Hello everybody in a sunny and shiny day from Spain:
Introducing myself (already done in the appropriate forum) I’m Alberto, a 40 years old Guy who, not knowing almost nothing in the Speaker’s DIY world, has started his own project after 2 years willing to do it.
My aim is to clone the Sonus Faber Cremona Speakers but with a very low budget… let me explain:
I’ve been a long time crazy for the Cremona’s, but no way to buy them even in the used market, so thanks to one of my friends, I bought a used pair of Monitor Audio Gold Reference GR60 floorstanding speakers, that I have to say they sounds me like angels singing….
Monitor Audio Gold Reference 60 Floorstanding Speakers reviews - Audioreview.com
Speaker Asylum: REVIEW: Monitor Audio GR 60 Speakers by O'Shag
http://www.htguide.com/forum/showthr...-B-amp-W-804-S
A Review of the Perfect Loudspeaker: Monitor Audio Gold Reference 10 - Archived Threads 2001-2004 - Home Theater Forum
But I don’t like how they look all:
So, with my tight budget I thought I colud use the drivers and Xover from the GR60’s inside my cremona’s enclosure. After some tests and looking for lots of information I decided I would do something like this: my Hybrid Cremona’s:
And… the fact is that I designed from the beginning all the CAD drawings and everything and sent the drawings to a Computer cutting and milling, because the guys who had built the Cremona’s Clone in Spain constructed them by adding lots of layers to build the enclosure, but I was sure I wouldn’t be able to do like that and I thought it was easier, faster and much more safe to build them rib by rib, and the fact is that I was in the right way. I will add some pictures of building process later.
When I designed all the stuff I did with the following parameters:
Very similar volumes that the GR60’s but compatible volumes to the BIG_AL Cremona’s Clone… who knows if I will build with this drivers (that was my first opinion, but the budget is quite expensive for me)
vs
I have already built the enclosure. It took me about 12 hours of gluing ribs from 5 to 5 and putting all the together to build the full enclosure (It took about 10 days leaving 24hours to dry each glued portion). This is the result (still not veneered):
And what happens now? Well, I have to say I’m really satisfied with the result and I’m very close to the starting point of this project long time ago: deciding whether or not to use my GR60’S drivers and Xover or a new drivers configuration, and here you are my options for you to give me your suggestions:
1.- Using the Cremona’s drivers and Xover (or the ones designed by my Spanish Friend) that is for each speaker: Morel Supreme Tweeter + Audiothecnology C-Quence 15 H 52 06 13 SD midrange + 2x Scanspeak 18W8531G00 woofers. All this stuff, Xover included and selling my GR60’s would be a $2100 investement (1550€). The pros is that this is a superb configuration, it sounds PERFECT and the Xover is already designed. The con is the hugh amount of money I don’t want to Spend.
2.- Build my own configuration accdording to my budget. For each speaker: Seas 27TDFC-H1189 Tweeter + SEAS MCA15RCY-H1262 mid + 2x SEAS U18RNX-H1571 woofers. All this stuff, adding a Behringer DCX2496 ultradrive pro Xover to avoid the passive Xover desing, and adding the mic and external sound card for measurement, all inclusive and selling my GR60’s would be a $410 investement (300€). The pros: no much expenses (I could rise my budget in drivers up to $675 or 500€). The cons: adding a new electronic device (The DCX2496) and lots of hours of measurement) and I don’t know the results… until I spend the money and test everything.
3.- Using the GR60’s stuff. The cheapest option, the worst looking but I’m pretty sure I will really have a good sound.
Do you think I will get more sound performance with options 1 or 2 or any other option you can suggest me?
I accept all your suggestions about drivers and Xovers, even if they are different to my ideas, but I need something tested and fully working and don’t want to test Xovers because I would become crazy for sure.
Thanks everybody for looking.