Hi,
I recently made 4x scoop bins & 4x midtops, and had a trial of the whole set.
The scoops have a very lovely base thump & Midtops very loud and clear, using in a 3 way setup.
My basic problem is when i am driving the scoops the clearity of the mids decreases, it is not due to the voltage problem, but because of the movement of the cones of mids, which tends to move a lot with the base thump. I suppose the base drive makes the mids coil move out of the magnetic gap which causes the mids to drop its clearity.
Please help me what should i do.
I have attached the photograph of my setup.
I recently made 4x scoop bins & 4x midtops, and had a trial of the whole set.
The scoops have a very lovely base thump & Midtops very loud and clear, using in a 3 way setup.
My basic problem is when i am driving the scoops the clearity of the mids decreases, it is not due to the voltage problem, but because of the movement of the cones of mids, which tends to move a lot with the base thump. I suppose the base drive makes the mids coil move out of the magnetic gap which causes the mids to drop its clearity.
Please help me what should i do.
I have attached the photograph of my setup.
Attachments
Hi Crissty,
Interesting. I deliberately tone back the mid on my outdoor stuff because as the volume goes up, they become overbearing. They sound rather muffled at low volumes but clear once some juice runs throught them.
You say it drops in clarity. Do you mean the level seems to drop?
How is this XO'd? Do you run the mids with a high pass or straight?
Is there any physical isolation between the woofer and the mid cabinets?
EDIT: How come the flag for Greenland is red and white? 😉
Interesting. I deliberately tone back the mid on my outdoor stuff because as the volume goes up, they become overbearing. They sound rather muffled at low volumes but clear once some juice runs throught them.
You say it drops in clarity. Do you mean the level seems to drop?
How is this XO'd? Do you run the mids with a high pass or straight?
Is there any physical isolation between the woofer and the mid cabinets?
EDIT: How come the flag for Greenland is red and white? 😉
Roll off the deep bass - use a high pass filter - another thing to do is make the back chamber smaller.
Foxx510 said:Can you move more of the mid freq to the top boxes without running out of spl capability?
Where do you crossover now? What drivers? What type of crossover?
Its a 3way setup c/o @ 160hz & 2.4Khz.
Now what i mean to say, when i m driving only the Mids (400w) x 4 and tops (100W) x 4, and base amps volume to minimum, the mids are very clear and loud, and the cone movement is very less.
But as i pump 4000W of base from scoops x 4 (1000W each), the base thump is so hard that your shirt & trouser also vibrate and dance to the music
, and the cone of the Mids (xmax is 4mm), also moves as if it is also pumping base from it, which means the cones definately move out of their magnetic gap.
As shown in the Picture the Midtop cabinets are directly kept on the scoops.
Now what i mean to say, when i m driving only the Mids (400w) x 4 and tops (100W) x 4, and base amps volume to minimum, the mids are very clear and loud, and the cone movement is very less.
But as i pump 4000W of base from scoops x 4 (1000W each), the base thump is so hard that your shirt & trouser also vibrate and dance to the music

As shown in the Picture the Midtop cabinets are directly kept on the scoops.
Are you saying the sound pressure from the bass cabs is moving the cones of the mid drivers? Does it happen if the mids are not running?
They are in separate cabs already, aren't they? See if there is a certain frequency that is exciting the midbox cabinet airspace, use a tone generator and sweep the low freq. You might need to address that freq by changing the midbox somehow.
Foxx510
Does it happen to excite the mids cabinet, havent heard like that anything before, the midtop enclosure is tuned to 45Hz.
C/o is 24db linkwitz set @ 160hz & 2.4Khz.
Still very confused why & how is it happening.
Does it happen to excite the mids cabinet, havent heard like that anything before, the midtop enclosure is tuned to 45Hz.
C/o is 24db linkwitz set @ 160hz & 2.4Khz.
Still very confused why & how is it happening.
crissty said:Foxx510
Does it happen to excite the mids cabinet, havent heard like that anything before, the midtop enclosure is tuned to 45Hz.
C/o is 24db linkwitz set @ 160hz & 2.4Khz.
Still very confused why & how is it happening.
air pressure - load your mids in a horn (if the drivers are suitable)
I'd simply position them a little further away from the scoops. And the fact that your clothes move to the rythm is not really bad, ist it ? 😀
Are you using these for disco or live music ?
Regards
Charles
Are you using these for disco or live music ?
Regards
Charles
Charles
give some idea how should the Midtops be positioned, should it not be on the top of scoop bins.
yes it is for the DJ Setup, now i have tested it outdoors.
give some idea how should the Midtops be positioned, should it not be on the top of scoop bins.
yes it is for the DJ Setup, now i have tested it outdoors.
I would try a higher tuning on the top boxes maybe, but you should see if it is a particular frequency setting the top boxes resonating.
OT: ohh.. my.. god... that is one incredibly well built and beautiful PA system
An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.
give some idea how should the Midtops be positioned, should it not be on the top of scoop bins.
With some disco system that I have (though much much les beefy than yours) we often "flew" the tops and placed the woofers close together. Stereo reproiduction of bass wasn't that good anymore that way but punchg was increased due to mutual coupling.
The tops might be built as closed box of quite small volume this would reduce cone-movement from external SPL as well. Although you would loose the possibility to use them "stand-alone" in situations where the big bass-bins aren't need.
Regards
Charles
phase_accurate said:
Although you would loose the possibility to use them "stand-alone" in situations where the big bass-bins aren't need.
Regards
Charles
Although you would loose the possibility to use them "stand-alone" in situations where the big bass-bins aren't need.
[/B][/QUOTE]
Thats the reason i have buit it, and tuned to 45Hz, so i would be able to use it as fullrange in small places.
can you post some pictures
[/B][/QUOTE]
Thats the reason i have buit it, and tuned to 45Hz, so i would be able to use it as fullrange in small places.
phase_accurate said:
we often "flew" the tops
can you post some pictures
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Live Sound
- PA Systems
- Scoop Bins + Midtop problem