If by "main law" you mean "First Law," every cell does. Every known biological process does. Same with the Second Law. The Third Law is irrelevant since biological processes do not happen at absolute zero.
I cannot describe to you the details of a pathway that doesn't exist. Your question has no answer because it's based on a false premise.
Actually, it is your answers that are based on false premise that self-organization in the nature complains to the 2'nd law of thermodynamics. It does not.
Every time I open my bag with cables before the next concert I have to spend some energy in order to organize them. They jam without my help. But sometimes opening a can with jam I often find there self-organized green matter on top of a jam that self-organized without my help.
Every time I open my bag with cables before the next concert I have to spend some energy in order to organize them. They jam without my help. But sometimes opening a can with jam I often find there self-organized green matter on top of a jam that self-organized without my help.
Last edited:
The occupation of a lower energy state leads to self organization - see crystals.
Cells are an open system, receiving matter and energy from external sources so why do they violate the second law of TD?
I find it funny when folks doubt the self organization of cells - wtf, they do it everyday. The question just is - how did they get from a prebiotic state to a biotic state in the first instance.
Last edited:
Why do they use an external energy source to self-organize, unlike my cables that use it to self-deorganize, that complains fine with Thermodynamics?
Why cables don't eat and don't poop? They react the same way dead cells do.
Yes, it is the mystery! They do that easily, repeatedly, but do not eat and do not poop!
But they don't reproduce. And don't regenerate, unfortunately...
I know, I know SY has the answer! But he keeps it in secret, repeating every time names, definitions, empirically found laws of higher order than is needed to answer the question...
Small things slip down past big things. That's why there's dust in the bottom of the coffee jar and new rocks on top of the farmer's field every spring.
The cables won't deorganize if they're not jiggled in some fashion.
Oh! Energy is transferred. How about that!
common roots:
Genome of ancient sponge reveals origins of first animals, cancer
Sponge shines light on life's origin: Genome connects the dots between Amphimedon, animal descendants
prebiotic:
Secret of life on Earth may be as simple as what happens between the sheets -- mica sheets, that is
Origin of life: Adding UV light helps form 'Missing G' of RNA building blocks
'Nature's batteries' may have helped power early lifeforms
Did phosphorus trigger complex evolution -- and blue skies?
Peptides may hold 'missing link' to life
Secrets of unique enzyme may illuminate ancient ecosystems
the first cellular organisms:
Model explains rapid transition toward division of labor in biological evolution
Complex, multicellular life from over two billion years ago discovered
How did higher life evolve? Brown algal genome opens new door to understanding multicellularity and photosynthesis
Just a short selection on what is happening in biology.
If you want an unambiguous answer on how life occurred - read the any of the holy books that give you a definite answer, although all different.
If you are willing to entertain doubt, ambiguity, not knowing definitely, leaving room for new findings: then science is for you.
What? Someone changed his conclusion (presumably) based on new data? What kind of person would do THAT???
I think some of the difference between what these two people observe are the selection of the people they're involved in. Blackmore has had many people come to her claiming psychic phenomena for most of her life, and they are "true believers" in their craft, eager to share their amazing discoveries with others. Even the makers of the piece of jewelry Hillary Clinton wore, once contacted, were willing to provide "real" and "fake" items for testing and work with Blackmore in an attempt to show that it works.
This PBS Nova episode featuring James Randi, originally broadcast 17 years ago, demonstrates Randi going after not just those who may be self-deceived (as many of these psychics are), but those who, as he demonstrated, INTENTIONALLY and CONSCIOUSLY deceive others for their own profit (especially see the section on TV evangelist Peter Popoff, in the second segment).
YouTube - Secrets of The Psychics (Part 1 of 6)
Continued cynicism is well justified.
Let's wait for a new work called, "Application of Thermodynamics' Laws to Evolution of Cables".
Thermodynamics was very convenient for steam machine business, why can't be re-used for audio, with addition of Darwin's Theory of Evolution, huh?
I think it is already adequately covered by the second law of thermodynamics, no?
Attachments
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.