With all due respect, but this is the kind of review you read in any audiophile magazine about a $10000+ 2-way bookshelf covered in leather.
I've built myself a pair of TV speakers out of PVC tubes, hidden behind the TV. I've spent countless of nice evenings with them and would like to pronounce them fantastic (seriously).
PS: I do think the LX521 are exceptionally well engineered speakers.
My wife said "Plutot bien !" and pronounced them as spectacular just seing it and also ask if maxi instead mini was possible ! 😱 Suspect it's a liitle freudian thought !
Well you asked about leather on mini speakers, why not on the tube or even fur ! ... sorry foam...
Seriously, does a LX Mini do bass as a 12" mid bass does or the push pull of its big brother does ? Don't think so to have a 8" Seas Proac D15 at 35 hz - 3 DB : it do bass... bu not the same bass as a bigger speaker can do. It doesn't mean the sound is bad, Proac D15 have a nice and very accurate tonal color ! But sometimes ROck n' ROll ask for more !
Well, are the bass and the treble not have an intimatly dependance then asking about a subjective good tonal balance ? Is there a ratio or are just the highere frequencies not necessary for clearness, subjective transcient and impact with bass to mid-bass drums e.g. .... Really want to know as two serious fellows (Papa & JG) have a serious good testimonie.
A new paradigm... new theories (not about just polar response) but for the width of the frequency range ?????
Well you asked about leather on mini speakers, why not on the tube or even fur ! ... sorry foam...
Seriously, does a LX Mini do bass as a 12" mid bass does or the push pull of its big brother does ? Don't think so to have a 8" Seas Proac D15 at 35 hz - 3 DB : it do bass... bu not the same bass as a bigger speaker can do. It doesn't mean the sound is bad, Proac D15 have a nice and very accurate tonal color ! But sometimes ROck n' ROll ask for more !
Well, are the bass and the treble not have an intimatly dependance then asking about a subjective good tonal balance ? Is there a ratio or are just the highere frequencies not necessary for clearness, subjective transcient and impact with bass to mid-bass drums e.g. .... Really want to know as two serious fellows (Papa & JG) have a serious good testimonie.
A new paradigm... new theories (not about just polar response) but for the width of the frequency range ?????
Last edited:
Omni vs. lxmini
Dave,
I got the impression that the mini is intended as an overall improvement over the Pluto and that the altered radiation pattern is just one factor. Not sure which would sound better in my room. My walls are brick w/ no treatment right now so I suspect that side attenuation would improve intelligibility. I'd like to be able to play around with the pattern a bit if possible. I do have at least 3' between the sides and rear of the speakers.
I am also concerned that removing the rear cylinder on the mini would necessitate EQ'ing the HF driver to the point of distortion due to front & back cancellation..
BTW, Totally confused about the phasing SL recommends. Makes no sense to me...
Dan
Dave,
I got the impression that the mini is intended as an overall improvement over the Pluto and that the altered radiation pattern is just one factor. Not sure which would sound better in my room. My walls are brick w/ no treatment right now so I suspect that side attenuation would improve intelligibility. I'd like to be able to play around with the pattern a bit if possible. I do have at least 3' between the sides and rear of the speakers.
I am also concerned that removing the rear cylinder on the mini would necessitate EQ'ing the HF driver to the point of distortion due to front & back cancellation..
BTW, Totally confused about the phasing SL recommends. Makes no sense to me...
Dan
Dan: Is this plot what's troubling you?
The large null centered at 850 Hz happens when the polarity of one drivers is reversed from the normal connection. This is only done as a test of how well the crossover is doing it's job. The Linkwitz-Riley crossovers are in-phase at the crossover frequency. By reversing one of the drivers a null should appear at the crossover. It's a very convenient test. The orange trace is the system response.
Jeff
The large null centered at 850 Hz happens when the polarity of one drivers is reversed from the normal connection. This is only done as a test of how well the crossover is doing it's job. The Linkwitz-Riley crossovers are in-phase at the crossover frequency. By reversing one of the drivers a null should appear at the crossover. It's a very convenient test. The orange trace is the system response.
Jeff
driver phase
Which is the correct connection for the LR 2nd order crossover. By reversing the phase of one driver, relative to the correct connection, you can check for the null. See:
http://www.linkwitzlab.com/crossovers.htm://
Which is the correct connection for the LR 2nd order crossover. By reversing the phase of one driver, relative to the correct connection, you can check for the null. See:
http://www.linkwitzlab.com/crossovers.htm://
The "tweeter" is an FU10RB Seas driver. The woofer is the same as used in the Pluto.
Dave.
