Slewmaster - CFA vs. VFA "Rumble"

SymaSym, my first favorite amp build. Watching with interest.

Ahhh , there you are ...

Yes , I did a symasym variant as one of my firsts , as well.

They do well , but don't clip gracefully and shunt HF as compensation.
About 1-200ppm THD is what a typical symasym outputs.

This one is different ,
It uses a blue and red led to reference both the CCS and the VAS's
cascode. (D5/D3/R16) Simple , it also negates tempco and CM distortion.

The LTP is common fare with a more precise offset adjustment (Q1/2 +
R7-11).

The Wilson Cascoded VAS is the winning ticket. Q4/5 + Q9/10 can be
small low voltage (cheep !!) to-92's.
The "wilson" part of the Mirror (Q6) does all the work (acts as a cascode).
On the active side , Q7/8 (another cascode) do the "heavy lifting",
and are a good match for Q6 (A high-Z cascode).

All this is compensated with the Sansui lead/lag/miller "array" (C5/6/7)
C7 sets the pole , C5/6 "tweaks" phase for real good stability margin.


Driving a EF3 with this ... it does 11ppm 1/2 power and only 33 full throttle.
(below 2) .... clipping has only the most minor saturation and is
symmetric within 200mV. (below 3)

WAY better , by far than the original ... and able to leap tall buildings
in a single waveform :D ( 125V p-p with 70V rails ).

OS
 

Attachments

  • symasui-1.jpg
    symasui-1.jpg
    104.1 KB · Views: 807
  • symasui-THD20.jpg
    symasui-THD20.jpg
    97 KB · Views: 766
  • symasui-clip.jpg
    symasui-clip.jpg
    48.5 KB · Views: 698
Last edited:
I see, not really a symasym at all. Funny that folks pick that amp apart when it sounds so good.

No !! The VAS has the same "temperment". Except that it can really
fly. FFT wise ... it also resembles the SYM - but with much less THD.

If you "partied" with it , and drove it ever closer to those rails ....
It DOES (exactly)match the SYM (harmonic wise). At the rails , it just
behaves itself while you overdrive it.

os
 
Thanks OS but i can't understand this"THEN ..... "trim" vas I by bleeding X amount of that current away by using
33-56K at hawksford LED string (R20)."
Do you mean to play with values R19 R20 FROM 33K UP TO 56K?
Or you mean R18?

I mean the resistor that goes between the hawksford leds. R18 or
R20 could be different from my simulator schema > ips schema.

the hawksford led I is usually 3ma , this is shared current from
the cascode Re's (150R) ... If you get a little more than 8ma at those
R's , increase the LED current to "bleed" more away from the
cascodes. 4.5 - 5ma is what the cascode collectors should see.

OS
 
Ok i understand this .
Thanks, this is job for tomorrow.
Now i have the rest of test.
Clipping at 20KHz
1)Inp.=950mV RMS
5)Inp=1.5V RMS
6-7)inp. signal down,out signal up(20KHz)
8) same as pict 6-7 two signals superimposed.
9)30KHz
10)30 KHz signals superimposed

to be continued..
 

Attachments

  • DSC07520.JPG
    DSC07520.JPG
    585.3 KB · Views: 136
  • DSC07519.JPG
    DSC07519.JPG
    524 KB · Views: 132
  • DSC07518.JPG
    DSC07518.JPG
    594 KB · Views: 133
  • DSC07517.JPG
    DSC07517.JPG
    547.9 KB · Views: 144
  • DSC07516.JPG
    DSC07516.JPG
    571.6 KB · Views: 137
  • DSC07515.JPG
    DSC07515.JPG
    514.4 KB · Views: 144
  • DSC07514.JPG
    DSC07514.JPG
    515.1 KB · Views: 140
  • DSC07513.JPG
    DSC07513.JPG
    596.5 KB · Views: 141
  • DSC07512.JPG
    DSC07512.JPG
    615.4 KB · Views: 603
  • DSC07509.JPG
    DSC07509.JPG
    533.6 KB · Views: 655
Last edited:
the rest
1)40KHz
2)40KHz superimposed
3)60KHz
4)80KHz
-3db at 2,7 HZ DOWN(Tested at 14v RMS)
-3db at 200KHz UP(Tested at 14v RMS)
 

Attachments

  • DSC07525.JPG
    DSC07525.JPG
    618.9 KB · Views: 151
  • DSC07523.JPG
    DSC07523.JPG
    611.9 KB · Views: 137
  • DSC07522.JPG
    DSC07522.JPG
    541.3 KB · Views: 138
  • DSC07521.JPG
    DSC07521.JPG
    591.6 KB · Views: 152
Last edited:
Looks like OEM reliability + Superior DIY performance.
Excellent. :) :cool:

OS
Thanks OS. This looks Excellent ,congratulations!:)
Yes ,amplifier tested at 16V RMS OUT. which is stable from 3Hz up to 200KHz. At 2,7 Hz this Vout =11,312V .At 200KHz this Vout=11,312V
(16*0,707=11,312)
Tomorrow i will try these recommended modifications on VAS.
Best Regards.
Thimios.
 
Last edited:
Thanks OS. This looks Excellent ,congratulations!:)
Yes ,amplifier tested at 16V RMS OUT. which is stable from 3Hz up to 200KHz. At 2,7 Hz this Vout =11,312V .At 200KHz this Vout=11,312V
(16*0,707=11,312)
Tomorrow i will try these recommended modifications on VAS.
Best Regards.
Thimios.


LT is right on ... 28.5db gain / 2.5hz to 190+Khz (-3db).
PS- drops like a rock at <.5hz-1hz (servo is R/C .2hz )...
OS
 

Attachments

  • NAD-S-BW.jpg
    NAD-S-BW.jpg
    73.8 KB · Views: 657
Last edited:
OS,
How fast an oscilloscope are you having to use to test these circuits? What would be a practical range to use on these and other audio circuits?

I use A/D PC based setup ..no analog scope (only 10 mhz).

I only use it sparingly , as with good models ... my sims reflect the real world
nearly perfectly (thimios's scope mirrors my LT spice EXACTLY).

On to the new shat...


Almost done with the symasui .. (below)

kept it small at 76.2 X76.2mm ..

I would suggest to build this .... it "flies".


so simple , yet can do that 125v p-p with the grace of
a 2000$ amp .... :cool: I would prefer this over a badger/
wolverine...

OS
 

Attachments

  • survivorpcb.JPG
    survivorpcb.JPG
    248.8 KB · Views: 624