Slewmaster - CFA vs. VFA "Rumble"

Another advantage appears to be that heavy IPS degeneration makes an amp (at least a folded cascode - not simulated others recently) more tolerant of reactive loads. The reduction of stability margins seems smaller when using a reactive load vs resistive. But at the expensive of a small increase in THD consistent with the reduction in LG. A penalty I'm willing to take these days....

Have others found this?

Paul

Interesting. I haven't worried about load-related instability, since I get better results by outsourcing that task to a inductor/resistor or other kind of network.
 
Kypton V

kypton v
+/-50v
Idle current 60mA/pair
5 pairs njw0281,0302
All this test on a real speaker.
Last photo my sound card loop in out for comparision
 

Attachments

  • details.PNG
    details.PNG
    22.8 KB · Views: 520
  • thd noice.PNG
    thd noice.PNG
    22.6 KB · Views: 172
  • sweep.PNG
    sweep.PNG
    15.5 KB · Views: 167
  • noice.PNG
    noice.PNG
    24.3 KB · Views: 499
  • inter.PNG
    inter.PNG
    23.3 KB · Views: 503
  • fr resp.PNG
    fr resp.PNG
    18.8 KB · Views: 503
  • dynamic.PNG
    dynamic.PNG
    22.3 KB · Views: 531
  • julia in out for comparision.PNG
    julia in out for comparision.PNG
    23 KB · Views: 200
Last edited:
Kypton v

Using other software
Please on pictures 1&2 see the left channel where amplifier is connected(mono)
 

Attachments

  • KYP V SEPARATE GNG INP.PNG
    KYP V SEPARATE GNG INP.PNG
    99.3 KB · Views: 203
  • kypton v linear.PNG
    kypton v linear.PNG
    65 KB · Views: 174
  • Img.png
    Img.png
    79.7 KB · Views: 182
Last edited:
That is real good performance.

Strange how the distortion profile (dominant 3'rd) is also reflected
by the LT simulation. (below)
The sim and the real amp are right on.

I also got @ .0015% on LT at 1-10Khz.
Edit - I also got nearly equal H2/3 at 1K ... THD was around .001% there.
That is K-V2 , right ?
OS
 

Attachments

  • K-V2.jpg
    K-V2.jpg
    92.7 KB · Views: 198
Last edited:
That is real good performance.

Strange how the distortion profile (dominant 3'rd) is also reflected
by the LT simulation. (below)
The sim and the real amp are right on.

I also got @ .0015% on LT at 1-10Khz.
Edit - I also got nearly equal H2/3 at 1K ... THD was around .001% there.
That is K-V2 , right ?
OS
I'm afraid that is ver.1 ,look at the picture.
 

Attachments

  • DSC09793.JPG
    DSC09793.JPG
    584.8 KB · Views: 283
No , V2 has the super-pair left out .

So , you used a V1 PCB to make a V2.

Still , one excellent 1970's Japanese input stage. 🙂
PS - yours outperforms the Japanese ones by many magnitudes.
OS
Thanks Pete, this time is the Kypton ND under test.
Here we have interesting things to look at.
I will post 3 different way for input gnd connection.
In the first picture the G2(GND) point connected at G1 point on the power amplifier board ,near +v/-v.The worst way!
In the second picture this G2 (GND)point connected direct on star gnd.Better
The other picture is what you see in the last picture,G2 connected to G1 point and the gnd from the IPS lifted from G2 and connected on star gnd directly.The best way.
 

Attachments

  • ND ON BOARD.PNG
    ND ON BOARD.PNG
    100.5 KB · Views: 302
  • ND G2 TO STAR GND.PNG
    ND G2 TO STAR GND.PNG
    99.4 KB · Views: 195
  • ND G2 TO G1 INP GND TO STAR.PNG
    ND G2 TO G1 INP GND TO STAR.PNG
    100.7 KB · Views: 184
  • DSC09794.JPG
    DSC09794.JPG
    574.4 KB · Views: 253
Last edited:
Ahh , interesting effect.

K-ND input pair virtual ground is the servo output (very good PSSR) ... not
earth.
That leaves the current feedback ground. Having that modulated by the speaker
return and OPS decoupling returns must degrade performance.
This is nowhere as pronounced with most VFA's , as their NFB returns are
not ground referenced.
We are still learning 😀 ....
PS - have you tried connecting speaker returns directly to the PS star ?? (another workaround).

OS
 
Last edited:
Ahh , interesting effect.

K-ND input pair virtual ground is the servo output (very good PSSR) ... not
earth.
That leaves the current feedback ground. Having that modulated by the speaker
return and OPS decoupling returns must degrade performance.
This is nowhere as pronounced with most VFA's , as their NFB returns are
not ground referenced.
We are still learning 😀 ....
PS - have you tried connecting speaker returns directly to the PS star ?? (another workaround).

OS
have you tried connecting speaker returns directly to the PS star ?? (another workaround).

This is what i do always.🙂
 
Here is what I did (below).

Injecting both a fixed ripple and / or a phased output signal (more realistic)
will degrade a CFA's feedback signal.

I guess this is another deficiency of current feedback topology.

I also did this to the K-ND servo ground reference , here no degradation. The servo's PSRR "swallow's" it up nicely.

The new Groner TIS (SG-1) is immune to a noisy ground , and most of the
VFA slewmaster IPS's negotiate even a nearly faulty ground reference
without any penalty. Most of those VFA IPS's lost about <5ppm , even
with 1V ripple on any earth reference.

So , be VERY anal with a CFA grounding.
Edit - CFA IPS's like the VSSA/CFA-X have a capacitive coupling to ground
.... they also seem less affected by a "dirty" ground (in simulation).

OS
 

Attachments

  • CFAdirty.jpg
    CFAdirty.jpg
    114.8 KB · Views: 594
Comparision

what is the input impedance of Kypton V? with 22k resistor at the input the first resistor which connects at the input to the ground. With the following procedure I got about 22k as input impedance.

After the coupling cap, find the first resistor to ground... that is close enough.

OR:

Put a 50 - 100 K rheostat (pot) in series with your sound card and the amp (pos lead)

Power up the amp and apply a sine wave... 500 - 1000 Hz, 2.5 V ACrms

Adjust the pot until the ACrms across the pot and across the amp input are equal.

Power down, disconnect, and measure your pot value; that is your Zin.

Did u measure the input impedance of the Kypton V?
 
what is the input impedance of Kypton V? with 22k resistor at the input the first resistor which connects at the input to the ground. With the following procedure I got about 22k as input impedance.

After the coupling cap, find the first resistor to ground... that is close enough.

OR:

Put a 50 - 100 K rheostat (pot) in series with your sound card and the amp (pos lead)

Power up the amp and apply a sine wave... 500 - 1000 Hz, 2.5 V ACrms

Adjust the pot until the ACrms across the pot and across the amp input are equal.

Power down, disconnect, and measure your pot value; that is your Zin.

Did u measure the input impedance of the Kypton V?
Look at post#5282,83,84 ,you will see all the details about Kypton V.