P3A Comparison table ( long .... )

Attachments

  • P9160030-1.JPG
    P9160030-1.JPG
    595.8 KB · Views: 803
All Genuine here!

Hi Folks,

Yes, they are original PCB's purchased from the Rodd Elliot web site. I have split them because at a later point in time I'm hoping to go dual mono by adding a second transformer, rectifiers and capacitance.
And yes, I have also trimmed the top of the PCB's as I want to mount them close to the heatsinks with the outputs standing up.

Hope I havent done anything wrong! 😱

Kind Regards
Roy.

P.S.
Hi Mr Sakis, - No, I dont party every night - but I do like realistic listening levels 😀

Hi Mr Thimios, - The cap you highlighted on my PCB is a PSU decoupling cap which is shared between the two boards. So with splitting them I will be placing a +ve and -ve decoupling cap to each PCB where the fuses go. The fuses will be off board.
 
Last edited:
Hi Folks,

Yes, they are original PCB's purchased from the Rodd Elliot web site. I have split them because at a later point in time I'm hoping to go dual mono by adding a second transformer, rectifiers and capacitance.
And yes, I have also trimmed the top of the PCB's as I want to mount them close to the heatsinks with the outputs standing up.

Hope I havent done anything wrong! 😱

Kind Regards
Roy.

P.S.
Hi Mr Sakis, - No, I dont party every night - but I do like realistic listening levels 😀

Hi Mr Thimios, - The cap you highlighted on my PCB is a PSU decoupling cap which is shared between the two boards. So with splitting them I will be placing a +ve and -ve decoupling cap to each PCB where the fuses go. The fuses will be off board.

Yes i believe that the right way isn't cutting the board because this piece of board is useful for heat sensing from out transistors to Vbe multiplier
 
The heat sensor om a P3A is to the driver transistors. NOT to the PCB !
Absolutely. This isn't an EF (emitter follower) output stage amplifier - it's a CFP design and the most appropriate temperature range for bias control is sensed at the driver stage. Note how close Q9 and Q6 are located. That is all the coupling you need with Rod's ESP board, just like it was designed. 🙂
As this is Rod's IP and he has requested we don't show product details, visit the site and see details: 60-80W Power Amplifier
 
Nikos, you can post results of your P3A build and as many pictures of your own build as you want but you can't then go on to produce and offer those boards for sale.

Once you associate your boards specifically to the P3A (which by inference is what posting in this thread does) then that is infringement of Rods work.
 
Hi All,

Here's some more pictures showing my progress. Not the prettiest of builds I'm sure but hopefully okay. Boards are complete now apart from the outputs and I am ready to build it all into the case. Trouble is, I'm not really sure about how to lay it all out. I was thinking about making it dual mono once I knew it worked okay. But now I'm wondering if having two transformers would really make that much difference. Could I have just have one tx feeding two sets of rectifiers and capacitor banks (one for each board)?

Any way I'd be grateful if you could have a look over my boards and let me know if there's anything amiss.

Also, does it seem okay the way its laid out, or is there a better way?

Thanks all
Kind Regards
Roy
 

Attachments

  • PA050010.jpg
    PA050010.jpg
    994.7 KB · Views: 655
  • PA050011.jpg
    PA050011.jpg
    901.2 KB · Views: 604
  • PA050012.jpg
    PA050012.jpg
    821.8 KB · Views: 567
  • PA050007.jpg
    PA050007.jpg
    827.9 KB · Views: 543
  • PA050014.jpg
    PA050014.jpg
    702.3 KB · Views: 494
  • PA050015.jpg
    PA050015.jpg
    730.4 KB · Views: 268