An arguably better replacement for the resistor in a CRC power supply - R21 PS module

No penalty past increased power dissipation. SUP70101 is rated for 375 W dissipation, but limited heat conducting surface of TO-220 case limits that in practice. With a good heatsink and thermal interface, I would limit dissipation to 30 W max.
 
  • Like
Reactions: codyt
Another quick question for you, @tombo56 . I'm hoping to make a bipolar supply based on that dual mono motherboard I made a while back. Reading your earlier comments it seems pretty straightforward – would the attached schematic do the job?
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot 2025-02-16 at 12.03.06 AM.png
    Screenshot 2025-02-16 at 12.03.06 AM.png
    243 KB · Views: 161
@codyt
On the second look I've noticed connection points marked as R21-G. 😳 Several coffees do wonders.

I suppose that are connection points for R21 module reference ground wires?

In that case, for the second R21 supply that has role as the negative supply, reference ground wire has to be connected to the actual ground of that module, which is on your schematic marked as V-.
 
  • Like
Reactions: codyt
@Vunce, @tombo56,@codyt,@ItsAllInMyHead

Hi fellas I’m currently building up 4 R21 regulators (2 positive and 2 negative) but I am having a heck of a time finding the Ohmite heatsink referenced in the BOM. Mouser p/n: 588-PA-T21-38E

Any tips for substitutions or where I can find it since it works so well in making the design very compact with Prasi’s LT4320/TO220 CRC PSU?

Of course if you have extra, please pm, I’ll buy them!

Thanks,
Anand.
 
@Vunce, @tombo56,@codyt,@ItsAllInMyHead

Hi fellas I’m currently building up 4 R21 regulators (2 positive and 2 negative) but I am having a heck of a time finding the Ohmite heatsink referenced in the BOM. Mouser p/n: 588-PA-T21-38E

Any tips for substitutions or where I can find it since it works so well in making the design very compact with Prasi’s LT4320/TO220 CRC PSU?

Of course if you have extra, please pm, I’ll buy them!

Thanks,
Anand.
I have a pair I can send you, if that helps. Just PM me your address. I’ve not found substitutes, though the second set I built I mounted them to the chassis heat sinks (probably a slightly uncommon approach, and also the standalone PSU version).
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0425.jpeg
    IMG_0425.jpeg
    708.1 KB · Views: 104
  • Thank You
Reactions: poseidonsvoice
  • Thank You
Reactions: poseidonsvoice
After thorough testing that included stability, transient response under severe fast varying load and PSRR, here are some approved replacement MOSFETs with corresponding component values changes:

Positive regulator:
SUP60061EL-GE
https://hr.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Vishay-Siliconix/SUP60061EL-GE3?qs=TuK3vfAjtkWzs5EzO2t/6w==
R7 – 4K7
C5 – 47 pF

C5 can be only ceramic C0G/NP0 or film type as are:
https://hr.mouser.com/ProductDetail/TDK/FG18C0G1H470JNT06?qs=qf2ddTMq67X/%2Bcf8DqHvfw==
https://hr.mouser.com/ProductDetail/WIMA/FKP2O100471D00HO00?qs=WI052HLiD5gTYAbXe/Io1g==

Negative regulator:
SQP120N10-09_GE3
https://hr.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Vishay-Siliconix/SQP120N10-09_GE3?qs=Nn1VXUNwu%2B/dh2XamFxneg==
R7 - 3K3

SUP70040E-GE3
https://hr.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Vishay-Semiconductors/SUP70040E-GE3?qs=eRmS5dli9yMyw65%2BBumSlg==
R7 - 2K2

At last, MOSFETs are not a problem anymore.
for the SQP120N10-09_GE3 besides changing P7 to 3K3
change ? and C5 – 47 pF (it is not mentioned for Negative regulator)
thanks