Tighter tolerances and lower temperature coefficients than the typical metal film resistors. I'd say these are pretty good, especially if you can get the lower Tc types.
Voltage coefficient is also significant, but rarely specified most of the time so I'm not sure how well this series compares to others.
Voltage coefficient is also significant, but rarely specified most of the time so I'm not sure how well this series compares to others.
I don't know if they are inductive or capacitive or pure resistive but they sure are magnetic! I have some of these resistors and I tested them with a small magnet and they "glued" on it. Don't know if this has an effect on sound or not...
Vishay bulk foils are very expensive...
I'm thinking in these tycos or maybe Takman metal film. One other option might be Audio Note tantaluns but these are 1% 100ppm wich is worst than the tycos... I like these tycos because they have a nice datasheet but are they any good for audio? Any advice would be very welcome!
Vishay bulk foils are very expensive...
I'm thinking in these tycos or maybe Takman metal film. One other option might be Audio Note tantaluns but these are 1% 100ppm wich is worst than the tycos... I like these tycos because they have a nice datasheet but are they any good for audio? Any advice would be very welcome!
Last edited:
I've never found specifications for the tantalum resistors; I thought they'd be tighter tolerance and better Tc.
In the objective sense, which is what I consider first, the Tycos are very good--better than any of the other parts mentioned except bulk foil, which are the very best of any resistor of its size and ratings.
Subjectively, some people prefer the sound of carbon resistors, which have poorer electrical specifications by a considerable margin. Carbon composition appear to be actively piezoelectric--very poor voltage coefficient--but again, some people prefer what they call a 'warm' and rich sound.
I actively search for bulk foil resistors but the best of that type, the Z-foils are outside my budget altogether--and I really don't like the construction of the 'naked' bulk foil types. So I can only use them very sparingly in what I think are the most critical locations, and use the best metal films in most other locations.
In non-audio applications, as long as tight values and low Tc aren't required, most any resistor type will work fine. Don't overlook wirewounds, some of them should be nearly as good as bulk foil if their Tc is very low. But they are not as common as they once were.
In the objective sense, which is what I consider first, the Tycos are very good--better than any of the other parts mentioned except bulk foil, which are the very best of any resistor of its size and ratings.
Subjectively, some people prefer the sound of carbon resistors, which have poorer electrical specifications by a considerable margin. Carbon composition appear to be actively piezoelectric--very poor voltage coefficient--but again, some people prefer what they call a 'warm' and rich sound.
I actively search for bulk foil resistors but the best of that type, the Z-foils are outside my budget altogether--and I really don't like the construction of the 'naked' bulk foil types. So I can only use them very sparingly in what I think are the most critical locations, and use the best metal films in most other locations.
In non-audio applications, as long as tight values and low Tc aren't required, most any resistor type will work fine. Don't overlook wirewounds, some of them should be nearly as good as bulk foil if their Tc is very low. But they are not as common as they once were.
Here's an opinion from an audio designer for high quality resistors which he likes to use:
Aria Audio
Resistors
And they're mostly expensive. I have to fall back on less esoteric metal film most of the time, and the main guideline is a very low Tc (which is what precision resistors require to remain precise!) and low voltage coefficient. 50 ppm is better, and 25 ppm is still affordable; bulk foil resistors can be as low as 0.05 ppm.
But I suspect that elusive voltage coefficient is more significant than most people realize.
Aria Audio
Resistors
And they're mostly expensive. I have to fall back on less esoteric metal film most of the time, and the main guideline is a very low Tc (which is what precision resistors require to remain precise!) and low voltage coefficient. 50 ppm is better, and 25 ppm is still affordable; bulk foil resistors can be as low as 0.05 ppm.
But I suspect that elusive voltage coefficient is more significant than most people realize.
Sorry, I meant the Takmans are 1% 100ppm. I don't know about the tantaluns, can't find any datasheet of them. I wonder if they are objectively as good as people believe...
