Funniest snake oil theories

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think Stuart at one point somewhere found the expression 'Chronic Underachievement Disorder' but I guess he has been too chicken to use it 😀

The fundamental problem is, I think, linguistic. In my first language (Yiddish), there are two ways of expressing intelligence, sechel and chacham (these are rough transliterations). They have very different meanings! In English, we don't really have that differentiation.

"Sechel is just plain smarts, a grasp on what really is and really counts, that cuts and sees through it all, that guides you to do the right thing the right way at the right time, to size up what’s really going on, to see where someone really comes from, to understand what does and doesn’t matter. You either got it or you don’t."

Chacam is more like a learned wisdom, e.g., the ability to calculate contour integrals or analyze James Joyce. If you don't have it, you can get it through intense study.

I don't know if Dutch has separate words for these concepts.
 
The fundamental problem is, I think, linguistic. In my first language (Yiddish), there are two ways of expressing intelligence, sechel and chacham (these are rough transliterations). They have very different meanings! In English, we don't really have that differentiation.

"Sechel is just plain smarts, a grasp on what really is and really counts, that cuts and sees through it all, that guides you to do the right thing the right way at the right time, to size up what’s really going on, to see where someone really comes from, to understand what does and doesn’t matter. You either got it or you don’t."

Chacam is more like a learned wisdom, e.g., the ability to calculate contour integrals or analyze James Joyce. If you don't have it, you can get it through intense study.

I don't know if Dutch has separate words for these concepts.

Yes we have, although they are sometimes used interchangably.
'Slim' is more like your Sechel, a more practically oriented sort of intelligence, a great survival trait!
'Intelligent' is more the innate capability to learn quickly and focussed.

Jan
 
The fundamental problem is, I think, linguistic. In my first language (Yiddish), there are two ways of expressing intelligence, sechel and chacham (these are rough transliterations). They have very different meanings! In English, we don't really have that differentiation.

"Sechel is just plain smarts, a grasp on what really is and really counts, that cuts and sees through it all, that guides you to do the right thing the right way at the right time, to size up what’s really going on, to see where someone really comes from, to understand what does and doesn’t matter. You either got it or you don’t."

Chacam is more like a learned wisdom, e.g., the ability to calculate contour integrals or analyze James Joyce. If you don't have it, you can get it through intense study.

I don't know if Dutch has separate words for these concepts.

I tend to see that as 'street smarts' vs. 'book smarts' ...

And it's amazing how the often they don't overlap at all ... from both directions ...

Actually, understanding the underlying neurology, it's not that surprising at all! Just contrary to 'common wisdom.'
 
My daughter is a "human resources" person. I suggested she put "do you believe audio cables are directional?" on her employment applications. She said "why not ask if jumper cables are directional ?" We both came to the conclusion that the people at Waffle House, who use jumper cables often, are far too intelligent to believe that it makes a difference. Many audio people however, lack this innate intellect.
 
Last edited:
The fundamental problem is, I think, linguistic. In my first language (Yiddish), there are two ways of expressing intelligence, sechel and chacham (these are rough transliterations). They have very different meanings! In English, we don't really have that differentiation.

"Sechel is just plain smarts, a grasp on what really is and really counts, that cuts and sees through it all, that guides you to do the right thing the right way at the right time, to size up what’s really going on, to see where someone really comes from, to understand what does and doesn’t matter. You either got it or you don’t."

Chacam is more like a learned wisdom, e.g., the ability to calculate contour integrals or analyze James Joyce. If you don't have it, you can get it through intense study.

I don't know if Dutch has separate words for these concepts.
So you grew up on the lower east side then . This does bring thing into much clearer focus.
 
My daughter is a "human resources" person. I suggested she put "do you believe audio cables are directional?"

Don't, I've had interviews decend into nonsense by asking about an applicant's audio hobby. OTOH my favorite was a young woman "noise" artist telling me about which old germanium transistors scavenged from IBM 1400 boards made the "harshest" noise. She was actually quite good.
 
In the days when I was fittier and less smart I went to every corner of this world to climb mountains. I dont do that anymore for obvious reasons. In those days I found that various people has their own way of dealing with strangers. I never wanted to be let in to any society, I was not there to socialice but I could not help to notice that whereever I went there was always one bullie. The israelis. noone liked them because they were so hostile. Now I got to know one of them so I know they are not evil at all.
 
I best interview question was " What do you do when you washing machine breaks?"
If the answer was "call Sears", I moved on. If they said, you fix it stupid!" I hired them. I needed technicians. I could teach a technician our machine, but I could not teach them how to fix. You can or you can't.

In our business, there are 10 kinds of people, those who understand binary...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.