Certainly the tubes would look nice wrapped in veneer. Since the curve is in one direction only, one could use the veneer with the birch backing. It's thicker but completely fool proof. The only time the thickness is a problem is when one can see the edge of th e veneer , and with this design there are no edges uncovered! Overlap the seam at the rear, cut through them both with a razor knife, then glue and there you go..
I am seriously considering these right now due to the fact that I will be moving into a 800sqft Condo in a few months for a new job.
I was planning on a larger build until I found out about this move late last week. Seeing as how even a SEOS10 and 10" midbass will be a little more imposing than this in such a small family room I think this might be a better option.
I was planning on a larger build until I found out about this move late last week. Seeing as how even a SEOS10 and 10" midbass will be a little more imposing than this in such a small family room I think this might be a better option.
May I ask how it was amplified when you heard them? I am curious how well the full range driver used in this would work with one of your Firstwatt amps even though Linkwitz states 4 channels of 50-100w.
Thks for the info, the concept of LXMini looks like an interesting project to experiment on, I have left over of 4" FR driver and 6" woofer to conduct some experimentations on this speakers configuration, like some of other projects I have done, e.g. JK's NaO, etc.
I own measuring instrumentations, software and hardware to conduct measurements on this project, hopefully I should be able make it to work.
It was driven by 4 channels of an Emotiva 5 channel amplifier with I believe
has a 100 watt/ch rating.
The FW amplifiers do not have enough power for the bottom, and the gain
of the high pass on the dsp unit would have to be raised about 10 dB in order
to have something like a J2 drive the top. SL informs me that this 10 dB
would be do-able.
😎
amps for miniLX
...not all that familiar with the new mini, but wasn't SL keeping the HP gain down for an enormous boost on the low end? so a preamp might be called for on the HP portion to help a FW product, and a high gain AB amp on the bottom. maybe even something by Papa: AB bipolar which started life as a commercial order that fell through but might be ideal amp for this section?:
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/pass-labs/227503-ab100-class-ab-power-amplifier.html
or am I missing something? (which should not really suprise anybody
)
...not all that familiar with the new mini, but wasn't SL keeping the HP gain down for an enormous boost on the low end? so a preamp might be called for on the HP portion to help a FW product, and a high gain AB amp on the bottom. maybe even something by Papa: AB bipolar which started life as a commercial order that fell through but might be ideal amp for this section?:
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/pass-labs/227503-ab100-class-ab-power-amplifier.html
or am I missing something? (which should not really suprise anybody
)just an afterthought: a few selected papa amps might be able to do better on the top portion (minus the added heat 
) , if SL used a higher sensitivity 4ohm version. right now both of his drivers are 8ohm, right? (or am I missing it again?; well the safe thing for me is probably to shut up now🙄)
) , if SL used a higher sensitivity 4ohm version. right now both of his drivers are 8ohm, right? (or am I missing it again?; well the safe thing for me is probably to shut up now🙄)
All he has to do is reduce the 10 dB attenuation in the dsp high pass and I
think it will work out with a 18-20 dB gain 10-20 watt amp.
😎
think it will work out with a 18-20 dB gain 10-20 watt amp.
😎
There is more boosting EQ programmed into the HF section than the LF section so removing the 10db HF attenuation might cause a clipping issue. Regardless of EQ settings, the voltage output limitation of the standard 2x4 miniDSP unit still remains, so a power amplifier would need appropriate sensitivity to not compromise the gain structure. SL has already investigated this for the LF section (as noted on his site) but I'm not sure about the HF section (if attenuation removed.)
No offense to Mr. Pass, but I'm not sure why someone would want to use a multi-thousand dollar amplifier for just one portion of a system like this when one of the main attractions is the relatively low cost it can be assembled for. You could build approximately four complete LXmini systems (with Emotiva amps) for the price of one Pass J2 amplifier. 🙂
Cheers,
Dave.
No offense to Mr. Pass, but I'm not sure why someone would want to use a multi-thousand dollar amplifier for just one portion of a system like this when one of the main attractions is the relatively low cost it can be assembled for. You could build approximately four complete LXmini systems (with Emotiva amps) for the price of one Pass J2 amplifier. 🙂
Cheers,
Dave.
Pass amp for LXmini
But one can make a DIY FW design for pretty cheap. F5 comes to mind. I'm intrigued by the possibilities of Nelson and Siegfried collaborating. I've admired both of these guys for a long time.
Jeff
But one can make a DIY FW design for pretty cheap. F5 comes to mind. I'm intrigued by the possibilities of Nelson and Siegfried collaborating. I've admired both of these guys for a long time.
Jeff
😕
So the HP out of the miniDSP is phase-reversed? This will confuse many week-enders like me....
So the HP out of the miniDSP is phase-reversed? This will confuse many week-enders like me....
- Status
- Not open for further replies.