John Curl's Blowtorch preamplifier part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have just one advice, Bob. Do not believe much what is said. I am trying to stay polite as much as I can.
It really doesn't matter that much Pavel, seriously. 🙂 OK, there is the occasional safety issue and that is immediately jumped on vigorously, the rest is harmless and doesn't make any real difference, when was the last time he posted any kind of measurement for example?
 
The general idea is to eliminate the middlemen, not add more, so extra lugs are no-no.

  • Good: there appears to be holes in the posts, so strip the wire, jam it in there tight, and solder.
  • Better: same process plus replacing the wires with better ones.

Thanks Zung. I’m not even going to start talking about wire in public!

Been researching the zobel network at the output and is matching the R to the complete speaker DCR a good thing?
 
Uh huh, so why should anybody believe your statement ?.
Or perhaps you might like to divulge all about your belief systems ?.



Dan.

Pavel has all the markings of a serious engineer who investigates and underpins his conclusions with credible information gathered by applying objective scientific procedure and method.

That is why I believe him when he makes a statement. Because it coincides with my belief system that progress can only be made by thinking hard and valuating all that hard thinking by verifying the heck out of it.
 
Last edited:
I still have my NASA soldering standards book, along with my IPC standard. Still takes time and practice. Proper tools help.

The secret to good solder skills is good inspections! That accelerates the learning curve.

So I don't think it is so much time involved as knowing what the result should be.
It was just a play on the old saying 'To become an expert at X takes 10,000 hours'



Wave soldered surface mount parts were picture perfect. Hand soldered not so much.
I didn't think anyone wave soldered SMT in the 21st century? 6 zone reflow ovens are the norm for unleaded production boards.
 
Interesting.
I am interested to know about ovens to begin with SMD.

You don't need an oven to do SMD but if you have a large board or high density design it certainly saves time.

Most of the really cheap ovens we tried at my office were terrible. The most common one is sold as T962A from various Alibaba type vendors. It sucks, I can't recommend it for lead free soldering because it's so uneven. It might be okay with leaded paste and small boards. I have heard some of the toaster ovens with PID control mods are better than it is too.

We use a Torch T200C+ (same as T200N+ without nitrogen). I've been pretty impressed with it, it just works. Directly from China, but there were no other decent looking options in that price range. I think Eurocircuits sells one that might be okay too.

It's not super cheap, I think around $2000, but seemed to be the best thing in that price range as far as I know. The software it comes with is scary and didn't even start without crashing on my PCs, so I modified this old Python GUI someone wrote to work with it.

Torch T200N Reflow Oven
 
Last edited:
It was just a play on the old saying 'To become an expert at X takes 10,000 hours'




I didn't think anyone wave soldered SMT in the 21st century? 6 zone reflow ovens are the norm for unleaded production boards.

Yes, no one waves SMT boards as far as I know. SMT is all reflow except if you have lots of through hole parts mixed and you might get wave on the bottom or selective wave.
 
I'm not sure if the lead free solder discussion from 12 hours ago is still going, but there's this.

I dunno what constitutes proof or what, but I were a manufacturer of a consumer device with lots of safety features, for all safety critical solder joints I'd be using the same type of solder as approved for satellites and other spacecraft.

For the radio, whose only safety feature may be playing the official announcement of imminent nuclear attack, lead-free solder should be plenty good enough.
https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1264373
 
You don't need an oven to do SMD but if you have a large board or high density design it certainly saves time.

Most of the really cheap ovens we tried at my office were terrible. The most common one is sold as T962A from various Alibaba type vendors. It sucks, I can't recommend it for lead free soldering because it's so uneven. It might be okay with leaded paste and small boards. I have heard some of the toaster ovens with PID control mods are better than it is too.

We use a Torch T200C+ (same as T200N+ without nitrogen). I've been pretty impressed with it, it just works. Directly from China, but there were no other decent looking options in that price range. I think Eurocircuits sells one that might be okay too.

It's not super cheap, I think around $2000, but seemed to be the best thing in that price range as far as I know. The software it comes with is scary and didn't even start without crashing on my PCs, so I modified this old Python GUI someone wrote to work with it.

Torch T200N Reflow Oven

Thanks for that. Good info.:up:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.