Settle an argument - Which genre has the lowest notes?

Which genre has the lowest notes?

My guess is that it is old-skool Hip-Hop. My given reason is because of the scratching. To stop a spinning deck it must decelerate. During this process 40hz, briefly becomes 20, then 10, then 5 . . . you get the picture.
 
A turntable's arm/cartridge has a fundamental resonance around 10Hz, and won't put out signal below that.
Only a CD or streaming has no inherent limit and can have such low frequencies. Syn or organ music can go very low.
 
Last edited:
A turntable's arm/cartridge has a fundamental resonance around 10Hz, and won't put out signal below that.
Only a CD or streaming has no inherent limit and can have such low frequencies. Syn music can go low.

I'm not au-fait with modern recording techniques but offer some anecdotal points. (1) A commercial recording of said music does not seem to contain these lower frequencies but observing a woofer while scratching live will reveal the epitome of violence. (2) Put a warped record on a turntable and a woofer's excursion will mirror the warp without making making an audible sound.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AddiDub
While you bring up some observations, I'd like to mention that there are people that do not believe a ported speaker requires a high pass filter. Cone excursion rapidly increases below tuning without one, especially in poorly tuned boxes and woofers with soft suspensions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrKlinky
Any audiophile recording made in a place with a draught (draft for Americans).
Technically speaking, that wouldn't be a "note". 😉 Although, I do understand what you mean - I think. Are you talking about air currents due to HVAC systems? That's why I always use fabric windscreens on my sensitive condenser (valve) microphones. The foam ones don't do as good of a job down that low.
 
Technically speaking, that wouldn't be a "note". 😉

Are sounds from stopping records notes?

Although, I do understand what you mean - I think. Are you talking about air currents due to HVAC systems?

Yes, or anything else that causes air currents or slow air pressure variations.

That's why I always use fabric windscreens on my sensitive condenser (valve) microphones. The foam ones don't do as good of a job down that low.
I sometimes record birds from a large distance with condensor microphones with foam windscreens. The result is always a recording with strong, very-low-frequency wind sounds and very soft bird sounds. As long as it isn't clipped, a steep high-pass filter can remove the wind sounds.
 
Classical; Tellarc's recording of 1812 Canon fire 18Hz (apparently).
Perhaps car stereo test CDs, Bass outlaws use low bass. I think the lowest frequency is some gas cloud in space that a single resonance is measured in years. Although organ music does have low notes, they're often at low volume. Electronica and prog-rock have some low frequencies, then there's sound effect CDs/records.
 
Which genre has the lowest notes?

My guess is that it is old-skool Hip-Hop. My given reason is because of the scratching. To stop a spinning deck it must decelerate. During this process 40hz, briefly becomes 20, then 10, then 5 . . . you get the picture.

Today's synth based music and specifically "bass" centric synth goes to all frequencies, purposefully, well below 20hz to the point of not being a natural instrument simply because we can now.

Very best,
 
If you see home theatre as a genre, you got it. The LF output can go quite low.
With music, large organs (only really large ones) take the price.

If you manipulate an analoge record player and call that genre, you may see technical defects as music too.
Even as the result is very interesting music, a manhandled phono player is no real instrument.
 
The 24/96 recording of a space shuttle launch.
 

Attachments

  • spcsht.png
    spcsht.png
    19.2 KB · Views: 136
A 64' stop on a pipe organ is at 8Hz. As someone else mentioned, quite rare to have that big of a pipe. I think only a couple in the world have one. I've heard organs with 32' stops (16Hz) and what was interesting is it takes some time for the air to setup the resonance. And you feel it more than you hear it.

One of my favorite CDs is Telarc's Saint Saen Symphony No 3. It was recorded in Philly at the St Francis Church. The second half of the first movement just envelopes you in the pedal. It never gets old for me. I believe it is a 32' stop that I am delighting in.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SamAnytime