Best midrange to pair with Beyma TPL-150

"...djk has provided a clever rule of thumb for calculating the dispersion for a given driver size at a given frequency - the "1,000,000" rule:

1,000,000 / Cone size in inches / dispersion in degrees = frequency in Hz

..."cone size in inches" refer to the actual cone size of the driver, which is usually a little less than the "formal" size...

For instance, a 10" PHL 3451 mid driver has an actual cone size diameter

How do we know the actual cone size diameter?
 
What about the Satori MW19P-4? At 7.5" it would seem a good directivity match at ~2khz, has very flat FR from 200 up, low distortion and reasonable sensitivity at 91.5...

Sd of 158cm2 is a bit small to match 80 degrees at 2kHz.

Yes sensitivity is a bit low but actively it could work. The MW19P-4 could deliver 117.5dB within Xmax at 200Hz if fed 400W (e.g. Ncore NC400), which should be plenty. IEC power rating is only 70W but I'd be surprised if the VC couldn't take short bursts of 400W.
 
88 db sensivity.... ! In a horn ?

a 8" (8pe21 from B&C) or a 6" (?) with this H6000, RCF below the TPLH150 ? For instance a good enough PHL Audio ?

It seems it is possible if asked gently to RCF with a grup buy to make it builded again but I don' know the minimum quantity !

Same problem with any 8 pro : no bass. Real bass with small 6-8 mid woofer => low eff drivers. Miracles => Lourdes😀
 
What about the Satori MW19P-4? At 7.5" it would seem a good directivity match at ~2khz, has very flat FR from 200 up, low distortion and reasonable sensitivity at 91.5...

An LR4 crossover at 1700Hz between the Satori MW19P-4 midbass and Satori TW29R tweeter provides good attenuation of the MW19P cone breakup, and also a smooth polar transfer to the 1.1" TW29R dome. The MW19P just starts to beam ~1700Hz, so the tweeter baffle placement will control high freq 2-PI to 4-PI transistion.

Decisions on baffle shape will also shape the soundstage. A narrow front baffle with large(3") radius edge treatment can smooth the upper midrange, but also put greater demands on the woofers. A wider baffle will "drive" more midrange sound to the listener and less into the room, plus support a sharper and lower frequency transfer point to the woofers.

The factory SPL measurements for the MW19P and MW16P both look like excellent midbass candidates.
 

Attachments

  • Kronos Klone 2xSB23  MW19 TW29R.jpg
    Kronos Klone 2xSB23 MW19 TW29R.jpg
    96.9 KB · Views: 673
  • MW16__MW19_SPL.jpg
    MW16__MW19_SPL.jpg
    117.6 KB · Views: 666
Kronos Klone Cabinet with Beyma TPL-150S(no-horn) and Satori MW19P-4. LR4 at 1700Hz shown. LR4 at 1800Hz should have acceptable polar match.

High cost of TPL-150S seems to demand much higher efficiency midbass.
 

Attachments

  • Kronos Tpl150s MW19P.jpg
    Kronos Tpl150s MW19P.jpg
    101 KB · Views: 664
Does anybody know which 8" midrange driver Legacy is using in their Aeris speakers?

"a titanium encrusted 8” midrange with an enormous motor structure imported from Italy... accordion surround.... the smoothest, high efficiency 8” midrange built to date. I have yet to find a driver to challenge it. This silky 8” mid has a range of 7 octaves with nary a wrinkle in the response, yet a sensitivity of 98 dB"

- Bill Dudleston, Chief Designer, Legacy Audio

AERIS-HEADER.png