An Under-Appreciated Cabinet Material

...giving it high Q high frequency resonant modes. Ok for subs but could prove hard to damp in the midrange.

While general consensus is that highQ is bad, consider that if it is at high enuff frequency and high enuff Q, the liklihood of music providing sufficient continuous input into such a narrow band at such a high frequency is VERY unlikely.

350px-Bandwidth2.png


Toole also shows that if the Q of the resonance is higher, and it is excited, it is less likly noticed.

Damping these potential resonance is counterproductive in my estimate.

A quote from hifijim that is relevant/
The reason the high stiffness approach works is two-fold: (1) the vibration forcing function is music or movie soundtrack... which contains lots of transients. The frequency range of music that contains continuous high energy is approximately 50 Hz to 500 Hz. Above that range, the energy comes in short bursts. (2) second reason high stiffness works... At higher frequencies, all structures have increasing self damping. Plywood, MDF, and most other common materials have a lot more damping at 1 kHz than they do at 100 Hz. Same is true for glues and adhesives.

dave
 
  • Like
Reactions: Juhazi and MrKlinky
Over the years I’ve had access to some exotic composite panels, yet never considered them for speaker cabinets since more common materials can perform very well.

I had seen audiophile products that did just that, but figured it was to help justify a higher price, and appearance/bragging rights for the owners.