Hello all; I'm looking for some friendly advice for my speaker building project...
My current and long-time “hi-end” speaker system consist of 17 year old Audio Physic Virgo III’s, which offer more inner detail and resolution, transparency, and pinpoint imaging compared to my previously owned mid-1980's Apogee Duetta’s. And while the Apogee’s could produce prodigious amounts of bass, it was not as tight as I desired (especially after hearing the Entec SW-1’s). I’m not a loud-volume listener, but because the Virgo’s have limited bass extension, I chose to run them in parallel with a pair of line-level late 1990's Velodyne 12 inch servo subwoofers which I can blend well with the main speakers in my relatively large listening room.
Years ago I thought I would pursue an improved DIY speaker project that would offer even more of the above qualities, using what were considered then to be some of the best speaker driver units available:
Scan Speak D2509/9900 Revelator tweeter
Scan Speak 18W/8545-00 mid-woofer
NHT 1259 subwoofer
Since I lacked the requisite measuring equipment, knowledge, and experience to design my own crossovers, I was going to use the 2-way Scan Speak Reference Monitor, Brennwald's ScanSpeaker, or Madisound designed crossover that had been employed for the Scan-Speak drivers, in conjunction with a pair of sealed subwoofers for the NHT 1259's powered by plate amplifiers. The general design would follow the Tony Gee Andromeda speaker, which I find quite aesthetically pleasing.
Now approaching retirement, I have been bitten by the idea of building these speakers once again. Pulling the drivers out of storage, I discovered they are pristine. But I have become aware that after 15+ years, significant advancements with speaker technology have been made. I therefore have the choice to:
1) pursue the project as originally envisioned, or
2) sell one, two, or all of these driver pairs and invest in an updated design, such as those from Troels Gravesen, who seems to have a very good reputation and obviously is both very knowledgeable and experienced.
However, I find the potential number of possibilities bewildering. Troels refuses to make any recommendations, and I don’t have the time or inclination to become a serial speaker builder. Other than frequency response and distortion graphs, and without the ability to audition a particular speaker, let alone hear it in the personal home listening environment, how does one decide between – for example – the Ekta Grande, Jensen 1071, Illuminator Monitor, Ellam FLEX paired with a suitable subwoofer, Ellipticor-1 with subwoofer, Ellipticor-3, or the ATELL-3?
Are the “classic” drivers I have still good enough that I wouldn’t hear a significant difference compared to the newer designs? Or given a specific budget, would it be best to pursue the most cutting edge drivers and designs one can afford, hoping for a significant and worthy improvement over what the classic drive units can provide? Given the few and far between reviews of DIY speaker projects by an independent reviewer (e.g. not the builder or kit seller), which direction should one move towards? I’m looking for suggestions or a methodology by which – ear-unheard – one can make any kind of informed decision.
Much thanks 🙂