would polls asking if a horn forum be helpful as to seeing if the community could benefit from such a dedicated forum? - or do existing forums such as fullrange - subwoofer - multiway - PA pretty much take care of things? (there's always the Klipsch community although pretty much locked into Klipsch products)
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
As already displayed many times over in this thread, what would qualify as a horn forum?
Don't bother trying to answer, we all know how many different opinions there are, hence the root of the evil.
Don't make this any more laborious than it is. Be happy with what is here. It is the best of it's kind anywhere in the English speaking world as far as I can tell.
If it's not to your liking, fine but there are a lot of minds that do this sort of thinking on a daily basis. I am going to side with their decisions as they are well thought out.
Don't bother trying to answer, we all know how many different opinions there are, hence the root of the evil.
Don't make this any more laborious than it is. Be happy with what is here. It is the best of it's kind anywhere in the English speaking world as far as I can tell.
If it's not to your liking, fine but there are a lot of minds that do this sort of thinking on a daily basis. I am going to side with their decisions as they are well thought out.
Given that we would not want to steal from legitimate use of horns in multi-way or FR loudspeakers (ie invariably part of the spectrum is direct radiator), the only thing that would qualify would be a fullt horn loaded system, i have seen pictures, but there are few if any here. Very few people have the room for a fully horn loaded system.
Its a thread, not a forum.
dave
Yeah, look how many times it's been debated 'when is a horn a horn ', and 'when is it a waveguide' .
Sometimes I've thought maybe multiway should be split: "active vs passive", and "simulations vs real speakers".
But then I also find i keep learning things from simulations I wouldn't see if left to focus only on my own "real speaker" primary interest.
So it's cool to be exposed to stuff i might be inclined to skip.
Now if only i could say the same thing about passives LOL
I think it’s fine as is, but if I were to make a split it would be real speaker projects split from theory, testing, and simulations. If you haven’t purchased any parts or lumber yet, you can’t post in the projects section.
What is a horn? = theory, testing, simulation
Check out this horn I built! = projects
What is a horn? = theory, testing, simulation
Check out this horn I built! = projects
Well, here is my compromise to a separate horn-forum: I think it is a good idea/practice to clearly indicate in the thread-name, what the thread is all about!
For instance the heading for my thread includes the word "MEH", as I hope that it will make it easier to find for people interested in MEH´s.
That actually makes sense for me.
Steffen
For instance the heading for my thread includes the word "MEH", as I hope that it will make it easier to find for people interested in MEH´s.
That actually makes sense for me.
Steffen
I vote for everything in just one big category.
I can make up thousands of ideas that would fit in all categories.
There is so much overlap.
It just makes things unnecessary complicated for no reason.
Plus I don't like pigeonholing.
In the end they are just sound reproducers.
Whether you go left or right.
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member