I've rabbit-holed down a number of paths, and am now confused at a higher level.
My room is 12.5 ft across from where the sound system must go. 13 ft across, then one side opens up into a larger basement area. Mildly acoustic absorbing drop ceiling. Decent room, some acoustic treatment behind the speakers and bookshelves. Current system is a HTA100 hybrid driven by TV optical or bluetooth from other things (bluetooth's limits show up). The speakers are Polk RT55 Two 6.5" and a 1" dome tweeter. Well supported (invisibly) by a decent subwoofer. Not as crisp and detailed as I'd like for nicely recorded music, but nice for the TV.
I intend to find or build a reasonably compact pair of cabinets. These would move away for TV time, and for my relaxing time, move into the room a bit, would still be oddly placed (I think frugalhorn mk3 and other rear firing designs are out.
Small footprint, ideally no more than 3 ft / meter tall, more or less. I'd really like to be able to build with already dimensioned lumber, standard widths being 3.5", 4.5", 5.5", 7.25", 8.25" and so on. Sides I can use good ply.
I'm looking for clean, crisp, transparent sound. I don't need super highs or magic earthshattering bass. I just need moderate volume. I can rig to my sub, or get a small sub for each speaker if need be, but having them stand alone OK would be nice. Not so easily "seeing" where the speakers are would be great. My odd HiVi system is invisible, I can look right at the drivers and can't see/hear that the sound is coming from there. That's the sensation I want.
Decision 1: Size of drivers. I'm listening to 3" HiVi B3N in pipe TL at about 20" washing across computer monitor screen. That's what I want but large. 3" drivers may be too little. Based on reviews of various posts here, 4" or 5" seem right, given the size of the room. I could easily be wrong, and 3" might allow slightly more compact.
Decision 2: Which driver? I keep coming back to the Pluvia 7.2 HD based on "listening" to youtube videos. Other contenders include the Alpair 7 MS. But I really don't know. Something $75/driver is great, but I could go to perhaps $110 before flinching.
Decision 3: Cabinet. I'm tempted by the various tall open boxes, e.g., TABAQ and Pensil. But the folded up Voigt pipe versions (e.g., long Sibelius discussion) got me thinking.
https://www.diyaudio.com/community/threads/markaudio-7ms-and-chp90-enclosure-options.402623/ has some compelling ideas. I really like the 12.5 ML design that heads that discussion, just conceptually. I may be nuts. Who knows, but that type of thing appeals. If I can pick a driver, and pull together a design that can use regular dimensioned lumber, then I can put together a nice solid-wood cabinet that would look good.
Odd question: Feasible, not bad, to put in a speaker selection switch box? My amplifier does not have a/b speaker select. I'd like to be able to use one amp to drive either set of speakers.
Thanks much for any suggestions and hints.