The whisky and whiskey thread

I think i may have a problem...

These are just the single malts. Bourbon, Canadian and Irish are elsewhere!

View attachment 1475108

We'll be landing at Heathrow in ten hours... please PM the directions to your humble abode.

We're bringing the glassware.

;-)

I love the Talisker Sky... the saltiness is neat... my wife doesn't like it. More for me...

Oh, no sherry/port cask aged whiskeys, huh? Tsk, tsk...
 
I had some Bruichladdich Port Charlotte yesterday, an Islay style whisky. I find it very hard to describe flavours, and the descriptions I read are mostly meaningless to me, and sometimes just absurd. And the next review you read will use totally different descriptors. Here's how the website describes the Port Charlotte palate: "Coconut, vanilla custard and lemon honey combines with smoked oysters and sun baked salty sand"
https://www.bruichladdich.com/products/port-charlotte-10

I don't much like coconut flavour, I love vanilla custard, and vanilla is a pretty common flavour in whisky. I know what lemon honey tastes like, but I didn't taste any in the Port Charlotte. I certainly didn't taste smoked oysters, which I like a lot. I have never tasted sun baked salty sand. That seems like something that should not be in your mouth, not on purpose anyway.

Despite the descriptors, I liked the Port Charlotte very much. The flavours I can relate to; smoke, sweetness and alcohol burn were all present and very nicely balanced.
Fantastic whisky. A teaspoon or two of water in a tot helps to open the nose up in most whiskies. With the heavily peated ones, I drink them with one or two ice cubes.
 
“There is no bad whiskey. There are only some whiskeys that aren't as good as others.” -Raymond Chandler

I enjoy whiskey immensely and agree with the statement above. I've had hundreds and hundreds over the years but if I had to pick one brand to stick with for the rest of my years I'd likely pick George Dickel. Everything I've tried from them is good to great and I feel they don't get near the respect they deserve. Especially for the single barrel stuff.
 
I was a big Scotch fan... then I moved to Nashville, Tennessee. It was hard to shop for Scotch when the Scotch section as the local bottle shop was about 3 feet wide, and next to it was a 100 foot wall of American Whiskey... with quite a bit of it made within a days drive of me. I was converted.

My favorite is from a local distillery in the village of Leiper's Fork: https://leipersforkdistillery.com/

Its a small distillery with annual production of less that 25,000 gallons. It's a bit hard to find on the shelves outside of the Nashville area, but they do ship (not cheap though).

Their Tennessee Whiskey is my favorite regular offering. But their Rye is my favorite of their limited runs. It's typically available at the distillery only and often sells out in days if not hours.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3438.jpeg
    IMG_3438.jpeg
    319.9 KB · Views: 10
Fantastic whisky. A teaspoon or two of water in a tot helps to open the nose up in most whiskies. With the heavily peated ones, I drink them with one or two ice cubes.
Your preference is not for me to argue, but I never add water or ice to my whisky. I know a teaspoon of water is a common recommendation, but dilution has never improved the taste for me, not with distilled water nor tap water.

I did the math; adding a teaspoon of water to an ounce of 40% whiskey drops it to around 35%, or from 46% to 40%. I figure if the distiller thought it would taste better at lower proof, surely he would have added the water and released it at the lower proof.
 
Last edited:
You don’t need to add that much to alter the taste. If I add water, it’s a few drops to a double shot pour.

The idea is not to dilute it. Adding a few drops does something chemically speaking after it’s been aging in a bottle. I don’t recall the specific explanation, but the impact can be significant.

It varies by the bottle. From my experience sometimes it’s positive and others times it’s not. It’s fun to experiment though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lydlaug
I agree on JD. I love the history and the distillery grounds are beautiful. If you’re in middle Tennessee, it’s worth a visit. But the only time I drink JD is for a Jack & Coke. That combo pairs well in my opinion. And you aren’t wasting any special in a mixer.

Drinking it straight isn’t anything special. Even their bottled in bond 100 proof stuff is OK at best. I think it’s the result of distilling on a column still in mass production. You can only get so far with that approach.

All of their stuff is the same base distillant. The different products they sell is a result of which barrels they select and how long it’s aged and what proof they bottle at.
 
  • Like
Reactions: audiobomber
Your preference is not for me to argue, but I never add water or ice to my whisky. I know a teaspoon of water is a common recommendation, but dilution has never improved the taste for me, not with distilled water nor tap water.

I did the math; adding a teaspoon of water to an ounce of 40% whiskey drops it to around 35%, or from 46% to 40%. I figure if the distiller thought it would taste better at lower proof, surely he would have added the water and released it at the lower proof.
I don't know about Canadian tax, but in the UK alcohol is taxed on ABV. There is a long history of whisky being distilled to meet the 40% standard, and then, of course, there are higher proofs as well. I've visited quite a few distilleries in Scotland (Talisker, Tomatin, Dalwhinnie, Torabhaig, Oban, and one locally here in the North of England, 'Lakeland', to name a few) and they almost always recommend adding a drop or two of water to open up the whisky. A highly peated whisky like Laphroaig is just too medicinal for my taste without ice 🙂 YMMV.

(I heard a story that Laphroaig was shipped into the US during the prohibition because the distillers had it classified as a 'medicinal health drink'. Might be b.s. but sounds like a good story 😀 )