The Hundred-Buck Amp Challenge

We mention a tube here and some %#&hole buys them all. It has happened too many times. I will not mention any more numbers until it is necessary.

Tellmebouddit. It even happened with these VHF small signal dual triodes that don't even have any mention of audio applications in the spec sheet, but which appeared quite frequently in TV front ends. Despite that, I discovered that they really do make for sonic excellence the way I used 'em (and have added glowey bottle coolness due to larger than usual cathodes).

After that, the price for these tripled. Still much less than what you'd pay for comparable duals that are more well known as audio small signal triodes, but still, no $1.00 a pop either. I prefer to buy these at hamventions so's I can pick up the ones with parallel connected heaters.

I got a box of these TV HD pents that I use as audio finals when Radio Daze decided to get out of the VT supply business and dumped their inventory. Even then, I was almost too late to the party to get the version I wanted (since the GTA types red plate in my particular design).
 
Must be some HV DIY project that ate them up.

They are used in DIY X-ray machines.....no joke. Why do you think they were designed out of TV's.

It even happened with these VHF small signal dual triodes

Be careful here. Thats what I'm using in Amp 2.0. I haven't chosen a flavor yet, so I can't say anything.

I was almost too late to the party to get the version I wanted (since the GTA types red plate in my particular design).

I was too late to get the box full of one of my favorites, but I did get a box full of the ones you are speaking of.

George, you need to pronounce some beam triode as the ultimate SET tube

SHHHHH, I haven't said a word and someone bought enough of them to get them removed from the dollar list. They may have some use if I can stop the oscillation.
 
"They may have some use if I can stop the oscillation. "

I've found that putting a small pin hole in the glass works well to quiet them down, then they can be used for their impressive appearance top side with the big plates. (and Mosfets under the chassis.) Lets see, could actually make use of them for freq. compensation capacitors for the SS circuitry. Pull them out and the amp goes unstable, eating the speaker. (an impressive test of functionality)
 
Last edited:
"I recall someone was using them to direct drive electrostatic speeks some time ago."

Probably one of the bigger beam triodes like 6HV5 or 6JK5. The 6BK4 is a 1.5 mA wimp.

The 38HE7 is a relevant tube for our amplifier use here, and was on the box specials menu for like $0.33 a tube. All five boxes (100 tubes each) of them sold out one day after I posted the triode configured curves for it. It may still be available on the $1 menu though.
 
Last edited:
Just use ten different tubes for the design.

Hmmm, that gives me an idea for special effects, two different output tubes in P-P. Then maybe two different driver tubes too. Assymetrical splitter. Up to six so far.

There used to be digital logic circuits published that used NE-2 bulbs and fuse clips. Some way to get them to amplify? Maybe could use them for special saturation effects in the screen circuits at least. The fuse clips went over the NE-2 bulb and influenced the trigger/firing voltage. If the preamp stage were very high gain to generate sufficient voltage to trigger the bulbs, one might be able to parallel a hundred bulbs with incrementally staggered trigger voltages on the clips (multi-tap resistive divider chain). Then as the signal increases, more bulbs would fire across. Problem still remains as to how to turn them off incrementally. Seems like one needs a HF carrier B+ to turn them off at zero crossings. Then maybe mult-phase HF B+ with multiple bunches of NE-2s so that conduction could be overlapped for signal continuity. This would lead to a significant problem in sorting out the firing potentials of all the hundreds of NE-2s, but this could be a service (for fee) provided by the seller, like matching tubes, but here an automated tester would determine the voltage ratings like zeners and label them. Impossible to hoard hundreds of such devices then.
 
Last edited:
This is getting us back to the old "secret components sealed in a tar filled box" scenario. You need to put some unspecified components into an epoxy filled cube, so that the amplifier cannot be duplicated without this black box "key". Then there would be no point in anyone hoarding the tubes, since they could not build the amplifier without these "keys". Maybe just dip the preamp tube in black epoxy paint or sand blast the numbers off of metal tubes. Hmm, even glass tubes would work here if the numbers were sand blasted off and the glass frosted. Could even publish the schematic with the special tube #s that only the seller could provide. I suppose that would kind of defeat the purpose of this exercise though of making a design for anyone to build.
 
Last edited:
Sorting NE-2s please don't forget about the aim: sound, that must be musical, and changed from soft to aggressive easily, by the guitarist himself.
Speaking of epoxy, when I invented what was known in Western countries as Phaser (I called it multi-rejector comb filter), my friend made it of small cubes, with springs between them. Open the box, and they jump around.
 
Interesting. How about little pill capsules of sand attached to a spring delay line? Sort of like sand filled shakers. Would give some interesting sound effects. Hmmm, getting ideas here. How about making the OT with loose laminations? Sort of like gravel washed jeans. Or a gapped SE OT with powdered iron sprinkled into the gap. The old telephone mics had some kind of carbon granules for variable resistors. Could be cool if the amp gave off sounds when it got shaken. Or maybe put a mini speaker on the pre-amp tube to inject microphonics. With little tuning fork like resonators epoxied to the tube. I saw a piano perfomance once where the piano had various size screws inserted between the strings for effects. I suggested afterwards that they try putting some marbles onto the piano strings.
 
Last edited:
This is getting us back to the old "secret components sealed in a tar filled box" scenario.

Ever take apart a 60's vintage Standel guitar amp? There were several plastic boxes each filled with a different colored epoxy. Each box had colored wires coming out of the epoxy going to terminal strips. About the only thing not encapsulated were the output transistors and the power supply.

Ever see a Standel amp today? Even heard of Standel? You couldn't fix them and they blew up a lot. Bye Bye Standel!

