Yet another Planar Magnetic Line Source, the SMAPPP

So for the full length membranes I need the Silouette Cameo 5 to cut 2440 mm to get a 2200 mm corrugated membrane.
The problem with that is that there's is no control in which order the machine will cut if I just export the design as dxf from Fusion:
MWSnap848 2024-08-15, 13_58_24.jpg

The result is that the membrane goes back and forth while cutting the full length a lot. The chance of failures is very high if not certain.
Thanks to OllBoll I now have the solution.

More to follow.
 
2440 mm divided by 40 gives 61 mm chunks, it'll be tedious to CAD and take a long time to cut but hopefully the yield will be satisfying.

First I draw lines cross over the membrane at every 61 mm using rectangular pattern:
MWSnap854 2024-08-15, 17_11_42.jpg


Then insert a Break at every intersection, this is the tedious part.
MWSnap855 2024-08-15, 17_12_44.jpg


Be sure to select the vertical line and not the horizontal as in below:

MWSnap856 2024-08-15, 17_12_53.jpg


One can see that the line is broken by selecting the lines above and below the break:
MWSnap857 2024-08-15, 17_15_43.jpg
MWSnap858 2024-08-15, 17_15_49.jpg


Compare to the next line which is yet not broken:
MWSnap859 2024-08-15, 17_15_57.jpg

Break the rest of the vertical lines in that row, then remove the horizontal line.
Do this for the other 38 horizontal lines.
 
I found an easier way.
Just do the bottom segment and one more at the top.
Then select the second from the top and copy it using rectangular pattern, done in no time!
MWSnap860 2024-08-15, 20_02_21.jpg


Then I export the design as a dxf-file and import it to Silhouette Studio where I assign every segment to an unique color:
MWSnap862 2024-08-15, 20_11_17.jpg

There must be a better way to do this, why use colors?

I can then in the Send/Line determine the order of the cuts.
MWSnap863 2024-08-15, 20_13_00.jpg


And then hopefully the membrane while cutting only will be moving 61 mm at the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: esl 63
Well, it didn't work as expected. The cutter jumped one segment or two on occasion.

So I added a pause after every segment to force the cutter to cut the segments in sequence.

MWSnap865 2024-08-17, 14_34_09.jpg


It could be good to also use the pause to check the cuts and perhaps clean the knife from time to time.

I also mounted the roll feeder to better align my cutting "mat":

And that worked!

Sadly I had made a couple of mistakes when prepairing the segment; those colors can really confuse you.
So at 1750 mm of perfectly cutting the membrane, the whole mat rolled back to cut the first line that accedentely had gotten the same color as that current segment. The line didn't end up in the right place and the whole membrane lost its alignment.
I also had a constrution line at the end, so I need to redo the whole from the export from Fusion.

But this time I shall use the hex representation of the colors starting at $000001 and adding 1 for each following segment:
MWSnap866 2024-08-17, 23_40_54.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: OllBoll
Some improvements:
Use odd vertical cuts, that way the cutter will not do a fast feed forward when the next segment starts.
I'd to add a dummy cut as the number of vertical traces were even.

Enter the hex color in actual hex number when assighning colors.
MWSnap870 2024-08-21, 14_53_20.jpg


During cutting the decimal number is displayed.
MWSnap869 2024-08-21, 14_52_54.jpg


Remove roller when cutting the final segments.
Otherwise the cutting mat will hit the roller on the way back and ruin the last cuts.

The first 2440 mm long mid membrane was finally successfully cut:
IMG_7848.JPG


The calculated 11.5 ohms was in reality 13.3 ohms.

So unless I take a leap of faith and go wide as OllBoll with 7 mm instead of my 3 mm conductor traces, I'll have to take a mirror of the above membrane and glue it to the other side of the mylar film.
 
If I understood correctly you use very thin aluminum foil, 5-10 micron? What supplier / brand do you use? I'm looking at buying some 6-9 micron foil. I can get 14 micron from Clas Ohlson but I can't seem to find thinner foil. Or at least I can't seem to find foil in that thickness where they list the thickness.
 
I ran into some trouble with the makings of the steel plates, so I've order laser cut plates from Fractory.
They'll arrive in the beginning of next week.

Meanwhile I've done some dispersion measurements on the mini SMAPPP:
IMG_7911.JPG


I've applied some PEQ In the measurements below to mitigate the effects of the Helmholtz' resonance.

Dispersion for Mid at one meter, 0 till 30°:
SMAPPP Mid Dispersion.jpg


Dispersion for Top at one meter, 0 till 30°:
SMAPPP Top Dispersion.jpg

This looks really good!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: OllBoll and esl 63