Harbeth SHL5 Plus Rosewood with Stands

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
8mm MDF, veneered on both faces, last I checked.

As far as the crossover goes, the majority of current Harbeth models run MKT film caps from Suntan in Hong Kong (you can see them in the image Steve posted), although the 40th Anniversary models, if memory serves, have MKPs produced for them by ClarityCap. Alan follows the BBC mantra of even axial response as the dominant objective, with the same bitumen damped thin-wall construction approach the BBC research department under Harwood focused on.
 
Disabled Account
Joined 2019
wazaaa ?

Ah got it, courtesey of on line dictionaries ! Well, one has not have to use them... just let them on stands and fire the Altec A5 at the oposite of the living room...

Ah, I'm sure you want already to upgrade the filter:D... but send e the woofer please !
 
Last edited:
I loved my time with the SHL5plus. incredibly transparent mids and very good bass extension, they really go down to 30hz.
imaging is not their forte. its still just a 8 inch woofer so the bass wont shake your body like a 12" let alone a 15". and the treble was to my ears too bright.

but that midrange... probably the most transparent and open window iver ever heard.

but at the end of the day, nothing replace a 12"or 15" for bass, and im not a fan of metal tweeters.
I will buy a pair of Harbeth 40.2 one day
 
Last edited:
Disabled Account
Joined 2019
I loved my time with the SHL5plus. incredibly transparent mids and very good bass extension, they really go down to 30hz.
imaging is not their forte. its still just a 8 inch woofer so the bass wont shake your body like a 12" let alone a 15". and the treble was to my ears too bright.

but that midrange... probably the most transparent and open window iver ever heard.

but at the end of the day, nothing replace a 12"or 15" for bass, and im not a fan of metal tweeters.
I will buy a pair of Harbeth 40.2 one day


This thing should let us think twice. The main driver is going perhaps till 1500 hz and it's very transparent. Like an ESL which sweet spot is also difficult ?!
Now imagine the polycone driver in a modern enclosure like a Kef Blade or a Vivid !
Now the hybrid ESL have often a XO in the 200 - 500 hz area and I read testimonials some liked more the Haberth polycone presentation than an ESL diagphragm ! Maybe a filter in that area is not such a good thing ! And I wonder about the XO cutoffs choice of the Haberth flagship with its two plymer cones...Well it's OT !
 
Last edited:
Well, it's a flippin' miracle that some loudspeakers conceived by Alan Shaw in Sussex, England are currently rocking up to your door in the Windy City of Chicago, Illinois! :D

Arizona to Chicago is quite a Road Movie in itself. And who did it better than Harry Dean-Stanton? :cool:

We have no idea who the Truck Driver might pick up on the way! Me and Bobby Mc.Gee

Current 2 metre social distancing, naturally, considered. TBH, I think Waylon, Johnny, Willie and Kris would buy these speakers. But let's wait. :)
 
Maybe it's being escorted by black 77 Trans Am and they will stop to pick-up Janis and a dog named boo, that would test Macgyver for sure.

To top all that, my desktop wallpaper in the one of Johnny's back with the guitar slung and face in profile. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This thing should let us think twice. The main driver is going perhaps till 1500 hz and it's very transparent.

3.2KHz actually. Harbeth Super HL5plus loudspeaker Measurements | Stereophile.com

Now imagine the polycone driver in a modern enclosure like a Kef Blade or a Vivid!

It's clearly a good driver of its type in terms of its FR. It is not likely to significantly benefit from a differently shaped box, except in terms of diffraction, which does not appear to be a major issue in the original. The enclosure resonances are high Q, so less likely to be excited on a varying signal, although in theory either some additional bracing or additional damping may have been beneficial. The HL5 however is deliberately designed and voiced the way it is because it is a direct decendent of earlier speakers, so they cannot significantly depart from that.

Now the hybrid ESL have often a XO in the 200 - 500 hz area and I read testimonials some liked more the Haberth polycone presentation than an ESL diagphragm!

Probably do (almost certainly) but a matter of opinion.

Maybe a filter in that area is not such a good thing!

Nothing wrong with it taken independently, but if you cross an ESL to a moving coil in that BW you risk a significant shift in polar behaviour / characteristics. This is a matter that varies on a case by case basis depending on design details.
 
We have touchdown! Harbeth porn tomorrow, I put off shopping all day to make sure I was here to sign for them... I have to do some marketing, and then a haircut.. looking like damn wookiee!

Then it's home for some fine Irish refreshments and possible the first listen... I might just sit here drinking single malt and admiring them. lol
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.