Plethora of Pinjatas / SET P amp(s)

Many have done that, I think flochinni on XA 252? He used an Erse coil that Mr Pass had recommended. Alas, no longer available.

What a good replacement? I think it was flochinni who did that and IIRC used 4 HA boards with coil between them?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plott
Unfortunately, my winder Guy is not willing to send outa Country; I asked, thinking about you Boyz in Europe

see Hammonds or maybe local winders



Zen Mod 1_1.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: twitchie
For CLC I don't think 4.7mH is the critical value.

To quote MZM from another thread: "take choke between 4mH and 10mH, no more than 0R33 of Rdc, toss it in place of R in your CRC"

DCR is very important, current handling is important.

Have you had the chance to play around in PSU II and model CRC vs CLC, cap sizes, etc? Download PSU II here: https://www.duncanamps.com/psud2/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plott and Russellc
Here are 2 quick & dirty PSU II examples showing CRC and CLC for one rail at constant 1.7A constant current (Class A amp).

The CRC is assuming 0R11 (figure parallel 0R33 x3), and CLC is using the Hammond 159ZJ at 10mH / 0R16 DCR.

The absolute voltage value is off, and that's OK. We know you'll end up in the 22-23V range. The donut resistance is a guess, but close enough for this exercise.

The key thing I look for is the ripple at C2 or I1, and that's shown in the "Diff" column. Compare CRC at 69mV vs CLC 1.7mV ripple. Those numbers give you a relative idea of the difference between the R & L. You can play around with different values to see the relative impact of your choices. Does it make sense to spend more on bigger / more caps? Different choke? CRCRC? CLCRC? CRCLC? What is the right bang for buck ratio for your amp AND your wallet? This tool lets you play with those scenarios and make the decision.

1746458894641.png

1746458978941.png
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Plott
Here are 2 quick & dirty PSU II examples showing CRC and CLC for one rail at constant 1.7A constant current (Class A amp).

The CRC is assuming 0R11 (figure parallel 0R33 x3), and CLC is using the Hammond 159ZJ at 10mH / 0R16 DCR.

The absolute voltage value is off, and that's OK. We know you'll end up in the 22-23V range. The donut resistance is a guess, but close enough for this exercise.

The key thing I look for is the ripple at C2 or I1, and that's shown in the "Diff" column. Compare CRC at 69mV vs CLC 1.7mV ripple. Those numbers give you a relative idea of the difference between the R & L. You can play around with different values to see the relative impact of your choices. Does it make sense to spend more on bigger / more caps? Different choke? CRCRC? CLCRC? CRCLC? What is the right bang for buck ratio for your amp AND your wallet? This tool lets you play with those scenarios and make the decision.

View attachment 1457182
View attachment 1457185
Many thanks Randy, great tool, will play with it.