Hi,
would a series resistor after R4 junction feeding T1 emitter add a bit of current limiting in event of mishap?
would a series resistor after R4 junction feeding T1 emitter add a bit of current limiting in event of mishap?
What are R3&R19 for? Isn't that a problem under transient conditions? They dominate the loop under turn on/off conditions.
I ment both, both trimpot and 4 resistors. The extra trim resistors can be on top of the trimpot if it's necessary to save space. Trimpot _or_ triming resistors.BobEllis said:I like the tripot idea.
Question for buyers: Do we want a trimpot in the parts kit or just a resistor that will give very close to 15V?
May I suggest soldering a resistor on the bottom side if extra trimming is needed 😉
No point making a big problem out of nothing - IMHO
\Jens
No point making a big problem out of nothing - IMHO
\Jens
Jens, you haven't commented this. Should the emitters of the differential pair be fed with a stiff current source and certainly not be decoupled?peranders said:C13, C15 why? Don't you loose feedback in high frequences?

Jens, not a big problem really but I try to when it's possible to add optional parts because I don't like parts pacthed in here and there. Compare the work to fit in a LM431 if you thought of a LM329 in the first place. It's better to make a 4 pin part so both types will fit or simply have two footprints, one for the LM431 (and similar) and one for LM329 (or similar).JensRasmussen said:May I suggest soldering a resistor on the bottom side if extra trimming is needed 😉
No point making a big problem out of nothing - IMHO
\Jens
The 431 is out of the question as the voltage divider needed for low voltage references will raise the output impedance a lot (lower loop gain) I prefer the 10V LM4040 as this allows for a voltage divider with more gain compared to the 431 (2.5V) divider
The capacitor in parallel with the emitter resistor has been removed as I found it was not needed for stability. For practical reasons I have left it out as the cap needed to actually do any difference was so big (>100uF) that I chose not to bother
Initially I wanted it to be there as a gain reducer at high frequencies…. I found it to be not needed and removed it.
\Jens
The capacitor in parallel with the emitter resistor has been removed as I found it was not needed for stability. For practical reasons I have left it out as the cap needed to actually do any difference was so big (>100uF) that I chose not to bother
Initially I wanted it to be there as a gain reducer at high frequencies…. I found it to be not needed and removed it.
\Jens
Really? You set the reference voltage at the value you like (from 2.5 volts up to 35V) and set the gain according to taste.JensRasmussen said:The 431 is out of the question as the voltage divider needed for low voltage references will raise the output impedance a lot (lower loop gain)
I think it is more like removing feedback at higher frequencies.JensRasmussen said:The capacitor in parallel with the emitter resistor has been removed as I found it was not needed for stability. Initially I wanted it to be there as a gain reducer at high frequencies…. I found it to be not needed and removed it.[/B]
peranders said:You set the reference voltage at the value you like (from 2.5 volts up to 35V) and set the gain according to taste.
Without the need for extra parts?
\Jens
May I suggest to ask the other people that have signed up on the wiki what they would like and let the forum decide.
I'll wait for a reply from the people that have expressed their interest.
\Jens
I'll wait for a reply from the people that have expressed their interest.
\Jens
Based on the preliminary schematic, here is a BOM. At current interest, the 15V parts kit for the board (both positive and negative regulators) will cost $16 without a trimpot. Using Bournes 3296Y multi-turn pots would add about $3.62/kit
For 12V use you could add a 100K trimpot and just dial down the voltage or swap R11 and R13
I just put parts in the order that they caught my eye, sorry.
