Slewmaster - CFA vs. VFA "Rumble"

A small observation from today.
Few posts above I have posted pictures with simple mosfet OPS with only one pair of popular IRFP transistors soldered (82R gate stoppers), all was working really nice and stable.
Today I have soldered 3 pairs of irf540/9540 mosfets to the same OPS, it started to show some parasitic oscillation so I had to increase gate stoppers from 82R up to 330R (at 150R the oscillations were still present).
Now I am just wondering if It was caused by the two more pairs of OP transistors or just by the type of the transistor.
I will try to check it tomorrow.
It is not so simple as it looks like.

Regards
 

Attachments

  • 3 pari mini ops.jpg
    3 pari mini ops.jpg
    103.2 KB · Views: 472
A small observation from today.
Few posts above I have posted pictures with simple mosfet OPS with only one pair of popular IRFP transistors soldered (82R gate stoppers), all was working really nice and stable.
Today I have soldered 3 pairs of irf540/9540 mosfets to the same OPS, it started to show some parasitic oscillation so I had to increase gate stoppers from 82R up to 330R (at 150R the oscillations were still present).
Now I am just wondering if It was caused by the two more pairs of OP transistors or just by the type of the transistor.
I will try to check it tomorrow.
It is not so simple as it looks like.

Regards
Beware, base stoppers had to be set as close from the chips as possible: I was shocked by your wires as I am with the long transistor's legs in your photo. Remember we are dealing there with something around 10MHz.
 
Last edited:
Esperado
But the version with the wires was performing really good. My problems have started afted I have soldered 3 pairs of irf transistors. Maybe the irfp transistors are less sensitive to parasitic oscillations.

I have placed the gate stoppers just by the transistor leg, the track on the pcb is no longer than 1-2mm.
I am wondering how to match correctly the gate resistors, just by the hardware measurements and tests on the bench ?
On the mosfet amplifiers they have values from 47R up to 470 or even 1k !
The most used is approx 220R.
 
cfa-vfa prototypes

Nad look at post# 832,963,967.988,989,1005
Spooky #1247,1267,1292,1301
Gnome v1.3 #1455,1467,1485,1500,1516,1531,1538,1567
Symasui #1642,1671,1672,1673
Cfa ver.1.2 #1754,1756,1757,1784
Cfa v1.3 #2976
Wolverine ver1-c #3543,3564,3637,2279
Kypton C #4797,4765
Kypton V #5261,5282
Eyessee #5521
Kypton ND #6830,6850,6888
Infidel an unsuccessful IPS #5385
Ostriper schematic list look at post # 1
I hope this is a complete list and may be useful.
 
Last edited:
Christophe,
I'm not so sure he wasn't interested in your proposal. The fact that we haven't seen anything from him for awhile is a bit troubling but I suspect he has had some family issues come up. I don't think anyone has heard from him? I just don't want him to disappear as NuwaveGuy did on the 02headphone thread. Let's give him some time and space before we start trying to chase him down.
 
I hope this is a complete list and may be useful.

The "SYMETRI" simple complimentary (Bimo) has many supporters. ROBUST topology.

"Symetri-Cascode" post #8349. You can run the .asc file to confirm ~ 25% lower THD with your models.

The "spookyamp" (leach amp) also uses complementary cascoded inputs, with a Hawksford VAS instead of the second complementary diff VAS used in Symetri. The BC5xxC transistors have a 4db noise figure. Cascoding the Symetri inputs also allows using ultra low (2db)noise JFETS as input transistors.