Hallo guys,
this is my first thread after reading a lot for years on this website. So thank you for all your input. I dont speak english very well, so sorry for that. Now I want to design a new speaker and it should be my last one (at least for some decades)...
Points to consider:
- My room is 5,5x4,5x2,6m. Listening Distance is 3,8m. My avg. (for me) loud listening at 3,8m is about 75-80db avg. with 85-90 db peaks. So the speakers should produce around 85db. avg. with 95-100db peaks, to have some headroom.
- Musictaste is very wide. Only thing I dont listen to is stuff like heavy metal, large orchestras...
- It should be a 3-way. No 2-way. No Di'appolito.
- It should be activ with dsp.
- It should allow to swap amps (so no Hypex but miniDSP)
- It should use the T25B and M74B (I already have them)
- Passiv Notchfilter will applied to lower distortion of the resonance peak of the M74B
- It should have a nice dispersion, but dont use waveguide (because my son is 1,5y old and I dont want to have beryllium exposed to him (atm using a TW34BWNG in my speakers that have to go because of it)
- Room is my homeoffice, music, homecinema, gaming room. So room treatment is an option. A little bit is done already and I will continue.
- It should looks like build by a company, not a diy dude. Similar to Rockport Orion
- It should cost overall arround 5-6000€ without amps.
- Solidstate Amp for woofer and Tubes for the Midrangdome and the Tweeter.
- It can be a bigger floorstanding speaker but no refrigerator.
- I want to do some fancy stuff, even if it wont help much (Tuned Mass Damper at the top of the speaker)
- Building time should be arround 6-12 months.
Tweeter is BlieSMa T25B crossed at 2750hz LR4 passiv.
Midrange is BlieSMa M74B crossed at 520hz LR4 activ (considering my needed max SPL and LR4 I think its fine).
Woofer will be most likely the new Purifi PTT10 crossed activ. Closed.
DSP will be miniDSP Flex or Flex 8 depending if I go with hybrid crossover or not.
Amp for the Woofers is a Accuphase 303-X (I inherit from my grandpa, so selling it, is more or less no option)
Amp for the Midrange I consider Tubelab SE with single-ended 300B
Amp for the Tweeter will be the same (if hybridcrossover) or a Tubelab SSE with single ended KT88 13-15Watt (to come closer to the max SPL of the M74B with 7-8 Watts from 300Bs)
I have a UMIK1 for measurements.
I dont know if I wanna go the Tube route with a Hybrid Crossover or not... Or just use 3 Amps... one less amp is tempting...
The plan for hybrid (of couse can only be finaled with enclosure build and measurments taken):
The plan if going full activ:
The enclosure plan:
Volume for the Purifi is exactly 24,8 L like Purifi datasheet and WinISD consider for 0,7. (You can get the mm² from sketchup for every object and than get the volume out of it. Volumen displacement from the Purifi is also considert.)
It maybe look like the enclosure for the purifi goes all the way to the top. But there is a plank under to M74B without any holes.
The bracing you can see in the pictures.
The front is in total 30cm wide. At the mid of the Midrangedome its 142mm wide and at the tweeter 88mm wide. C-T-C speacing between tweeter and midrange is about 1,2. (I follow some of HifiJims (and his friends) recommandations, I found at diy audio.
It will be build ot of 22mm good quality MDF and all parts will be glued with SikaBond T1 Purform. I have a fully equipt woodshop in my basement with a format circular saw, routers and so on. It will take time to do all the parts, but that's what make the design possible for me. You can print every piece in Sketchup in 1:1 and than use a router and flexible curve ruler to get it perfect. Than use the finished one as template for the same pieces.
The Tuned Mass Damper at the top will build out of steel with a total diameter of 110mm. It will be damped with small adjustable oildampers you can buy for RC cars. And it will be adjustable in height. I consider to make it out of aluminium and hollow to adjust the weight with damping oil. But this will increase the costs and chances are, the oil will escape.
I want you to ask, if my design is completely ******** or are there some mayjor design flaws?
Should I skip the hybric crossover and take a miniDSP Flex 8 with 3 Amps instead and for what reasons?
What I could maybe improve?
I just tried 2 passiv Notches for the M74B like found on this forum, but cant see much improvement over just one with slightly diffrent values. Is there a reason to use two? The Peaks are to close in my option to get much benefit out of it. Peak of resonance is -54 dB down at its highest point.
Thank you very much, be nice and greeting from Germany.