Hi Al,
I have Eagle, but darned if I've learned it yet. I just need to figure out how to print on the photo paper. I also want to stick maybe 6 board patterns (to fit on an 8 X 11 sheet) so as not to waste on sheet per board. That way I can build some. Etching and drilling is no problem.
Mike, as soon as I figure out how to make boards I can help out. If you recall, we had discussed groundplanes earlier. I think the groundplane should be split between the output area and input area.
How about "Symasym- going further" for a new thread, also one for troubleshooting to help keep things on track?
Another request (as if you need this!). Cascode circuit. It can be jumpered past. I don't see the board size as terribly important right now. Less than 4" X 6" is fine. Then you can add another set of outputs for lower impedance loads if you want.
-Chris
I have Eagle, but darned if I've learned it yet. I just need to figure out how to print on the photo paper. I also want to stick maybe 6 board patterns (to fit on an 8 X 11 sheet) so as not to waste on sheet per board. That way I can build some. Etching and drilling is no problem.
Mike, as soon as I figure out how to make boards I can help out. If you recall, we had discussed groundplanes earlier. I think the groundplane should be split between the output area and input area.
How about "Symasym- going further" for a new thread, also one for troubleshooting to help keep things on track?
Another request (as if you need this!). Cascode circuit. It can be jumpered past. I don't see the board size as terribly important right now. Less than 4" X 6" is fine. Then you can add another set of outputs for lower impedance loads if you want.
-Chris
pinkmouse said:Using Mike's Eagle files at the moment, but I'm going to redo the schematic with Protel to try and sort out the grounding, Eagle is just too limiting for that.
I've just made a Protel schematic. Can I send it to you? I'm using a newer version of Protel so you'll need to associate parts on the schematic with footprints on the board.
bremen nacht said:I've just made a Protel schematic. Can I send it to you? I'm using a newer version of Protel so you'll need to associate parts on the schematic with footprints on the board.
Go for it, that should keep me quiet for an hour or so!
anatech said:I also want to stick maybe 6 board patterns (to fit on an 8 X 11 sheet) so as not to waste on sheet per board.
I use the CAM processor to output eps format files, then combine them in Photoshop. Do you have Photoshop?
How about "Symasym- going further" for a new thread, also one for troubleshooting to help keep things on track?
Good idea, we are well over the 2000 post mark.
Another request (as if you need this!). Cascode circuit.
Point me at a schematic. 😉
Hi Al,
Man, you're a busy fella! 😉
I tried using Photoshop Elements 2.0 (That's all I have), but just got really frustrated. (what the heck are layers??) Mind you, Word frustrates me as well. I learned on a typewriter and I end up fighting with the program.
In short, not too successful so far.
-Chris
Man, you're a busy fella! 😉
I tried using Photoshop Elements 2.0 (That's all I have), but just got really frustrated. (what the heck are layers??) Mind you, Word frustrates me as well. I learned on a typewriter and I end up fighting with the program.
In short, not too successful so far.
-Chris
Hi everybody,
I layed out a new board for Symasym with 4 AC filter caps on board measuring 5" x 3" double sided. So far everything is running great. I modified the design slighty so that it works with 50v rails. I'll post pics of the amp, waveforms, schematics , and THD measurements later today after I get home work. Mike, thanks for a great design!
Best regards,
Al
I layed out a new board for Symasym with 4 AC filter caps on board measuring 5" x 3" double sided. So far everything is running great. I modified the design slighty so that it works with 50v rails. I'll post pics of the amp, waveforms, schematics , and THD measurements later today after I get home work. Mike, thanks for a great design!
Best regards,
Al
Hi Al,
That's what happens with a small board.
As for a schematic, one could simply adopt the cascode from most amplifiers (Luxman, Marantz and tons more). I think I'd like to see Pavel or Mike guide this as they have a deeper understanding of this amplifier.
Mike, do you want to create the new threads or would you rather we do it? Just waiting for a title you like really.
-Chris
Yup. I really don't like the zobel ground and aux cap grounds where they are.Using Mike's Eagle files at the moment, but I'm going to redo the schematic with Protel to try and sort out the grounding
That's what happens with a small board.
As for a schematic, one could simply adopt the cascode from most amplifiers (Luxman, Marantz and tons more). I think I'd like to see Pavel or Mike guide this as they have a deeper understanding of this amplifier.
Mike, do you want to create the new threads or would you rather we do it? Just waiting for a title you like really.
-Chris
anatech said:Yup. I really don't like the zobel ground and aux cap grounds where they are.
That's what happens with a small board.
