How would you incorporate a supertweeter in the Woden Design Vulcan or Kirishima?

It's a matter of personal choice really, since implementations of this type are not about technical perfection (they can't be) & more a question of individual taste. Fostex themselves suggested a T90a with a 0.33uF - 0.68uF series capacitor, wired in the same electrical polarity, which should be a reasonable starting point for experimenting. Make sure it's as close as possible to the main unit.
 
I believe the FE206EN being an 8" driver is a bit too large to integrate with a supertweeter since the dispersions won't match in the crossover region. My suggestions would be:
  1. Turn the speaker into a FAST setup with a smaller 2-3" FR driver crossed at ~ 500-1000 hz.
  2. Replace the FE206EN with a coaxial driver.
  3. Add a large waveguide loaded dome or compression tweeter, crossed probably at ~ 1000 - 1600 hz.
 
I believe the FE206EN being an 8" driver is a bit too large to integrate with a supertweeter since the dispersions won't match in the crossover region.
Technically correct, although partly assumes that the 8in nominal diameter is the basis; in practice it's smaller as the whizzer is direct-coupled to the coil. They won't match anyway but a little better than implied. As noted however, in the majority of cases when someone is adding a supertweeter to a wideband, outright refined technical performance is not usually a priority.

My suggestions would be:
  1. Turn the speaker into a FAST setup with a smaller 2-3" FR driver crossed at ~ 500-1000 hz.
There is no room in the enclosures available to do that, unless you are proposing independent satellites. If that's the case, the OP might as well junk the entire speakers & start again from scratch, since if you're going to make a pair of 6ft horns for an 8in wideband, it's unlikely you're going to want to use them simply as a woofer.

  1. Replace the FE206EN with a coaxial driver.
I designed Kirishima & Vulcan for the specified units, not an unspecified coaxial driver, which would require a response charactertistic (as well as T/S parameters) close to the units in question for them to function properly.

  1. Add a large waveguide loaded dome or compression tweeter, crossed probably at ~ 1000 - 1600 hz.
There is no room available for that in the enclosures, so it would need to be an additional sub-enclosure. I suspect however that most people who build a speaker of this type don't want a regular multiway.
 
Last edited:
An easy and cheap way to improve the treble a bit is to add a rear tweeter. It works fine with Ron Clark type curved horns when you have som distance to the rear wall. Make sure to place the tweeter in the center line off the fullrange. I have had it in A126 with Daves treated drivers with a Dayton NDF20-6
and now in FH3 with Daves A7.3 and AKAI orthydynamic tweeters. Temporary attached with blue tack pads.
Wire tweeters in phase, pad it down 4-5 dB and select a capacitor to your own personal taste.

Anders
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5199.jpg
    IMG_5199.jpg
    58.9 KB · Views: 117
Audax TM025F15. The Super 12 originally ran a titanium dome unit. It was discontinued shortly after John Wyckoff died; his partner wanted to keep Hammer going, at least for a time though, so she asked Dick Olsher to help select a replacement; this was the one he came up with, and was used in the S12 kit from that point until things were finally wound down.