[snip]I have never heard of a mass production manufactrer to claim that their low cost equipment sounds better than any specific high-end one.This is one of the very few places where you can read such claims.
This is an interesting observation. Why would that be? I'm pretty sure that a mass production manufacturer could 'prove' that their amp sounds better than a 10x more expensive amp. But they don't. Why?
jd
Yes that's true. But one should remember that in all but the most pathological cases, that voltage model is valid in the context of the cable impedance.
Talking to Dr. van den Hul (eat your heart out JC 😉 ) a few weeks ago, he told me his carbon cables have a resistance of about 28 ohms per meter. Even with such an extremely high cable resistance, one can argue that there is no audible impact of resistance period, except some possible very minor level differences which are easily corrected by twiddling the volume control, of course.
jd
Did Mr.van den Hul tell you that his carbon cables are a waste of money or something similar?I bet not.He considers his carbon cables great sounding as you can read in his website.Have you ever listened to one?If yes,did you hear any difference compared to other interconnects?
A Pioneer cheap amp for example can't be in anyway better than say an audio research.When you talk of serious mass production manufacturers,talk about serious high-end manufacturers too.There are many of both kinds.I have never heard of a mass production manufactrer to claim that their low cost equipment sounds better than any specific high-end one.This is one of the very few places where you can read such claims.
I'll specifically make a "similar" claim - my Pioneer receiver sounds as good as (not "better", I don't know that) any "reputable" Hi-end amp - say Audio Research. Both are inaudible (well I am assuming the Audio Research is, if its not then its broken.)
Did Mr.van den Hul tell you that his carbon cables are a waste of money or something similar?I bet not.He considers his carbon cables great sounding as you can read in his website.Have you ever listened to one?If yes,did you hear any difference compared to other interconnects?
No,
Yes, casually,
No.
jd
LOL. Like the one Earl uses in his demo's
I don't know and haven't heard what Earl is using in his demo's.I used to do the same "trick" of using a cheap ampand still do when I want to help someone to concentrate on say a cartridge🙂But I can if I'm asked to use another amp to achieve a better sound.I have also never heard any manufacturer(low or high-end)to try and promote their amplifiers because they measure well.In fact,even the low-end manufacturers say their amplifiers sound good and ask potential buyers to judge them for that,not measurements.
I'll specifically make a "similar" claim - my Pioneer receiver sounds as good as (not "better", I don't know that) any "reputable" Hi-end amp - say Audio Research. Both are inaudible (well I am assuming the Audio Research is, if its not then its broken.)
Just received my new $0.79 interconnects. They sound so much more the same as the old Monster cable that was a leftover from "darker" times 🙂
If you only got to Monster Cable, your times were fortunately not that dark.😉Just received my new $0.79 interconnects. They sound so much more the same as the old Monster cable that was a leftover from "darker" times 🙂
Dan
I can give you my metric. The speakers, room, and the quality of the recording are by far the most important aspects of the reproduction chain. Unless the rest of the chain is broken, those will be the things that are most important.
I have never disagreed with any of the above,or that they are not the most important.
But you need non-"cheap" equipment and "good" wires to reproduce this "don't care if they are well recorded" music?I am buying recorded music that I like,and I don't care if it is well recorded.Happy now?
Fascinating🙂
Ok, so what does your room, speakers and recordings look like, given their importance for the music?I have never disagreed with any of the above,or that they are not the most important.
Ah, so you completely disassociate what you hear, from the "cheap" Pioneer receiver quality components...and wire...it passed through to get there.
Like Magic🙂
Or maybe you really can afford the actual performers to physically play in your living room. But then why do you need an electro-acoustic reproduction system...and wires???😕
I do not own an audio research amp.My amp cost me $1350 and have chosen it for its contribution in my system,room and taste,after I have compared it to some more expensive and some less expensive amps.Sorry I have not listen to a Pioneer receiver.
But you have, just like Andre has "heard" Mogami cables, but was oblivious. Almost every time you listen to a recording.Sorry I have not listen to a Pioneer receiver.
Yet you can't hear them, can you (or maybe you will now that you've been told 😉)?
Strange eh? 🙂
But you have, just like Andre has "heard" Mogami cables, but was oblivious. Almost every time you listen to a recording.
Yet you can't hear them, can you (or maybe you will now that you've been told 😉)?
Strange eh? 🙂
I have commented on not hearing a Pioneer receiver.I prefer GOTHAM PRO cables if it is of any interest to you🙂
No need to repeat. We understood the first time, that you can't hear something that is inaudible. No one can.Repeat:My comment was about not having heard any Pioneer receiver.
Just like Andre couldn't "hear" the Mogami cables...any more than you or I could. 😉
cheers,
AJ
No need to repeat. We understood the first time, that you can't hear something that is inaudible. No one can.
Just like Andre couldn't "hear" the Mogami cables...any more than you or I could. 😉
cheers,
AJ
A recorded cd,lp etc....sound the way they do.This does not mean they wouldn't sound any different if any other cables were used during the recording etc.....
A recorded cd,lp etc....sound the way they do.This does not mean they wouldn't sound any different if any other cables were used during the recording etc.....
Do you think that if they did sound different then some measurement would also show the difference?
A recorded cd,lp etc....sound the way they do.This does not mean they wouldn't sound any different if any other cables were used during the recording etc.....
Yes, a defective cable could change the recording. But like with reproduction gear there are other things involved that have a MUCH bigger impact on the end result than cables (e.g. mikes and their positioning).
I've never spoken to a recording engineer that had an opinion about cable sound. They have strong opinions about hum, hiss, broken cables and bad soldering.
Then they have strong opinions about the money they get and the time they have for a recording job. Both is in very short supply. That's why I quit.
Do you think that if they did sound different then some measurement would also show the difference?
I'm not sure if you are asking me about measuring the music's difference.
What I know,is that my recordings sound more realistic when I use the cables I've mentioned before.I'm not selling them,they are not the most expensive we could afford.We have not measured any of the cable samples we were offered either.We could choose from known professional cable manufacturers,all respected by many professionals.
Unstated "blind" listening...
Maybe a replacement thread "I don't believe INET discussions about cables make a difference. Any Input??":D😀😉
If seeing is believing, I wonder how all the believers can hear a difference between components, what with all the unknown wiring, transistors, capacitors, cables, inductors, diodes, etc. "Blinded" by default every time one listens to equipment (unless of course they listen to their components "naked" so to speak...🙄😕😱
Is It Vishay, or is it NGK???😉
John L.
Even if it's not closed, do you see anything productive ever coming out of it?
It's 7 years old and over 14,000 pots deep and it's got us no further down the road than where things stood 30 years ago.
se
Maybe a replacement thread "I don't believe INET discussions about cables make a difference. Any Input??":D😀😉
If seeing is believing, I wonder how all the believers can hear a difference between components, what with all the unknown wiring, transistors, capacitors, cables, inductors, diodes, etc. "Blinded" by default every time one listens to equipment (unless of course they listen to their components "naked" so to speak...🙄😕😱
Is It Vishay, or is it NGK???😉
John L.
That's awesome!
The concept of 'differential' might come in handy.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Design & Build
- Parts
- I don't believe cables make a difference, any input?