Is this a bad crossover layout.

I am experimenting a bit and added a few more components to an existing crossover circuit board. I was a bit worried about heat but wasn’t aware that coupling between inductors was also a thing to worry about.

I need to add an LPad to this and found a spot that would work, but I’m thinking I probably should pull everything apart and mount them to a piece of timber rather than trying to squeeze more on.

Does anyone think it’s ok as is?

IMG_4211.jpeg
 
The one on the right is series to the woofer, the middle is across the tweeter, top is series to mid and the ferrite core on the left is across the mid.

The top one would be coming off the board if I add a series resistor prior to the mid circuit, or the other thing I’m considering is an LPad directly on the back of the mid driver
 
I could outline a way to test for coupling.

To cut to the chase, the top inductor would be the one to move (if one were the number) since it is involved in both of the (visually apparent) potential couplings.
 
I am experimenting a bit and added a few more components to an existing crossover circuit board. I was a bit worried about heat but wasn’t aware that coupling between inductors was also a thing to worry about.

I need to add an LPad to this and found a spot that would work, but I’m thinking I probably should pull everything apart and mount them to a piece of timber rather than trying to squeeze more on.

Does anyone think it’s ok as is?

View attachment 1459709
For Reference....
 

Attachments

  • signal-2023-03-17-192631_002.jpg
    signal-2023-03-17-192631_002.jpg
    40.7 KB · Views: 28
I'd also point out that while these two look to be the same case (looking across the board from the side), the one in the diagram is placed on a flat surface so it's not in the middle (the one standing on it's rim is higher than the one flat on the bench), so it's more like the one I circled in orange above.

IMG_4211.jpeg
 
Turn the one marked "-42", 90 deg.

Now all the three inductors are orthogonally oriented - which is good.

But as Allen is indicating - for this to be effective, their centers (of gravity) need to be in one and the same plane - which is not so easy to achieve... haven't considered that I have to say... is it true?

//
 
Hmm, yes it gets more complicated than one assume... perhaps best to test in reality with pink noise generator and a analyser. Perhaps distance is the safest bet 🙂

Had to create this... need to study it more...

orthocoilfield.gif


//