D7,9______________________________LM4040-10___National
D1,2,3,4,5,6,11,12,13,14,15,16_________1N4004_____Diodes, inc
C4,5,31,32_________________________680uf/35v___Panasonic FC
C10,12,22,24_______________________470uf/25V___Panasonic FC
C6,7,11,13,16,19,22,24_______________1uf_________EPCOS
C1,2,3,8,9,14,17,18,20,21,26,29,30,34___100nf polyester film___EPCOS
C7,28_____________________________220nf polyester film_________EPCOS
R2,7,16,18_________________________10K_________Panasonic 1%
R3,4,5,19,20,21_____________________1K__________Panasonic 1%
R11,13____________________________2K__________Panasonic 1%
R6,10,12,17________________________330_________Panasonic 1%
R9,14_____________________________100_________Panasonic 1%
R8,15_____________________________22K_________Panasonic 1%
R23,24____________________________680*________Panasonic 1%
T1________________________________MJE15033G___OnSemi
T8________________________________MJE15032G___OnSemi
R1,22_____________________________1R 2W________Vishay BC
LED1,2____________________________LTL2T3TBK4 (blue)___Lite-On
T2,5,6_____________________________BC556C______Fairchild
T3,4,7_____________________________BC546C______Fairchild
* R24 and R24 are chosen to give ~15 mA LED current and keep their dissipation down to .15W. I don't care for full brighness of the LED (~400 mcd) and if you drop the resistor to 400R to get full brighness you need a 1/2W resistor, since the dissipation will be .3W. Space is a bit too tight for a 1/2 W resistor. Comments?
Also, the LM4040-10 is the 1% version. For $.75 more per kit, why use a 5% zener? Comments welcome again.
Trimpots in the kit?
Any comments on parts selection?
For 12V use you could add a 100K trimpot and just dial down the voltage or swap R11 and R13
I just put parts in the order that they caught my eye, sorry.
D7,9______________________________LM4040-10___National
D1,2,3,4,5,6,11,12,13,14,15,16_________1N4004_____Diodes, inc
C4,5,31,32_________________________680uf/35v___Panasonic FC
C10,12,22,24_______________________470uf/25V___Panasonic FC
C6,7,11,13,16,19,22,24_______________1uf_________EPCOS
C1,2,3,8,9,14,17,18,20,21,26,29,30,34___100nf polyester film___EPCOS
C7,28_____________________________220nf polyester film_________EPCOS
R2,7,16,18_________________________10K_________Panasonic 1%
R3,4,5,19,20,21_____________________1K__________Panasonic 1%
R11,13____________________________2K__________Panasonic 1%
R6,10,12,17________________________330_________Panasonic 1%
R9,14_____________________________100_________Panasonic 1%
R8,15_____________________________22K_________Panasonic 1%
R23,24____________________________680*________Panasonic 1%
T1________________________________MJE15033G___OnSemi
T8________________________________MJE15032G___OnSemi
R1,22_____________________________1R 2W________Vishay BC
LED1,2____________________________LTL2T3TBK4 (blue)___Lite-On
T2,5,6_____________________________BC556C______Fairchild
T3,4,7_____________________________BC546C______Fairchild
* R24 and R24 are chosen to give ~15 mA LED current and keep their dissipation down to .15W. I don't care for full brighness of the LED (~400 mcd) and if you drop the resistor to 400R to get full brighness you need a 1/2W resistor, since the dissipation will be .3W. Space is a bit too tight for a 1/2 W resistor. Comments?
Also, the LM4040-10 is the 1% version. For $.75 more per kit, why use a 5% zener? Comments welcome again.
Trimpots in the kit?
Any comments on parts selection?
I personally would like trimpots in the kit. Seeing the total price of the kit ,i signed up for two kits in the wiki.
Great job.
kro5998.
Great job.
kro5998.
No problem Jens. It is a lot easier to delete line items than add, which isn't a big deal, either.
If there is a great divide between trimpot/ no trimpot, I might offer option of with/without. Please let me know your preference here.
If there is a great divide between trimpot/ no trimpot, I might offer option of with/without. Please let me know your preference here.
JensRasmussen said:May I suggest to ask the other people that have signed up on the wiki what they would like and let the forum decide.
I'll wait for a reply from the people that have expressed their interest.
\Jens
I thought the output voltage was Vref*gain(R5+R11/R11)?
If Vref = 2.5v, R5= 5K and R11=1K that should be 15v right?
Or am I missing something?
BobEllis said:The LM4040-10 is a 10 volt reference.
I know, I was thinking about the TL431
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Group Buys
- Scalable PSU/regulator GB