Fast forward 25 years and Standel is back.....and the schematics to all the little colored boxes are posted on their web site. OH, and their "new amp" is a copy of one of the first Standel tube amps.
 
Did Heathkit ever make a guitar amp?

Yes they did. I fixed one of them too back in about 1972. It would not be allowed here. It was infested with sand based life forms and didn't glow. Unless you count the millisecond flash given off by the emitter resistors when the output transistors short out.

It is interesting to note that the power amplifier section of the big Heathkit guitar amp, and the power amp section of the Kustom 50 watt models were exactly the same. The Kustom 100 watt model just ran two 50 watt amps in parallel. Why were the circuits the same? Because they were both copied from the RCA transistor manual.

Never heard of Standel.

They were expensive amps used by some big name bands. So "unique" that there was a Band named the Standels, and they werent playing Fenders. Their one hit, Dirty Water.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8h2gVcDQ9E
 
Last edited:
I just scanned thru the RCA tube manual to see if it had a guitar amp, no luck. Maybe one of their application reports had one. Then maybe they didn't think much of guitar amp designs to bother either. I have this subconcious feeling that guitar amp sound evolved from cheapest amplifier design.
I keep trying to find the best OT and HV xfmr when I should be settling on the cheapest junk. It just has to be loud.

My last "brilliant" idea for the night before sleepy brain fog sets in:
Seems that RF amplifiers were built using the negative resistance slope of tunnel diodes. Now gas regulator tubes are supposed to have negative resistance too. So maybe there IS some way to get gain out of an NE-2 after all. Would be novel anyway. Probably hugely wasteful of power or something. Have to look up tunnel diode amplifiers to see how they worked. I'm envisioning a single NE-2 for the 1st stage, and then parallel banks of increasing numbers for the subsequent stages, until useful power is reached. Probably thousands of NE-2s for the output stage. Anybody who builds this WILL have to hoard NE-2s. Well, maybe a mercury street light could be used for the output stage.
 
Last edited:
hehe... Thinking about this negative resistance amplifier scheme further, the old tetrode tubes have a large negative resistance region due to secondary emission. Now there's a tube type that no one will hoard or even miss if they do all sell out.

In any case, I think this outlines a new strategic approach for me on this project. An ultra cheap guitar amplifier is likely to be built in very large quantities, and so will soon remove all supplies of its parts/tubes, so the objective should be to use the junkiest parts that should be disposed of, yet function just sufficiently well to meet the cost requirements.
 
Last edited:
If my numbers are correct, I just hit 11W plate dissipation on a tube spec'd at 4W plate dissipation, and there was no sign of red plate (4.76V on the 130R cathode resistor and 320V on the plate).

I got a whopping 2.5W out in push pull. However, that is over twice what I got in SE, and is more than enough for me. I'll dial it back and see what it does tomorrow.
 
I just scanned thru the RCA tube manual to see if it had a guitar amp, no luck. Maybe one of their application reports had one.

There wasn't one in the transistor manual either. Most of the Fender designs evolved from curcuits published for HiFi or radio use. Many of the Marshall designs evolved from Fender designs. Look at the similarities in the early schematics.

The early solid state guitar amp designs ofthe copied the output circuitry directly from HiFi designs. The most extreme solid state amp I ran across was an old Danelectro. It used the totem pole with trifilar driver transformer design that was very popular in early solid state HiFi's using PNP germanium output transistors. Danelectro ran the output stage directly off of rectified wall outlet using high voltage silicon devices from Delco and used a speaker cabinet with all the speakers wired in series. Wire up a conventional 8 ohm cabinet and the fire gods will dance all over the amp.

I did a "Transistorlab" version of this using 24 X 2N3773's that made over 1200 watts (military surplus heat sink with transistors already on it). Serious rock and roll in 1970. That amp was still running last time I saw it in the late 80's. I just replaced the power supply caps.

Seems that RF amplifiers were built using the negative resistance slope of tunnel diodes....Have to look up tunnel diode amplifiers to see how they worked.

They required a piece of RF magic known as a circulator. Ferrite, magnets, and resonance all combine to create a device that has 3 ports aranged in a circle. It works like the RF version of a traffic circle, the RF only flows one direction. Now add a negative resistance device to one port and you will have gain across the othar two ports. The circulator keeps the output energy from flowing back to the input, or you will have a tunnel diode oscillator.

I just hit 11W plate dissipation on a tube spec'd at 4W plate dissipation, and there was no sign of red plate

Welcome to my world. As many know I have found tubes that can be operated well beyond the ratings. I have also found tubes that can't. Most of the little 7 pin radio tubes don't take too kindly to overload. I have found that there is a very fine line on the 6AQ5 that divides between "cranked" and "sucking air". The glass is so close to the plate, and the plate hot spots in a localized area, so the glass will melt and a crater will form. Wait about 2 minutes and there will be no more vacuum.
 
Disabled Account
Joined 2004
I did build a 6SL7/6SN7 SE guitar amp. Good sound but not enough power.
Someone with a 100dB/1m speaker would have been happy and satisfied. I wasn't. Mine is 96dB. Little by little I've realized I'm no teenager and I can play as loud as I want to. Sooooo who wants a puny 1 watter? :D

Ok, I've covered now the 'not really loud area' and I'm not interested. Of course I could spend the money on a very sensitive speaker. Celestion Vintage 30 is pretty good. 1W amp with that speaker will be enough for some fun. LOUD.

After all these years the Champ is still the low wattage amp to copy anyway. No designer has beaten it, I see clones with el84's but almost same circuit. So if Wavebourn can make those Russian tubes sing, he's got many chances of winning. IMO.