• WARNING: Tube/Valve amplifiers use potentially LETHAL HIGH VOLTAGES.
    Building, troubleshooting and testing of these amplifiers should only be
    performed by someone who is thoroughly familiar with
    the safety precautions around high voltages.

Laminations for OT

Read the datasheet, to me it looks like plain vanilla PT grade iron, nothing to write home about.
Not bad, not special,in any case Guitar OTs are LoFi anyway.
No unicorn blood anywhere to be found, if anything winding geometry and interleaving which do affect parasitic inductance, coupling, parasitic capacitance, resonant peaks, are WAY more important.
Jim Marshall was as cheap as any successful large scale manufacturer or he would have failed.
Orange and Hiwatt did.
Both used expensive HiFi rated Partridge Transformers (and expensive Fane speakers).
They hade rich and famous customers ... that alone is not enough.
Marshall catered to the masses.

Don't obsess over iron, that one looks good enough and then some.

Just guessing: 660 might mean the steel type and 50 might be lam thickness.
2.4W/kg loss at 50 Hz? Wow!

Cheapest available here in Argentina is 2.2W/kg, premium is thin lamination grain oriented 1.8W/kg, go figure.

That steel is not grain oriented, they mention "average of transversal and longitudinal" which is clear enough.

They also present as a special feature that it is "semi treated" , then explain that after punching EIs you can retreat them again in an oven, because punching which is a violent mechanical action changes magnetic properties for the worse.
True enough .... only you can also do the same with any other lamination 😄

I bet your currently available lamination will do fine, and OTs will sound GOOD.
Just wind and mount them, and post results. 👍🏻
I will order 0.35mm Z11 laminate (used in transformers by HiFi enthusiasts locally) and the cheapest junk laminate I can find from China - with the same core size. I can then evaluate the same winding on both laminates and be able to measure and listen objectively. I have a looper pedal somewhere, to loop the same riff on both laminates. This will be highly educational! Will remind myself to post sound samples here after testing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMFahey
It's possible that any sort of winding impregnating material will slightly increase interwinding and inter-layer capacitance, since the dielectric constant for any material at all will be higher than that of air. I have wound output transformers for tube amps and experimented with that, measuring a pair of identical transformers the same in every way except that one has no impregnant while the other does. First major resonance occurred at a much higher frequency for the transformer NOT using the filler.

The more porous your dielectric is, the higher the capacitance jump is. If using a dense paper, for example, with a measured epsilon of 3, my practical results from ceresin impregnation have led to 3.5. However, for a paper with a lower density and measured epsilon of 2.2, it would still skyrocket to 3.2. The small difference in the secondary setup is due to the ceresin having a lower epsilon than paper fibers, so the dielectrics kind of come to an average value, depending of their distribution ratio across the dielectric area.

The abundant capacitance within a typical OPT lies between high-impedance windings and presumably (grounded) secondary. These are the most critical layers, where one would desire the lowest epsilon dielectric possible.


If using solid dielectrics like mylar, polycarbonate or teflon, wax boiling / impregnation should give little to no difference, as there is nothing to fill, except turn-to-turn capacitance, which is of laughable value within an OPT.
 
Wax does work. It's not magic, it's dampening. However, not everyone likes the signature of waxes and various ones sound different.
Come to think about it, this sound like a very convenient method. And easy to disassemble if need be. But, won't it get awfully messy when the transformer is getting hot? I mean, the melting point can't be that high, right?
 
Last edited:
Do you mean veneer glue? As for polyurethane, I think there is variety among, but mostly, quoting:

Most polyurethanes have melting temperatures in the range of 150-250°F (65-121°C),

As does mine. It doesn't widthstand the temperature of hot wax, it melts.
What is the glue's purpose?
1. Impregnating the dielectric?
2. Fixing a transformer winding in place
3. Fixing wire outputs or winding edges in place?
 
Hi
I varnish with a brush layer by layer to block the coils mechanically

For wood glue, I 'm thinking about "white glue" for assembly, polyurethane sealer for parquet that I'm using is also water base.
I dry it in an oven at 100°C.
Parasitic capacities become less important during drying.

Here a pics off my last design : 6P36C circlotron at 20Khz
Yan
 

Attachments

  • 20240124_183228.jpg
    20240124_183228.jpg
    123.3 KB · Views: 66
Last edited:
It's possible that any sort of winding impregnating material will slightly increase interwinding and inter-layer capacitance, since the dielectric constant for any material at all will be higher than that of air. I have wound output transformers for tube amps and experimented with that, measuring a pair of identical transformers the same in every way except that one has no impregnant while the other does. First major resonance occurred at a much higher frequency for the transformer NOT using the filler.
What was the filler? What was the insulation material? What material did you use for the bobbin? What material did you use for the EI's?
 
It was quite a while since I worked on that, so I do not remember vendor details anymore. I think the filler material was called Formvar, and laminations were 4% oriented grain silicon steel for the OPTs. Some other steel type was used for the power transformers. Don't remember bobbin material details except that the thin cardboard-like material was designed just for that purpose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMFahey