DIY optical cartridge preamp

Jump to Latest
H

Hans Polak

Member
Joined 2005
tonyEE said:
The derivative of velocity is acceleration.

Did you mean to write the integral of velocity? Optical cartridges are displacement ( distance ) driven, huh?

++

So, optical cartridges, being displacement driven, should be linear. Except for how the signal was encoded.

Does RIAA encoding take the non linear behavior of magnetic cartridges into account, Amplitude = F( f, input_amplitude ). or are they are based on just simple frequency manipulation? Ie: amplitude vs frequency. Amplitude = F( f )

I figure that magnetic cartridges exhibit amplitude compression whereas optical cartidges do not.
Click to expand...
In #44 Mikey already corrected my reversal.

Both principles can lead to excellent linear transfer properties, but also face the same mechanical limitations like tip mass that will be equal between both and the forthcoming effect of indentation of the elastic vinyl by this mass, usualy causing some form of a slight dip around 10Khz, dependant on tip mass and damping of the cantilever’s suspension amongst others.

But apart from those mechanical issues the principle of a magnetic cartridge is not a hair worse than that of an optical cart, but an optical cart has to cope with LP’s optimised for this velocity driven principle, meaning that at the high end of the spectrum velocity is still high but displacement is very small.
That results is a worse S/N for the optical cart.

My Benz LP is specified as +/-0.5 dB up to 50Khz, and although I have no LP to test this, I could succesfully confirm this up to 40Khz with the Ortofon test disk.
And yes, there was also the mentioned small dip in the FR at around 10Khz of 0.5 dB.
Apart from the fact that nobody needs 40 Khz, I won’t see any optical disk ever match this performance on a LP made for velocity driven carts.

That’s why the suggested higher transparency for an optical cart seems to me like being more the product of a highly optimized preamp.

But then again there is more between heaven and earth than just Frequency Responses to determine the perceived sound. Every high end MC sounds a bit different although their FR’s are identical, just like cables, amps and whatever in the audio chain also have this ungrippable property.
So who knows, maybe some day I may convert to optics :ROFLMAO:

Hans
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
H

Hans Polak

Member
Joined 2005
There is still one thing that might be in favour of an optical cart.
Every cart has a resonance frequency fr around 10Hz.
This resonance causes FM modulation of the audio frequencies causing sidebands.
Take A*Sin(wt) for this resonance frequency, which directly describes the displacement of the optical cart.
The velocity will then be Aw*(coswt), so the velocity will be higher by w (which is 2pi*f).

So the FM sidebands with an optical cart will be at a lower level but only when the audio output is on the the same level as a magnetic cart, which is very frequency dependant.
So there must be a crossover point somewhere where below the optics will be better and above the magnetic cart will be better.

To get a feeling for where this crossover point might be, a first proof of the pudding is to record a 1 khz@0dB test tone, make a FFT of it with 1Hz bin width and find the level of the fr caused FM sidebands.

So, Mark could you volunteer ?

Hans
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
M

Markw4

Member
Joined 2016
Hans Polak said:
So, Mark could you volunteer ?
Click to expand...
Hi Hans,
I have a Hi-Fi News test record around here somewhere, along with one other test record. I'm sure there is a 1kHz test track on one of them. That said, I'm not so sure that one or a few measurements would tell you nearly as much as a listen. There is probably more to the sound difference between magnetic and optical than simple measurements are going to fully capture. I trust anyone with a decent optical system can tell about their experience with the difference. And I would not assume they are hallucinating.

In the meantime, I am in the midst of listening tests on a new DSD dac. Its keeping me pretty busy for a few days as there are some different variations to compare. Then I have boards coming in from JLCPCB that I have to get to work stuffing. How soon do you need this?
 
D

dennis h

Member
Joined 2006
Markw4 said:
I have it from a hi end audio consultant with some of the best magnetic carts in his collection. He doesn't listen to magnetic anymore. He will still help people who want them though.

Currently using a DS W3 myself that I paid fully for, just said in the interests of disclosure. Using a custom discrete preamp not from DS, also said in the interests of disclosure.
Click to expand...
Which custom discrete preamp if I may ask ?
 
H

Hans Polak

Member
Joined 2005
Markw4 said:
Hi Hans,
I have a Hi-Fi News test record around here somewhere, along with one other test record. I'm sure there is a 1kHz test track on one of them. That said, I'm not so sure that one or a few measurements would tell you nearly as much as a listen. There is probably more to the sound difference between magnetic and optical than simple measurements are going to fully capture. I trust anyone with a decent optical system can tell about their experience with the difference. And I would not assume they are hallucinating.

In the meantime, I am in the midst of listening tests on a new DSD dac. Its keeping me pretty busy for a few days as there are some different variations to compare. Then I have boards coming in from JLCPCB that I have to get to work stuffing. How soon do you need this?
Click to expand...
Hi Mark

I’m not in any hurry.
And yes, FM modulation could only tell a part but not the whole story.
Nevertheless, the less the better, it’s not exactly improving perceived sound.

Hans
 
2A3SET

2A3SET

Member
Joined 2003
Separated the ground wiring to power and signal at cartridge clip side, good result and will keep this setup.

1711382822386.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
M

mikey_audiogeek

Member
Joined 2004
mikey_audiogeek said:
Yes the 5.6VDC lamp voltage supply is for the KE-9021 cartridge lamp in the cartridge. I haven't traced the circuit for the pilot light on the preamp, but it may be 100V AC. On my preamp the bulb appears to be open circuit.
I did not measure the pilot light voltage, it works without it...
The cartridge was connected when making voltage measurements. I will post further findings when I get time.

I found a cold solder joint which may be the cause of the hum in the left channel. Next I will power the circuit from a 6VDC battery with a dropper diode and measure current.

By the way, congrats on your cartridge purchase. Is it the one I saw on Yahoo Japan in the last month?
Click to expand...
Hum was still present after resoldering. Next step is to try a battery supply. I suspect that separating the grounds will help here also.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom