Bob, there's a world of difference, an enormous gap, between loud music with distortion - and the same, without distortion. Subjectively, one can tolerate, in fact thoroughly enjoy, far more of the latter ... many people probably haven't heard some of the classic rock albums wound up to full volumes and still being reproduced totally cleanly - they are amazing productions to listen to when heard this way, absolutely magic. The normal, mangled 'loud' just doesn't cut it, a dead loss in fact ...
Sorry, that expensive stuff is unlikely to do it - you might be lucky, but most likely you won't be, 😉.
Cheers,
Sorry, that expensive stuff is unlikely to do it - you might be lucky, but most likely you won't be, 😉.
Cheers,
Which is why a good system, playing a live recording of a rock gig, will sound vastly superior to anything anyone heard at the time. The feed will come from the mixing desk, before it's been mangled by the PA amps, and is pretty clean ... because often minimal post fiddling to the mix is done an extremely realistic sound can be heard - the first Peter Green Splinter album is an excellent example of this ...Truely convincing is not live , its impossible for any hi-fi system to sound like a symphony , reasonabliy convincing , yes , but not real. Now a regular PA BAND PERFORMANCE of their favorite rock group , yes ! seeing this is not really live music , what it is , is the over amplification of musicians playing their favorite song, this you can convincingly replicate via Hi-fi, because in the end , that concert is nothing more than a glorified hi-fi playback system.
Just saying ... 🙂
If I get the same emotional kick from hearing the recording as I do with live sound, of say a symphony, then that's convincing enough for me ...
yes exactly, but no way a system can sound exactly like a orchestra, a quartet, ect. No ssytem can be as intense, and dynamic and have the presence of real instruments. sad but true. Hifi is what it is, damn good and damn fun. my system is damn impressive and anybody who hears it is stunt, but its still not a live performance. but who cares, I rather listen to miles and coltrane as good as possible then a live modern quartet but thts another subject.Truely convincing is not live , its impossible for any hi-fi system to sound like a symphony , reasonabliy convincing , yes , but not real. Now a regular PA BAND PERFORMANCE of their favorite rock group , yes ! seeing this is not really live music , what it is , is the over amplification of musicians playing their favorite song, this you can convincingly replicate via Hi-fi, because in the end , that concert is nothing more than a glorified hi-fi playback system.
Just saying ... 🙂
Last edited:
Wrong.No ssytem can be as intense, and dynamic and have the presence of real instruments.
1. Myles and John are dead, so what we have left are their albums to be played on (reproductions).
2. A CD is much less expensive that hiring a live band @ your home. ...Between $500 and $5,000 an hour.
3. Frank, actually Murphy is quite right. ...I didn't want to personally break the bad news to you, sorry.
2. A CD is much less expensive that hiring a live band @ your home. ...Between $500 and $5,000 an hour.
3. Frank, actually Murphy is quite right. ...I didn't want to personally break the bad news to you, sorry.
And you know this, Bob, because you've read it in a book, hmmmm ...? 😉
Mightier than the sword .... 🙂
"Behold the turtle. He makes progress only when he sticks his neck out" - James Bryant Conant ... 🙂
Good music links, thanks for that, a.wayne ... 🙂
You know you've arrived when you can turn the volume up and up, and it never goes sour, never loses its composure - this is when you wish you had more turning room in that volume knob ... 😛
You need a ten turn potentiometer!😀
yes exactly, but no way a system can sound exactly like a orchestra,
I particularly like the girls that play the violins


Last edited:
Mightier than the sword .... 🙂
Bruce Wayne! I knew that you were Spider-man all along!!!!😀

Last edited:
Wrong ... 🙂
+1
I mean, come on. We're still waving bits of paper around with magnets.
Bruce Wayne! I knew that you were Spider-man all along!!!!😀😀 I bet you also like the cello player.
Dont you have a trial to watch ... 😀
+1
I mean, come on. We're still waving bits of paper around with magnets.
Franky waving the smallest bits of paper and magnets you have ever seen.... 🙂
I like the term soundstage and I enjoy a system that presents a good one. The problem isn't with the term but with the fact that some people don't know what it is or confuse it with imaging. I have found the Chesky - Ultimate Demonstration Disc to be one of the best tools for teaching others what to listen for in a sound system. IMO it gives clearly defined audio examples of different audio terms which helps develop a lexicon for explaining what they are experiencing. In this day and age it is one of the only CDs I would tell someone to go and buy if they are interested in audio.
... and then the one with the cello between knees![]()
Brings back pleasant memories of a Lorenna McKennit concert.
dave
Brings back pleasant memories of a Lorenna McKennit concert.
dave
wow, I thought of that sexy carbone cello too 🙄
Dave, don't say yu were there
btw, I have that out door concert recorded on a hard disc, which unfortunately is not in use anymore
McKennit is high class, but what a fantastic back up orchestra
When I listen to her I imagine being in the an English forest with fog and in the presence of druids goblins, dwarfs and scary things. A very unusual voice. She lives in your neck of the woods Planet10 not so?
I like the term soundstage and I enjoy a system that presents a good one. The problem isn't with the term but with the fact that some people don't know what it is or confuse it with imaging. I have found the Chesky - Ultimate Demonstration Disc to be one of the best tools for teaching others what to listen for in a sound system. IMO it gives clearly defined audio examples of different audio terms which helps develop a lexicon for explaining what they are experiencing. In this day and age it is one of the only CDs I would tell someone to go and buy if they are interested in audio.
Just ordered one - Thanks. Maybe I learn something. I find some jargon especially confusing.
Last edited:
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Member Areas
- The Lounge
- Does anyone else hate the term "soundstage" ?