Hi,
I'm on a journey to improve my system in my living room.. It is reasonably large room with a total volume of 140m3.
Current equipment:
- Receiver: Anthem MRX 520
- Front: Kef LS50
- Sub: 10inch Whaferdale SW 150 (that's the one I want to replace!)
- Back: Kef egg (not using them much)
I'm mostly listening to music but do enjoy a good movie now and then. Not playing loud (wife and kid are limiting the db!). I'm looking to improve the sub to bring a bit more low and presence to the room. The current sub is good for music but I think a bit small to move enough air for the room.
I'm based in New Zealand, and everything (when there's something) is very expensive here. I wanted to go with a SVS SB-1000 pro which cost 1500 NZD (=920USD!!!)
I like woodworking and DIY and have all the tools, so can definitely build my own sub. Problem, we only have car speaker drivers available here and shipping cost and tax duty doesn't make import possible (for a 15 inch, it cost more than 300 USD to ship, + 15% tax)
My aim is to build something better than the SVS-SB1000 with the same budget.
I found 2 potential drivers:
Powered with a Behringer NX3000D, and a box made of plywood (I don't like working with MDF!).
I'm more into bass details rather than power, so was thinking it is better (and easier) to go with a sealed design.
I don't want to go higher than 120 liters for the box.
Below the WinISD results (blue the alpine, red the rockford).
Also attached my oddly shaped living room with potential placement for 2 subwoofers (in red)
The 15 inch is of course the clear winner in term of SPL, and could for sure benefit from a bigger box (I might be able to slightly extend the box and stuff foam inside to gain some volume ....).
And this for the same price than the SVS (I'm not counting my own time involve in the building process, because I do like doing this
🙂 )
Now the questions:
1) Do you see a problem with those results or using those drivers for home use?
2) With the behringer integrated DSP, could I get a flat frequency from 25hz (ideally 20) to 120? is 100db loud enough?
3) Both those driver are around the same price, so I'm wondering if the alpine is better built and would provide a more detail sound? Or is it just, bigger is better, go with the rockford? I'm not looking for power here (my current 10 inch very old SW 150 isn't reaching max power (I think
🙂 )
4) Or should I just go with the SVS-SB1000 because it would provide a better sound?
Thanks for reading and for your advice.
Alex