PCB or not PCB, this is a problem

Yes, open mid/tweeter, ported woofer.
IMG_3914.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeffrowland
Widen your tracks as much as possible. Also, make the pads for the mounting holes as large as practical; the components are physically large, and this will add reliability to the mounting. For the caps, consider putting a pair of holes at 90 degrees to the axis of the cap to feed a tie wrap through. Be careful running tracks under air core inductors—consider the direction of the fields and whether you will be coupling to other components.
I would recommend a terminal strip with screws to connect your offboard wires. It will make it much easier when you have to take it out. Phoenix and Cinch make good ones. Most board manufacturers start the process with a dual-sided board, even if you order a single-sided one. (They etch off one side entirely!) If you have two sides of copper, use them! A simple trick I have used in high-current boards is creating duplicate, parallel tracks on top and bottom, cutting the track resistance in half.
 
now the tracks are at 0.3mm but I widen them to 1mm and the connectors are no longer visible.
this is the updated version with the correct dimensions to fit everything. I could optimize the spaces further and maybe insert the L2 between the capacitor and the L1.

1742911318379.png
 
I haven't decided yet who will make them. For now I'm practicing on this 2way 12db that I will make myself, without hand-each, then when I will have perfected the use of kiCad, I will decide who to rely on for a more complex crossover.

n. v:
1742917558866.png
 
let me understand, those who print the Pcb cards start from a completely copper-plated card that is then cut according to the tracks? I thought they proceeded chemically, applying the copper only where necessary. let me understand.

L. v.

1742929260876.png
 
Last edited:
AFAIK the copper is either milled or etched away where it should not be. Make that tracks a lot wider but not wider than the PCB pads of parts! Use 2 pin 6.3 mm faston PCB mount connectors and 5.08 mm Phoenix MKDSN connector block footprints for the input and output connections so you can use either of those. You can use 4.8 mm faston PCB mount connectors for the tweeters to avoid mistakes. Soldering wires to boards is asking for trouble with thicker cabling and it is less reliable too. Versatility and serviceability without extra cost is nice.

Beginners mistake: the text "REF**" will be visible on your board. Either delete or change to "M3" or "M4". BTW you just have mounting holes which is good but what about plated through reinforced mounting holes (they are in the library) for extra sturdiness?
 
Last edited: