### Counterfeit transistors

This is what I have for 2SA1302 and 2SC3281. Unfortunately, I returned the fakes back before I could take any photos of them, or smash at least. I also don't have any original smashed 2SA1302 and 2SC3281.

An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.


Notice the way those letters appear:
O, B and A in TOSHIBA.
A, 0 and R in 2SA1302.
8 and R in 2SC3281.
A and P in JAPAN, both of them.
 
Last edited:

Attachments

  • 7815-4.jpg
    7815-4.jpg
    210.2 KB · Views: 415
If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck....
Does it have silicone on the die ? Fake.
Does it completely fail to match the performance of the "first source" part ? Fake.

Cobra2, you cannot double-die transistors like that. So it's an inferior product.

Don't make excuses for China's lack of respect for intellectual property rights.
 
Yeah, you can find "equivalents" - if you are willing to retrofit an old unit to accept plastic packages. Current production parts will replace 99% of what's out there, except for TO-3's. For those you're pretty much limited to 4 MHz parts. Many times (more often than not) an amp is perfectly happy with them. Worth a try, when the alternatives are either hack it, trash it, or roll the bones with fakes.
 
Arne K, The problem is that fakes engrave the real company name on them. That's the whole problem with fakes, especially as companies have changed their production techniques and labelling methods over the years. The only way to identify some fakes is test to the point of destruction!
 
Speaking of fakes i have some 2sc5200-2sa1943,irfp250n from tayda electronics.
Are they original and good to be used to audio amps or fakes?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20161116_140055.jpg
    IMG_20161116_140055.jpg
    986.2 KB · Views: 386
  • IMG_20161116_194611.jpg
    IMG_20161116_194611.jpg
    985.2 KB · Views: 341
  • IMG_20161116_140111.jpg
    IMG_20161116_140111.jpg
    983.3 KB · Views: 339
Toshiba

mine are bought any years back here schuro shop.
- they have glossy backplate
- toshiba is same print in thick of lines like 1943/5200
- only the O than one point above and only 3 number code
(not extra letter+2numbers)
- at last JAPAN

this one not sure real ones.

With IRFP is a great dilemma newer days- you can buy this one you have-
also here reichelt, digikey has newer- not tinned legs.
I have bought IRFP 250-M Mouser older I- heart- O-R types- silky legs- good
ones- in Circlotron and ACA.

But it's a Challange!

In TME i became IOR(heart) 9140- now needed some 240.
 
Founder of XSA-Labs
Joined 2012
Paid Member
Speaking of fakes i have some 2sc5200-2sa1943,irfp250n from tayda electronics.
Are they original and good to be used to audio amps or fakes?

Tayda generally sells good stuff. Only way to know for sure is take it to a vise and crack it open. Real Toshibas have a big square silicon die perfectly centered on tab. Fakes have a small die crooked mounted and covered with white silicone RTV.

You can also measure capacitance of base to collector. A small die has small capacitance relative to real one which is larger.
 
some NEWS about Toshiba

Hi maouna and interested.

send pics from my last bought 2SC5200 O Toshiba from digikey, 14 days back.
That is TO-3P new production since 2015- you can reed on PDF there.
What is happen with your Trannis? :eek:
The Fakers ??? have taken the new LOGO ? or production has changed
to new LOGO with old TO264 Typ- is this possible? ;) :confused:
You can compare- the older working in onkle Charly DX-Amp and the news
should in a Ranchu/AKSA Quasi Amp.
 

Attachments

  • PIC_0394.JPG
    PIC_0394.JPG
    842.9 KB · Views: 268
  • PIC_0395.JPG
    PIC_0395.JPG
    836.4 KB · Views: 186