Another interesting part of your RF days probably was, why did components not neatly lay in rows on the PCB and in any direction. Some in the LF world would call that unprofessional or untidy claiming you can't design PCBs
So you were one of those guys that cannot lay out an RF PCB wit resistors and capacitors in rows like soldiers. Well you know the answer to that. Scaling your RF experience into LF does help a lot. Parasitic were one of the worst enemies.
Up at the frequencies we were working at, we were moving bond wires around and adding in extra bond pads to tune the rf response. We were doing wide band amps going up to 40GHz. Nice to reminisce but we digress...
Some may remember that a physical short circuit of dimensions, could be an almost perfect load 🤓
With regards to the layout at post #1615, You may have to get creative with the layout. Resistors R21 and R41 are still too far from the mosfet gate pads.
You need to get the gate resistors to within a couple of millimetres of the pads.
If you move R41 to the right of Q11 gate pad then you can move R21 to the right of Q9 gate pad where R41 is currently located.
I'm not sure if you made the pcb to a specific size but to make some room for R41 you could move the mosfets a couple of millimetres to the left.
Good suggestions. Now moved R26 slightly to make room for R41 alongside Q11 gate pad and moved R21 alongside Q9 gate pad.
As far as the PCB overall size and location of MOSFETS/fuse-holders/connectors go, these correspond directly with Prasi's board so that this pcb could become a direct replacement for his board and fit on the side heatsink panels of a Modushop Dissipante 2U case. The prime reason for redoing the board was to future proof the Mooly design as much as possible with the ongoing removal of THT semiconductors from availability for DIY construction.
Attachments
Last edited:
I don't think this layout will work on a Dissipante 2U heatsink. The mounting brackets they use are 10mm to 11mm wide, so the clear space on the surface is around 58mm. This layout is 72mm. It's a better fit for the 3U chassis.
I'm confused. I understood the slimmer Prasi layout, which has the same dimensions as this one, was done to suit the 2U chassis.
Having searched around on the Modushop site and finally found their Dissipante drawings, it looks like the clearance between the top and bottom mounting brackets is 56.3mm. As you say, this and the earlier Prasi board will fit onto the side walls of a 2U Slimline case but not onto the heatsinks of the Dissipante case.
If a board were laid out for a width of 50mm, it could be quite straightforward to rejig the layout for a single MOSFET pair doing this to accommodate either the single die EX10P20/EX10N20 or the double die ECW20P20/ECWN20 MOSFETs. Of interest?
It's something I've wanted to do. I imagine a longer skinny board similar to the layout that Rod Elliott uses on his P101 layout. Just need to find some time.
I'll see what we can come up with. I'll have something to look at later tomorrow.
I hope this file can answer your questions 🙂 "Dimensione Scasso utile interno mm" is the useful space on the heatsinks
Thanks Gianluca. I'd found the Dissipante drawing on your site (not an easy task) and calculated the 2U brackets had 56mm space between the top and bottom sections. 54mm useable space seems realistic as the absolute max to use.
At present, I'm working on a layout for pcb outside dimensions of 100mm x 50mm. The 100mm may come down dependent on how well I squeeze components into the available space.
In line with last few posts, I've done a slim board layout (140mm x 50mm) with a single output pair. I've done the output pair footprints so that it will take either an ECX10N20/ECX10P20 pair or the double die ECW20N20/ECW20P20. The double die pair will effectively give you the same output capability as a dual output pair.
Attachments
Final (hopefully) tweak of the last layout. Found enough room between the MOSFETs to site the drain resistors R27/28 closer to the MOSFET drains. Also repositioned the output resistor and Zobel network to take advantage of the space created by moving the other resistors.
