B1 with Korg Triode

Most likely it is already known, but Pete Millett has a suspension adapter for the Nutube. I have used one and found it to be incredibly useful and effective. In light of that, I bought two more to use on other Nutube units that I have made.
FWIW, I agree with the above post about the Nutube being a good match for a class D amp. It just so happens that I built Pete Millett's 50WPC amp which uses the SP1 tube in the input. It was a headshaker. Some of the engineers out there are really incredible with using new technology with old and beating the game.
 
That's the one alright. I do think that there are other ideas that lead to this tube performing at it's best in tandem with the suspension product that Pete Millett has offered. FWIW, I bought 2 of the last 3 available at this time so there's only one left in stock. One idea in particular is to not use the bolts and spacers given in the kit and instead use soft silicone rubber board mounts. With mine, I even use small O rings to lift the board above the bottom plate so that there isn't something awful that happens when the bottom of the circuit board bottoms out on the metal bottom plate of the enclosure.
 
All Kaneta audio gear is always build point-to-point on the perfboards :yikes:
Athletic training with soldering iron :Olympic: :D Papa style DIY is super easy !
You can find pdf. documentations on this blog: レポート | 趣味の自作半導体アンプ

Nutube Current Power IVC MK2 http://myaudio.sakura.ne.jp/report/6P1_Current_Power_IVC_MK2_電圧伝送対応.pdf

Nutube Current Power IVC http://myaudio.sakura.ne.jp/report/6P1_Current_Power_IVC_電圧伝送対応.pdf

Power Supply Box2 http://myaudio.sakura.ne.jp/report/ACPowerSupplyBOX2.pdf

Korg Triode USB DAC http://myaudio.sakura.ne.jp/report/I2S接続USB DAC作成レポート.pdf
Thanks Soundhappy for the sharing! Indeed M.Pass work are a lot less trouble to build thanks to the diyaudio staff. What I like with Kaneta san is that he test his creation with High effiency drivers and Denon DL 103, a setup ressembling mine. Indeed interesting design !
 
It is always difficult to assess, isn't it, as people who encounter problems will of course post and be more visible than people who don't...

I have a B1 Korg, so far no problem. If people not having any serious problem caused by this tube would post aswell, perhaps that would help drawing a clear picture?

Saying that because with another strong hobby of mine, cars and Lotus in particular, I am tired to read horror stories about the K engine HGF, posted by always the same individuals (a few not even having such a car, many being careless people that went wrong initialy), while the majority of happy trackers is quite.

Absolutely not saying it is the case here, at least people seem to care and can't do that many things wrong, but it would be nice to read how many folks are happy with the Korg tube before it gets a bad reputation (that should at least be deserved and founded if so).

All IMHO

Claude

No Problem with NuTube sounds great. Still on my original head gasket on my Elise too. No problem a PRRT won't prevent - small world.
 
Member
Joined 2019
Paid Member
That's the one alright. I do think that there are other ideas that lead to this tube performing at it's best in tandem with the suspension product that Pete Millett has offered. FWIW, I bought 2 of the last 3 available at this time so there's only one left in stock. One idea in particular is to not use the bolts and spacers given in the kit and instead use soft silicone rubber board mounts. With mine, I even use small O rings to lift the board above the bottom plate so that there isn't something awful that happens when the bottom of the circuit board bottoms out on the metal bottom plate of the enclosure.

The biggest effect on this tube, in my experience, is vibrations through the mounting pins. So whether one uses PM’s suspension product, or how the builder in post #6048 did it, or my less elegant approaches (pictured below along with the board I used purchase from Ebay & double-sided sticky foam from Home Depot) all will help stop vibrations to the tube. One is straight wire attached to the Ebay board the other is a looped wire soldered directly onto the Nutube pins (all wire is the multi-stranded flexible silicon coated type and tubes are mounted on foam). This is probably the best bang-for-the-buck to eliminate most ringing/microphonics with the Korg. Yes, sound damping will also be a productive endeavor as well.

Electronic failings of the tube is a completely different story.

Cheers, Pete
 

Attachments

  • 287CD54C-367E-4EE4-A5E7-F6E34A263CEC.jpeg
    287CD54C-367E-4EE4-A5E7-F6E34A263CEC.jpeg
    318.7 KB · Views: 314
  • C9EB1544-DF47-429D-8D38-501E9BB80D9B.jpeg
    C9EB1544-DF47-429D-8D38-501E9BB80D9B.jpeg
    574.8 KB · Views: 313
  • EBB7A7F8-61DA-4C36-8138-4B0475713371.jpeg
    EBB7A7F8-61DA-4C36-8138-4B0475713371.jpeg
    148.9 KB · Views: 327
The biggest effect on this tube, in my experience, is vibrations through the mounting pins. So whether one uses PM’s suspension product, or how the builder in post #6048 did it, or my less elegant approaches (pictured below along with the board I used purchase from Ebay & double-sided sticky foam from Home Depot) all will help stop vibrations to the tube. One is straight wire attached to the Ebay board the other is a looped wire soldered directly onto the Nutube pins (all wire is the multi-stranded flexible silicon coated type and tubes are mounted on foam). This is probably the best bang-for-the-buck to eliminate most ringing/microphonics with the Korg. Yes, sound damping will also be a productive endeavor as well.



Electronic failings of the tube is a completely different story.



Cheers, Pete
Just to put things in perspective. And maybe I'm very lucky. But I have no ringing at all. I used only double sided tape for dampening. The board is mounted inside the class D power amp. The housing has slids. Definitely not all NuTubes behave the same.
 
Yes, I think that both of you are correct in that 1) each tube seems to be of it's own goodness or shortcomings, 2) the damping supplied with the tube may be just fine, i.e. I have experienced both of these situations. One tube is without ringing the next is unusable in comparison, and some even ring all by themselves!
When I built the 50w class D amp that PM offered, the tubes rang excessively, then stopped. I did nothing different. After that, the amp sounded so incredible that it was a headshaking experience. I have built many Nutube products and overall am enamored with their sound.
 
ResisterClone
Joined 2011
Paid Member
Thanks Soundhappy…Amp A really sounded the best to me. I was surprised.
My KB1 is working fabulously so far…of course after reading the build thread I did incorporate sound deadening tactics. I also bought a couple more NuTube’s.
 

Attachments

  • 060F3EAA-BD13-4135-947A-19A1A3B9F815.jpg
    060F3EAA-BD13-4135-947A-19A1A3B9F815.jpg
    988.9 KB · Views: 421
Still getting hiss

Absolutely loving this build, but I still get a hiss that isn't terrible but is keeping it on the bench in favor of a DCB1.

Does not seem effected by volume. Good continuity between ground and chassis. Nutube rings when you touch the chassis, but in normal playing I don't notice it.

Currently have just the eraser on top, had foam underneath but I took that out.

Any suggestions?


Edit- took out the filter to make sure that wasn't it.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20210909_084813476.jpg
    IMG_20210909_084813476.jpg
    995.8 KB · Views: 307
Last edited:
Member
Joined 2019
Paid Member
If the ALPs pot, or the L-bracket it’s mounted on are not grounded to the chassis just try that. Your aluminum bracket looks like it’s glued to the chassis? I’m supposing your PCB is mounted to the chassis with conductive standoffs?

Pete

Absolutely loving this build, but I still get a hiss that isn't terrible but is keeping it on the bench in favor of a DCB1.

Does not seem effected by volume. Good continuity between ground and chassis. Nutube rings when you touch the chassis, but in normal playing I don't notice it.

Currently have just the eraser on top, had foam underneath but I took that out.

Any suggestions?


Edit- took out the filter to make sure that wasn't it.
 
Yes I followed the build guide section 4 - "use an aluminum L-bracket, a small wooden block, and a hot glue gun to secure the volume pot." In my defense I was trying to bring the pot further in as the shaft was way too long for the knob I had...

Good news, while I was testing the grounding on the pot/bracket I noticed one of the signal wires was just touching the metal frame of the pot. I moved it up and it seems much better.

Will also look into passively attenuating, thanks NP :) I do have more gain than I need in my system so there might be an additional benefit to that.