Hardware for high quality software based DSP
- By JeroenD
- Digital Line Level
- 42 Replies
Hello, I am new to this forum but reading already for quite some time interesting questions and answers.
Over the years I developed myself a nice audio system which I really enjoy (system components listed below). I did investigate what is the best option for me to improve my system and I think replacing the analog active filter I use by a DSP based system would be a nice next step. I want to move to DSP based crossover, phase correction, time alignment, room correction and have some questions related. I think PC software based DSP is the best way for me to go for.
I am planning to use Acourate for measurement and creating the filters.
At the moment I am using Roon and I did read Roon can handle these filters so that could be interesting for me. Otherwise JRiver is one of the best option as far as I understood.
I now try to make the right design decisions regarding the hardware and interfaces to use.
Question 1: I am thinking of using an fanless NUC with i5 or i7 and 8GB RAM. Any advice on this?
Question 2: I am planning to add 2 more Metrum DAC’s to my system to create a DSP based 3-way system. What is the best option to connect these DAC’s to the NUC? Use the USB port of the Metrum and connect 3 USB cables from NUC to the 3 Metrum DAC’s? I have the feeling this can generate timing (clock) problems. But is this more theoretical are also audible?
Or is it better to add an audio card to the NUC with for example 3x AES/EBU output. Or is it better to use something like “XMOS USB Digital Interface 32/384khz AES EBU” like the XMOS USB Digital Interface 32/384khz AES EBU TCXO Alimentation 230V Silver - Audiophonics or SINGXER SU-2 USB Digital Interface 32bit 768khz DSD1024 SPDIF AES/EBU I2S HDMI LVDS - Audiophonics ?
Or do you advice a different way to connect the DSP NUC to the DAC’s?
In short my current audio system:
• Magnepan MG20.1 (fully modified, silver foil wiring, no internal crossover, all external with high quality components)
• 2x Velodyne DD12 (I am not using the bass panel of the MG20.1 because it has a negative influence on the mid panel and tweeter. The 2x DD12 replaces the bass panels and using the internal DSP I already improved the low level frequency domain in combination with my room.)
• Metrum Ambre source
• Metrum Adagio DAC (volume control normally not used)
• Audio Research LS26 (modified with ODAM caps)
• Magnepan active analog filter (crossover between bass and mid/high)
• Krell KSA 300S (upgraded version) and Audio Research VS115 (I use 1 of both to power the MG20.1. The Krell is better in controlling the mid panel and the VS115 creates a nicer and bigger soundstage with the big ribbon tweeter)
• Interlinks Transparent Balanced reference and speaker wires self made using Mundorf 44mm foil and Teflon isolator.
Over the years I developed myself a nice audio system which I really enjoy (system components listed below). I did investigate what is the best option for me to improve my system and I think replacing the analog active filter I use by a DSP based system would be a nice next step. I want to move to DSP based crossover, phase correction, time alignment, room correction and have some questions related. I think PC software based DSP is the best way for me to go for.
I am planning to use Acourate for measurement and creating the filters.
At the moment I am using Roon and I did read Roon can handle these filters so that could be interesting for me. Otherwise JRiver is one of the best option as far as I understood.
I now try to make the right design decisions regarding the hardware and interfaces to use.
Question 1: I am thinking of using an fanless NUC with i5 or i7 and 8GB RAM. Any advice on this?
Question 2: I am planning to add 2 more Metrum DAC’s to my system to create a DSP based 3-way system. What is the best option to connect these DAC’s to the NUC? Use the USB port of the Metrum and connect 3 USB cables from NUC to the 3 Metrum DAC’s? I have the feeling this can generate timing (clock) problems. But is this more theoretical are also audible?
Or is it better to add an audio card to the NUC with for example 3x AES/EBU output. Or is it better to use something like “XMOS USB Digital Interface 32/384khz AES EBU” like the XMOS USB Digital Interface 32/384khz AES EBU TCXO Alimentation 230V Silver - Audiophonics or SINGXER SU-2 USB Digital Interface 32bit 768khz DSD1024 SPDIF AES/EBU I2S HDMI LVDS - Audiophonics ?
Or do you advice a different way to connect the DSP NUC to the DAC’s?
In short my current audio system:
• Magnepan MG20.1 (fully modified, silver foil wiring, no internal crossover, all external with high quality components)
• 2x Velodyne DD12 (I am not using the bass panel of the MG20.1 because it has a negative influence on the mid panel and tweeter. The 2x DD12 replaces the bass panels and using the internal DSP I already improved the low level frequency domain in combination with my room.)
• Metrum Ambre source
• Metrum Adagio DAC (volume control normally not used)
• Audio Research LS26 (modified with ODAM caps)
• Magnepan active analog filter (crossover between bass and mid/high)
• Krell KSA 300S (upgraded version) and Audio Research VS115 (I use 1 of both to power the MG20.1. The Krell is better in controlling the mid panel and the VS115 creates a nicer and bigger soundstage with the big ribbon tweeter)
• Interlinks Transparent Balanced reference and speaker wires self made using Mundorf 44mm foil and Teflon isolator.