I listen only to classical music and opera, and am looking at taking the next step up in speaker performance.
After trying a full range driver approach and realizing that they are not very good for classical music, I moved up to a pair of 2-ways with Jeff Bagby's Piccolos. That was a major improvement over the full range and now I'm finally enjoying the music. However, as good as the Piccolos are, they still don't give me quite the "big" sound that I am looking for with classical symphonies.
So now I'm researching the next step up, and believe that it has to be at least a 2.5 or 3-way. Troels Graveson has two new open SBA Satori designs that particularly interest me.
SBA-761
SBA-741
The SBA 761 is a 2.5 way and the SBA 741 is a full 3-way. Both use the TW29RN-B-4 for the tweeter and the MW19P-8 for the woofer. The difference is in the midrange and the cabinet design. The SBA 741 uses a 4" MR13P-8 for the midrange while the SBA 761 relies on the 6" MW16P-8 for that purpose.
I'm not going to ask which one is better, because that probably can't be answered. What I want to know, however, is what differences to expect in the sound.
Troels discusses the main differences on his website as follows:
With the 761 he says that by mating the MW16 and MW19, the latter gives quite a lot extra power in the lower registers. The combined membrane area is 277 cm^2. And that pays off in not only bass, but also upper-bass and lower midrange, which is a very important frequency range giving volume to grand piano and the cello.
The 741, on the other hand, uses a 4" driver for the midrange, which is much better at handling the upper midrange and lower treble compared to any 6 or 7" driver. The lower treble range he specifies to be ~800-1300 Hz while treble starts at 1280 Hz.
He adds that it comes as a surprise to some that 6" drivers are very often used to handle the treble, although it is very common in 2-way configurations in order to keep the cost down. However, this in a way contradicts the idea of the 761, essentially diminishing its value as an alternative to the 741.
What I am particularly interested in is any difference in the way the two will handle a sudden sharp string attack. When I listen to classical music and there is a sudden attack by the violins, for example, I want to hear a very, very sharp "kzing" and not a dull mushy "zuhm". This might have a lot to do with transient response and the cabinet themselves, so it may be difficult to predict.
Finally, I have two questions.
Which of these, the 741 or the 761, do you think will give me the better "kzing" on sharp violin attacks?
If you listen a lot to classical music, which would you choose? The 741 or the 761.
Thanks.