John Curl's Blowtorch preamplifier part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
You just play the same tune, Richard said, not only ones, there was no oscillation.

Maybe, but amplifiers bursting in oscillations and self destructing under difficult loads is unfortunately a very old and familiar tune.

With all due respect, Richard doesn’t have the foggiest idea what he is talking about, as long as he suggested replacing the vertical mosfets with lateral mosfets, just like that.
 
A better method is to isolate the AC and DC feedback paths, virtually unknown in the audio world. The DC feedback resistance goes from the output to the inverting input. This value should match the resistance from the non-inverting input to ground used to establish a 0 volt reference. These resistors can usually be a high value such as 100,000 ohms although it is useful to match the input offset current and voltage as before.

Ed, that's discussed in Cordell's book. Figure 10.3 (p.221) of the 2nd edition.
 
When correcting a 70 Volt OPS input signal, the correction signal will effectively be in the sub Volt region and should hover around this 70 Volt to correct the input signal.
Suppose input signal is 70 Volt at a certain moment and should be error corrected to 70.5 Volt. This will not be possible with your opamp circuit.
Napoleon said a little schematic says more than thousands words.
Just the idea. No free lunch, of course, but nothing impossible with a spirit of sacrifice ;-).
 

Attachments

  • ops-err-corr.asc
    ops-err-corr.asc
    1.3 KB · Views: 57
  • xxxx.jpg
    xxxx.jpg
    113.5 KB · Views: 217
Last edited:
If you search for the Putzeys designed 30W (balanced) class A amp, (Extreme A from memory?) , it had a pretty cool OP stage with local FB
loop current driving the emitters of a pair of 'backward' bjts.

Nothing turns up (any link?), but this reminds me of the emitter driven EC proposed by Barry Blesser circa 1972. He only had NPN's at his disposal at the time but with both flavors I drew a little family chart that led to an interesting EC scheme. Jcx pointed out that this was in a Pass Labs patent years later reinforcing the thought that nothing is new.
 
Nothing turns up (any link?), but this reminds me of the emitter driven EC proposed by Barry Blesser circa 1972. He only had NPN's at his disposal at the time but with both flavors I drew a little family chart that led to an interesting EC scheme. Jcx pointed out that this was in a Pass Labs patent years later reinforcing the thought that nothing is new.

Might have been some revisions, but here was the original article IIRC.

ExtremA, a reference class-A DIY amplifier. - Copyrights, Updates etc.
 
Napoleon said a little schematic says more than thousands words.
Just the idea. No free lunch, of course, but nothing impossible with a spirit of sacrifice ;-).

Just make a complete working circuit in LTSpice , with resistors, opamps, a voltage source injecting the distortion and your suggested error correction, all as close as possible to a real situation.

You are attenuating the input signal of the OPS by 10%, it might work that way.
First try to find out what the simulation tells.

Hans
 
You are attenuating the input signal of the OPS by 10%
These are Christmas sales.
As I told, there is no free lunch. You will told me too than an OPA do not have 0 Ohm of output impedance etc.
Just make a complete working circuit in LTSpice , with resistors, opamps, a voltage source injecting the distortion and your suggested error correction, all as close as possible to a real situation.
Not my way to work.
I have several ideas about the "mix" stage. Don't make the mistake of SYN08 to confuse a charcoal and the final painting exhibited at the Guggenheim museum ;-)
 
0.7uH should be OK, just 1-3uH or more that I worry about.

Might be that higher output L drops the resonant frequency of the load C and that may be audible to some but I have not done enough work on the audibility side to have an opinion either way. I do know when you sim it, or look at it in practice, there’s a lot of ringing going on so high L should be avoided. I’ve seen designs with 5uH.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.