be me as i don't see what i will do with that monster in 15m² listening room. The +/-50VDC choice in fact is because i have 4 nice 500Va 2x35V Rcore trafo. I will use one per chanel.
For MT200 what would be your choice : 2SC2922/2SA1216 or 2SC3264/2SA1295?
 

Attachments

  • P1030452.JPG
    P1030452.JPG
    131.7 KB · Views: 387
I would just make a 2 pair out of your design. The 2 pair mt-200 (or
semelab MGxxxx) would be a healthy 200W+ OPS.

In the space where the middle pair is - place the OP inductor.

I plan on keeping 2 of my old 5 pair OPS's in 3 pair mode - they are
nearly perfect thermally on a 3U.

I really want someone to build the new 5 pair OPS , even "blow us away"
with the maximum ( a 80V rail 5- pair MT-200 ultra monster).😀

OS

That sounds like a good one for you to build. Are you rebuilding you big amp or is this another project?
 
That will not be me as i don't see what i will do with that monster in 15m² listening room. The +/-50VDC choice in fact is because i have 4 nice 500Va 2x35V Rcore trafo. I will use one per chanel.
For MT200 what would be your choice : 2SC2922/2SA1216 or 2SC3264/2SA1295?

Nice trafo's !!

2922 vs. 3264 = almost the same.
Cob and ft are similar.
3264 is a bit faster/newer model.
3264 is higher voltage , better SOA @ 60V.

With your 53-54V rails ( I have a 35-0-35 as my tester trafo) ,
both would be the same.

OS
 
That sounds like a good one for you to build. Are you rebuilding you big amp or is this another project?

My big amp would most likely keep on ticking for 20 years , If I did not
bring it outside or party with it.

I'm scared if I do , my center pair will fail if I push to my thermal limit.
I have my protection sensor right over the center output - because I
know that one is the weak link.

I also know without distributing that heat equally , I don't have as powerful
an amp as should be (derating). Centers are 10C hotter than outers.

I don't need that much power , an "ultimate monoblock" wealthy builder
could buy a 1KVA trafo for each channel , embellish with 100Kuf.
He would then have 2 Pass X250's to power his 10K$ speakers.😀

OS
 
I would just make a 2 pair out of your design. The 2 pair mt-200 (or
semelab MGxxxx) would be a healthy 200W+ OPS.

In the space where the middle pair is - place the OP inductor.

I plan on keeping 2 of my old 5 pair OPS's in 3 pair mode - they are
nearly perfect thermally on a 3U.

I really want someone to build the new 5 pair OPS , even "blow us away"
with the maximum ( a 80V rail 5- pair MT-200 ultra monster).😀

OS

So more "Uni", inductor in the midle, but keeping the other package possibility as the pair output....
 

Attachments

  • UniSlewMaster_evo_brd.png
    UniSlewMaster_evo_brd.png
    148.8 KB · Views: 379
I would just make a 2 pair out of your design. The 2 pair mt-200 (or
semelab MGxxxx) would be a healthy 200W+ OPS.

In the space where the middle pair is - place the OP inductor.

I plan on keeping 2 of my old 5 pair OPS's in 3 pair mode - they are
nearly perfect thermally on a 3U.

I really want someone to build the new 5 pair OPS , even "blow us away"
with the maximum ( a 80V rail 5- pair MT-200 ultra monster).😀

OS
Ostripper, why didn`t you use diamond input OPS, you got about 2 x 0.7V bias voltage canceling and easier connection with gain stage at only one spot, perfect current amplifier module block 🙂 . IMHO it sounds better too.
 
So more "Uni", inductor in the midle, but keeping the other package possibility as the pair output....

Then with the extra space left over near the fuses , reposition and
allow for a 16-18mm main decoupling caps.

18mm is still the same 7.5mm LS and can be 2400uf@ 63V/1800@80/1K-100.
16mm can be 1800/1200/820u.

Those electrolytics at the output collectors are not essential. If they are too
small , your rails will "ring".
My idea for these on the slew V1.x came from the edmond stuart "camp".
They used no main decoupling , Just 4 smd 100-100V units at the collectors.
No inductance before the collector pads.

Omit them and just use a big 1Kuf at the beginning of a 30A Imax rail , you
would see the same signal at the collectors.

The secondary decoupling that feeds the driver/pre-driver rail is 4.7R -10R
plus a 47-470uf R/C combo. (below 1) green = R/C at drivers , red= the cap multiplier output.

The multiplier is a real good edition (below 2)green = input pair pssr , red= the final amp output after NFB.

This with a CFA !!! -120db is very good. That is why no slewmaster blows
up. Also , the ops is the best to compare with ... as CFA and VFA are
both have quite low PSRR. Some VFA's can drop to -150db using the multiplier.

OS
 

Attachments

  • ops psrr.jpg
    ops psrr.jpg
    51.1 KB · Views: 375
That will not be me as i don't see what i will do with that monster in 15m² listening room. The +/-50VDC choice in fact is because i have 4 nice 500Va 2x35V Rcore trafo. I will use one per chanel.
For MT200 what would be your choice : 2SC2922/2SA1216 or 2SC3264/2SA1295?

Hi
Is these type of transformer better quality than Plitron LONO.
I have to order 2PC 32V 100VA transformer. I know Plitron great quality but I never had the chance to test one like yours on the picture.
Greetings
 

Attachments

  • 485969d1433103406-slewmaster-cfa-vs-vfa-rumble-p1030452.jpg
    485969d1433103406-slewmaster-cfa-vs-vfa-rumble-p1030452.jpg
    131.7 KB · Views: 365
I'm your man.....would only need to put the os together and could go right into it's home. +-82 volt 800 watt supply and big heatsinks.

You realize the V2.0 OPS will even fit the same bolt holes ?
Not much redrilling. Use the same HS's.

The secondary decoupling can be 2X 470u and the primary can be 2 X 1000uF.

A 500W amp like this would need .01-.03C/W (7U 300+mm) of sink.
There is no way a V1.x OPS could dissipate that amount of heat.
All 5 would be in the thermal space of just positions 2-4 on the new OPS.
Pair 1 and 5 on the new one would be 200mm apart.
ONLY 50mm left to each end of the sink. ALL the outputs would therefore
have about the same dissipation area (on a 300mm extrusion).

PS- .01 would be a 20C rise at <2KW. .02-03 would max out at 65C.

This would be absolutely necessary to dissipate up to 2KW. Even
with a 7U , you might need a bit of fan to help convection.

This amp would be in the realm of ESP #117 -Project 117
The warnings apply to the new slew , as well.
About half of it. 500/800W. Best power to size ratio.
For ESP's project , 1500W is in the realm of class D or H.

OS
 
My current set uses per channel:
8" of this heatsink 10.080" Wide Extruded Aluminum Heatsink - HeatsinkUSA
800va transformer
two bridge rectifiers
crc fiilter 27000uf .0825ohm 27,000uf

The heatsink with the OS attached just slips up out of the chassis. If it is needed I could slip in a longer piece of the heatsink extrusion.

I need to get thermal interface for the big transistors.
E
Thermal interface comes with Sanken devices. If it doesn't, email them and complain. I got 10 free pairs that way.
 
My current set uses per channel:
8" of this heatsink 10.080" Wide Extruded Aluminum Heatsink - HeatsinkUSA
800va transformer
two bridge rectifiers
crc fiilter 27000uf .0825ohm 27,000uf

The heatsink with the OS attached just slips up out of the chassis. If it is needed I could slip in a longer piece of the heatsink extrusion.

I need to get thermal interface for the big transistors.
E

That will work. So you are 8" X 10" ,wide that is 1.6X what I have. If my
150W OP's were spaced , my whole HS would idle at <40C.

230W (devices) would idle at the same temp biased to 60ma. Your extra area
would be reserved to dissipate actual audio wattage.
You would be low 30's on idle , might bump 55C if you pushed 1/2kw
for a time. Music would be 40's.
The new board is exactly 10" , BTW. Your wires at the interfaces would be
right at the edge of your heatsinks. You seen it , huh ?

OS