I agree with you about lower TCR gives better, more transparent, sound but the Z-foils are to much expensive for me. I'd go with the Tycos but for signal path I'd like something better. Are the Takmans (even with worse TCR) or the Shinkoh a better choice?
Let your budget be your guide. The Tycos seem like a better choice for the money given the known specifications. Shinkoh tantalums have a high audiophile reputation, but lacking hard information I've never used them (though I did buy a sample to see if I could estimate Tc--seemed no different from a good metal film).
What was the value you estimated?
I think your right. It's good advice. Theres only one thing now that bothers me: the ferromagnetic end caps. Many people around here don't like magnetic parts. Metal histeresys and current induced magnetic fields across the resistors. Should this be a concern? I mean, is it detrimental to sound quality or the effects are negligible?
Thank you for your good advice
It seemed similar to an average film resistor, roughly 100 ppm. I have no idea how to measure voltage coefficient and probably don't have accurate enough equipment.
Do magnetic parts make for degraded sound? I don't know. Most film resistors have a few uA or mA running through them in medium/high impedance circuits, so I'm dubious. OTOH, it can't hurt to use non-magnetic parts; what I've seen of the best film resistors is that they are usually non-magnetic.
I think I forgot to mention that the bulk foil resistors are non-inductive by design; they're really miniaturized wirewounds using a nickel-chromium alloy just like most metal film resistors and most wirewounds. The bulk nature of the foil means less stress on the alloy compared to the very thin film. And therein, I suspect, may be the 'secret' or a big part of the reason why bulk foil resistors are considered the 'ultimate' by many. But not all, of course. And for that reason, a low Tc wirewound ought to be very good, too.
That's my theories, anyway...
Do magnetic parts make for degraded sound? I don't know. Most film resistors have a few uA or mA running through them in medium/high impedance circuits, so I'm dubious. OTOH, it can't hurt to use non-magnetic parts; what I've seen of the best film resistors is that they are usually non-magnetic.
I think I forgot to mention that the bulk foil resistors are non-inductive by design; they're really miniaturized wirewounds using a nickel-chromium alloy just like most metal film resistors and most wirewounds. The bulk nature of the foil means less stress on the alloy compared to the very thin film. And therein, I suspect, may be the 'secret' or a big part of the reason why bulk foil resistors are considered the 'ultimate' by many. But not all, of course. And for that reason, a low Tc wirewound ought to be very good, too.
That's my theories, anyway...
I think I'm going with the Tycos for within the feedback loop and Takman or Shinkoh for the more sensible areas.
Do you think the Tycos are safe enough in terms of not inducing oscillations because of their magnetism? I'm mean, they are really magnetic!
Between Takman and Shinkoh, any thoughts? The Takmans are nicely priced but the datasheet says 100ppm and no reference of voltage coeficient... On the other hand, there's no datasheet for the Shinkoh... only subjective praise...
Many thanks for your help.
Cheers,
Paulo.
Do you think the Tycos are safe enough in terms of not inducing oscillations because of their magnetism? I'm mean, they are really magnetic!
Between Takman and Shinkoh, any thoughts? The Takmans are nicely priced but the datasheet says 100ppm and no reference of voltage coeficient... On the other hand, there's no datasheet for the Shinkoh... only subjective praise...
Many thanks for your help.
Cheers,
Paulo.
I wouldn't expect any problems from such a tiny amount of inductance. There'd have to be something badly wrong with design to oscillate that easily. I feel that audiophile concern is way overblown.
Takman or Shinkoh? Without more hard information that's impossible to call. You may have to just buy some of both and try them out. For the price being asked of the Shinkohs I'd hope they're really good! That they have a very good reputation and I see them in very high-end equipment might be a recommendation.
Takman or Shinkoh? Without more hard information that's impossible to call. You may have to just buy some of both and try them out. For the price being asked of the Shinkohs I'd hope they're really good! That they have a very good reputation and I see them in very high-end equipment might be a recommendation.
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.