These days, I actually start off on a layout with about a dozen separate ground nets added to the schematic, and route and combine them as I go along. It makes much more sense to me, but would probabaly confuse the hell out of anyone else. 😉
Hi All,
I'm impatient sometimes. Mike, I opened a pair of new threads for you. The names can be changed to protect the guilty! 😉
The first is troubleshooting, here.
The second is for developement, located here.
I'll go back and link here ....
Hi Al,
What you are saying about ground nets makes sense to me anyway. Good idea.
-Chris
I'm impatient sometimes. Mike, I opened a pair of new threads for you. The names can be changed to protect the guilty! 😉
The first is troubleshooting, here.
The second is for developement, located here.
I'll go back and link here ....
Hi Al,
What you are saying about ground nets makes sense to me anyway. Good idea.
-Chris
Hmm, what about "Symasym - the sequel" ?
Should we wait for new boards ? I was confined to this board size because i use "Eagle light"... Proper grounding would definitely need bigger board.
Mike
EDIT: oops, you posted while i was typing... 😀
I was a bit distracted beeing busy with some research on FFT-coding.
Should we wait for new boards ? I was confined to this board size because i use "Eagle light"... Proper grounding would definitely need bigger board.
Mike
EDIT: oops, you posted while i was typing... 😀
I was a bit distracted beeing busy with some research on FFT-coding.
Hi Mike,
Those are your threads. I'll change the one title now for you.
Don't wait. Start discussing new designs right now. I don't want these ideas lost to an overlong thread.
-Chris
Edit: Done, Title changed. Next one Mike?
Those are your threads. I'll change the one title now for you.
Don't wait. Start discussing new designs right now. I don't want these ideas lost to an overlong thread.
-Chris
Edit: Done, Title changed. Next one Mike?
"Troubleshooting your Symasym" is perfect !
Okay, firing up spice to show input cascoding...
Okay, no rewrite of "SpectraLab" today...
Mike
Okay, firing up spice to show input cascoding...
Okay, no rewrite of "SpectraLab" today...

Mike
Hi Mike,
I have the same dithering problem when measuring THD with Pavel's wave file. How did you eliminate the dithering? I'm using a free demo version of SpectraPlus.
Thanks,
Al
I have the same dithering problem when measuring THD with Pavel's wave file. How did you eliminate the dithering? I'm using a free demo version of SpectraPlus.
Thanks,
Al
Ooops, 2 Al's ?
Problem with dithering ? You need the dithering to supress harmonics generated by aliasing. The trade off is noise level at -130db, but completely acceptable, assuming a typical noise floor at -120db.
If you look at my fft-picture, the upper is without dithering, the lower with dithering. Obviously the dithering is mandatory for readable fft plots.
Mike
Problem with dithering ? You need the dithering to supress harmonics generated by aliasing. The trade off is noise level at -130db, but completely acceptable, assuming a typical noise floor at -120db.
If you look at my fft-picture, the upper is without dithering, the lower with dithering. Obviously the dithering is mandatory for readable fft plots.
Mike
Thanks, Mike. Here's a paper on dithering for the audio engineer.
http://www.users.qwest.net/~volt42/cadenzarecording/DitherExplained.pdf
http://www.users.qwest.net/~volt42/cadenzarecording/DitherExplained.pdf
MikeB said:
Pavel, i analyzed your wave file (the 1025.5khz thing), you should have told me that i forgot the dithering...That gave all these nice spectral lines... What a difference ! Attached is fft of same wave without and with dithering.
Mike
Hi Michael,
I did not realize you have not been using dithering.
I am glad you are growing ..... 😀
Cheers,
Pavel
PMA said:
I am glad you are growing ..... 😀
Yes, learning something new every day... Wish my amount of hairs on my head would also grow...
Mike
Michael -
remember "horrible amplifier" (BTW - you were not happy 😀))
and "measurement that does not help" 😀
BTW - how is your 50Hz and its multiples now?
Cheers,
Pavel
remember "horrible amplifier" (BTW - you were not happy 😀))
and "measurement that does not help" 😀
BTW - how is your 50Hz and its multiples now?
Cheers,
Pavel
PMA said:Michael -
remember "horrible amplifier" (BTW - you were not happy 😀))
and "measurement that does not help" 😀
BTW - how is your 50Hz and its multiples now?
Cheers,
Pavel
Yes, i remember "horrible"... 😉
I have to admit, have not heated up the soldering iron for days, was researching FFT and dithering and so on, my programmer side was stronger these days. 😀
At least, i would have all routines together to build up my own measuring software. Had to try dozens of FFT-windowing possibilities. Only 3 survived... (Kaiser,Hanning,Gauss)
I always need to know what's behind the scenes...

Mike
- Home
- Amplifiers
- Solid State
- Explendid amplifier designed by Michael Bittner, our MikeB