Hi all,
long time since I posted something here, but reading a lot!
I was working on a P1.7 for 4-5 months (afterhours), to drive a Aleph 5 I built the year before (balanced).
I am not at all an electronics engineer, just an 'interested' hobbyist and trying-to-be-a-smart-guy.
This Aleph5 is such a success in building and sounding I thought this P1.7 would be easy-peasy.
However...
Building a power amp is really simple comparing to a preamp. You put in a signal, and you hope it comes out amplified and sounding at least better than what you had before, with just a power button that stops it from doing that.
A preamp however, there is a smaller amount of amplification to do, with smaller signals, relative to that noise is bigger. So there's much attention to grounding to be done. You also want to switch inputs, mute while switching, choose a volume. And find out a way to control all of that, by means of knobs, IRremote and maybe even bluetooth and/or rs232 (i'm a home automation engineer). You want it to trigger poweramps, and because everything Nelson Pass designs needs hours of warm-up, you want to time that to make the max of your precious listening time. There are different psu's, voltages to work with, for control, relays, etc... Meanwhile, you want to have it look the part to impress non-audiophile/electronics friends, and while at that control an old but very very good design very 2022-ish.
A preamp is not just an amp. As I read it elsewhere, it is the
centerpiece of all your equipment.
So I ended up soldering the amplification part, psu's I found pcb's for, but (as I can't design my own pcb's) also break my head around the relay-volumecontrol, input selection and then the whole control part of that. I had to write C++ code for the first time in life, which I liked very much, see the above 2022-ish approach.
I made a lot of stupid errors, as well as real beginner-errors. I managed to make a real nice (almost-finished) case. I ended up with 'the thing' on the pictures below. It is not completely finished, but I've had it for now, just some details.
It is working and sounding just incredible, comparing to what it replaces. The image is much wider, but maybe not as deep. Dynamics and transparancy are really remarkable. Sometimes I find it to sound 'flat', or with some sort of 'sawtooth' in it. Have to resolve that.
Things that concern me:
- It has 3 balanced inputs, and 3 unbalanced, of which just one is working, not in a hurry for that
- My scope showes an output that is not correct, but the scope is even older than the P1.7 design and in bad shape... I will break my head over that in short future. If the amp would sound as the the scope image looks, it wouldn't sound at all.
- Further software writing, that freaking C++ language, to implement a lot of things, of which timed start is most important to me (or the home automation control part, even more work).
- Finding/calculating a nice volume lookuptable, to have less but more meaningful steps.
- Allthough not critical, the fets get hotter than expected. All are mounted to the same piece of aluminium (not a heatsink, just a thick alu profile). There's a temp sensor in that as well, showing 50°C after 2hours on-time. From then on the sound is best and doesn't get better anymore.
- I find it to sound slightly better with balanced sources (my CD-player and phono preamp), even when matching SPL as good as possible on ear.
And then just one or two real questions concerning gain:
The lowest gain setting is what works best for me. Then i use low attenuation levels (high volume setting), being able to max it out. It is really loud then but speakers can have more (they are only 90dB). The higher gain setting is not workable, as the lowest volume setting is still to loud then. Is there some advice for that?
That working unbalanced input is used for a dac. As being just theory: it sounds 6dB quieter than balanced inputs. I'm working with an extra relay that grounds IN- when an unbalanced in is selected. What's the best way to match this volume level to the balanced ones?
- can I switch input gain at the same time, with relays, while it's on? I guess so. But: -6db for unbal, then from 1,3 to 9,7 will make it sound louder than balanced.
- is it better to calculate (in software) a 6db higher volume setting, and applying that without being visible to the user (which is me offcourse ;-) ) Then it would max out earlier.
- As I'm using a modest Chord DAC, i can but didn't try to crank up the output from 2V to 3V. There's no own volume control on the dac. How many db does 1V mean then?
So this is a lot of text, I guess every thought of the 4-5 building months are spit out.
All in all, this was one hell of a project, for the unprofessional me which I am.
Mr. Nelson Pass: thank you a lot for bringing me all this incredible and affordable sound quality, but above all and most important albeit maybe unintended, all this acquired knowledge. (I am addicted to tech knowledge of all sorts. For that and the fun of it, in my younger days I took a car and engine completely apart and remade it but better, stronger, safer and faster, only to understand how cars work).
Also thanks to this wonderful forum and offcourse its users!
Regards,
Dieter