Slewmaster - CFA vs. VFA "Rumble"

It is frustrating that we don't have access to many of the nice small signal stuff, heck even the power transistors, that both mouser and digikey stock.

I don't know what suitable replacement part numbers are for most of these either. I simply bought a reasonable amount of 992/1845 and 3503/its complement, a few years ago just in case.

The nice thing though is that all the amplifiers either use a cascode or regulation for the main input transistors, this keeps the Vce requirements very low. I am positive that farnell stocks at least one type of low noise, high hfe type input transistor, I just don't know what they are. Or at least they will have something better than the 5551.
 
Ranchu32,
I would think someone could mail you those small transistors fairly easily. What is the postage for a letter size envelope from the US to Aus.?

That would be wonderful but I don't want to put anyone to the trouble...

If someone were to order say 100 pcs (price break) I'd take 20-30 pcs in an envelope and that way should be assured of a decent matches.

I'm guessing that close matched devices is pretty important for this design and any other symmetrical topology.
 
The devices are pretty cheap and could be worked into the cost of a set of boards. I buy the KSA992F and KSC1845F a few hundred at a time and it would be easy to send a strip of ten per board. This sound like a possibility?

Matching is a nicety but not a necessity.
 

Attachments

  • folded leachCM.jpg
    folded leachCM.jpg
    129.6 KB · Views: 458
Last edited:
Hi Guys,

While I'm waiting for Jason to create some more Gerbers for some of these IPS, I have been thinking of utilizing a pair of Symasym boards that I have. I posted the schematic and OS made some suggestions for resistor changes. I just have a couple more questions. Based on the attached schematic, would I need to change Q1 & Q2 to something other than MPSA18 if I am using +-75V rails? What about Q7 & Q8? Will BC546B be OK? Also, are there any resistors that need to be more than 1/4w and if so, which ones?

Thanks, Terry
 

Attachments

  • symasym IPS.jpg
    symasym IPS.jpg
    58.8 KB · Views: 457
Last edited:
Now that the CFA-XH boards have almost reached fruition thanks to the efforts of OS and JK, I have a question about transistor selection.

The SA992/SC1845 are impossible to source locally from RS or Farnell and international shipping is pretty expensive from Mouser and Digikey for these few components. I really don't have much choice in the way of high Vceo small signal transistors apart from the 2n5401/5551.

OS, are you able to simulate the schematic with the 2n5401/5551 and let me know what the performance is like? I'd like to use these parts if possible, but I'm worried that it will significantly compromise performance.

You can buy Mouser product through X-On and they only charge $15.00 for freight in Australia. X-ON Electronics|Buy Online Over 2 Million Parts|Best $|Best Sales Support in Australia
 
That one will work but the specs aren't as good as the devices mentioned.
If you insert the SA/SC transistors backwards the pin out will be correct.

Actually. KSC is ecb. The MPSA is ebc so the leads would have to be twisted. Maybe possible but not the best solution. The only devices I see that have a base lead in the center and are at least 80V are the MPSA06/42/8099 and the BC546. Not sure if any of these will work.

Thanks, Terry
 
Would you remove the input filter (remove C) then measure the bandwidth? I want to know the bandwidth (small signal) of your CFA with 1K/33 feedback resistors.
Hi bimo i have tried this already but i can't see any difference.
I did this test for VSSA (PMI VER.)also. -3db for this VSSA =640KHZ.(10vRMS Out/4R).
If you interesting for bandwidth(small signal)i must repeat all these.
Thimios.
 
Last edited: