|25th October 2018, 07:14 AM||#1|
Join Date: Oct 2003
NJFETs for Source Follower Applications
In recent years, since Toshiba has stopped production of their low noise JFETs, there have been a lot of discussion about possible alternatives to replace them,
and what penalties there might be :
B1 JFET alternatives list
Replacement For Toshiba 2SK170/2SJ74
The most recent discussion is probably the source follower used in the LX Mini Active Crossover.
Following the discussions there, we decided to put some substance behind that discussion.
LX-mini Crossover Article
With the help of Jan Didden, we obtained access to an Audio Precision 2722 Distortion Analyser for half a day.
A small test setup was prepared to test various (Toshiba low noise) N-JFETs in a source follower buffer circuit.
The circuit consisted of 2x 9V alkaline batteries as power supply.
This was further filtered by 4mH Fastron inductors, followered by Panasonic FC 120μF capacitors.
Each of the N-JFET pairs used in the testing was matched to <10μA in Idss.
The output was loaded by a 10k ohm Vishay S102 bulk foil resistor.
The JFETs tested were
a. 2SK170BL at 8.2mA Idss
b. 2SK117BL at 7.5mA Idss
c. 2SK209GR at 3.8mA Idss
Single-ended input signal was 1Vrms and 2Vrms at 1kHz from the AP built-in waveform generator.
The results can be summarised.
DUT 1Vrms __H2 __H3__ 2Vrms H2 __H3
2SK170BL -102dB -104dB -96dB -92dB
2SK117BL -99dB -100dB -93dB -89dB
2SK209GR -92dB -107dB -86dB -97dB
As can be seen, there is very little performance difference between 2SK170 and 2SK117 (= 2SK209 in SMD) at the same Idss; on average about 3dB.
Halving the Idss push up the second harmonics by so 6dB, in return for 7dB lower third harmonics. The latter result (with the low H3) was rather unexpected and interesting.
|25th October 2018, 12:27 PM||#9|
Join Date: Oct 2003
BF862 is obsolete. You can't get them anymore on Mouser & Digikey.
It has high Idss and therefore will heat up quite a bit more.
It also has lower dynamic range as the gate current increases significantly above 9V Vds.
So it was not included in this test.
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Source follower VS white cathode follower||hellokitty123||Tubes / Valves||12||27th April 2018 11:16 PM|
|Source follower and common source output stages||slogan2112||Pass Labs||2||9th October 2008 08:19 PM|
|Aleph-type current source, but source follower this time||tschrama||Pass Labs||4||29th July 2005 12:55 PM|
|Source follower electret mike -> use with current source?||capslock||Solid State||1||28th February 2003 12:54 PM|
|Plate follower and applications||tiroth||Tubes / Valves||15||21st April 2002 08:15 PM|
|New To Site?||Need Help?|