Is MDF or plywood better for speaker cabinets?

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Those speakers must have furnished some flare flapping moments Douglas!

LOL ... Good one!

I don't know about the pants, but they could rattle all the dishes in the kitchen any time I wanted them to.

Had them hooked up to a self-built 50w/ch amplifier (which was high power for the time) and a home-brew pre-amp with a 9 band equalizer.

My neighbours hated me.... :)
 
Oh my God, I use to dress just like that.
I go right back to winkle picker shoes and bum freezer suits!
 

Attachments

  • 1960s Fashion.jpg
    1960s Fashion.jpg
    35.6 KB · Views: 340
Damrnit, wish I had maty tinman's ability with timber and sawdust:

An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.


A box just waiting to be populated with a two-way setup! :D

Just rumbled back from the cinema with Ford versus Ferrari, 1966. A cracker!

Fans of engineering excellence will love this one. Those heavy old cars might measure well, but they won't go round corners! And they can't stop fast! :cool:

Racing always tends to fast and light. Just like Harbeth, IMO: YouTube

This is the bleeding edge, IMO.
 


Phoney, phoney, phoney, and the title of the article is a lie.

The diagram (which looks too phoney to be a real measurement)claims to show:

A - vibration on the wall of a some kind of cabinet (likely a box of plywood junk), and

B - a woofer loosely attached to a very damped cabinet

Neither shows audibility to your ears, as the title proclaims. Anybody have that audibility data?

BTW, if your woofer is loosely attached to the cab and therefore the frame of the driver shakes all over the place as the patent claims, what kind of sound issues from that kind of unstable driver?

B.
 

Attachments

  • VonSchweikertPaper-1.jpg
    VonSchweikertPaper-1.jpg
    88.7 KB · Views: 261
Last edited:
Last edited:
Harbeth Super HL5plus loudspeaker | Stereophile.com

515harb.inside.jpg


Black material on the endges too. It seems that the back side is a sandwich.

Harbeth Super HL5plus loudspeaker Measurements | Stereophile.com

615HLS5fig2.jpg


Fig.2 Harbeth Super HL5plus, cumulative spectral-decay plot calculated from output of accelerometer fastened to center of top panel (MLS driving voltage to speaker, 7.55V; measurement bandwidth, 2kHz).


615HLS5fig8.jpg


Fig.8 Harbeth Super HL5plus, cumulative spectral-decay plot on lower-tweeter axis at 50" (0.15ms risetime).


I like much more the CSD of Ascend Sierra 2-EX RAAL ribbons

Sierra-2EX Measurements

index.php
 
Last edited:
I don't suppose the life expectancy of ship builders in the 18th century was very high!

Around 6,000 trees were used in the construction of HMS Victory, of which 90% were oak.

That is why oak lasts longer than other woods: It contains natural fungicides/pesticides which you don't want to breath in.

Good ventilation and a dustmask is a must when working with oak.
 
Not many people know this, but I had a career as a HMS. Victory tour guide in the Portsmouth Historic Dockyard:

795158d1573855892-mdf-plywood-speaker-cabinets-hms-victory-jpg


Victory was already 50 years old when Lord Nelson took on the combined French and Spanish fleets.

IMO, he was on a hiding to nothing. :eek:

But somehow emerged 29-0 victor. IMO, down to a close friendship with the Captain of HMS.Temeraire.

Temeraire was the true winner of Trafalgar. It's one of those amazing tales that Nelson restrained Temeraire from leaping ahead into the battle. Nelson wanted to take the battering on the nose. But at the height of the battle, Temeraire came to the rescue. That is why we revere the Turner painting. :D
 
Last edited:
HMS. Victory:

795158d1573855892-mdf-plywood-speaker-cabinets-hms-victory-jpg


My first model build. I might not have done her the justice she deserved but it was a good starting point.

It is a good starting point. As a neutral, I actually quite liked "Old Ironsides" aka USS Constitution, currently preserved in Boston Harbour. Actually not iron at all. But solid timber. :D

Not many people know this, but Ozzie Donald Bradman was just about the gutsiest Cricketer of all time, But he'd never have made it to greatness without a partner. Bill Ponsford.

The story I most like about Bill Ponsford, is that he came back to the dressing room with about 80 runs to his name and about 80 bruises on the back from Larwood and Voce's disgraceful bodyline tactics. He said he'd have taken a few more bruises if he could have made a century! :D

My kind of guy!
 
Last edited:
Donald Bradman was just about the gutsiest Cricketer of all time
A batsman may only be as good as his bat!

Just like in the production of speaker cabinets, the composition and construction of fantastic bats involves getting the wood into the right condition.

The surprisingly complex world of cricket bats - Telegraph

"The willow blade has a flattened front that is hardened through a process of slight compression, and a back that features a ‘swell’ – where the wood is thick enough to deliver some heft and power to a hit."
 
...so I plan on making the front baffle with 2 sheets of plywood....

As the old math textbooks used to say, "It is left to the reader..." to calculate the volume of the second sheet of plywood and would it be better to add (certainly needless*) rigidity to the front or better to have the extra cubic volume in the box?

B.
* eyeballing some of the pix, sure looks unlikely there are many points on anybody's front panel that are unsupported more than a few inches
 
Last edited:
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.