VIFA NE85W vs SEAS MU10

It is one i would like to hear. If you are looking for good but pricey, the Alpair 5 MAOP: https://www.madisoundspeakerstore.c...agnetic-arc-oxidized-full-range-matched-pair/

maop5-4.jpg


dave
 
Not sure why you'd any of these in a three way

They're basically ideal for a full range or maybe a two-way

I've tried six of them:
TC9, TG9, the Fostex FF85WK, the Vifa and SB Acoustics and the Faital:

1) for the money I don't think you'll beat the TC9. Nothing as good in it's price range IMHO

2) Though I have the TG9 I haven't heard them

3) The Vifa is "ok" but when used as a full range they're something missing at the top

4) Fostex looks like it should cost $10 but sounds fantastic. A little better than the TC9

5) SB Acoustics - if I had to pick one, that's probably it. Sounds about as good as the Fostex, but a better choice for car audio. (Much more weatherproof)

6) Faital will rip your ears off and I've never been able to understand why it's so popular. It's loud... that's about all I can say for it.

If you go digging over at diymobileaudio.com, there is an aluminum full range designed specificall for cars that used to sell for over $100, which MCM/Newark Electronics is doing on clearance for about $15 and it looks like it's competitive with the SB Acoustics, at least on paper

Plus, obviously, the Scanspeak 10F is beloved in this size range
 
SB65

Both drivers are good I just like the SB65 a little better

Both sound "clean" due to their low distortion, but the SB65 has about 2-3dB more output above 10khz and if you're running them full range it makes a difference

If you're not running them full range they'll likely sound about the same IMHO
 
  • Like
Reactions: vassilis1984
Another one worth considering is the ND64 from Dayton. It will go in a tiny enclosure, and sounds good within its limits. For low distortion, I wouldn't cross lower than 400 Hz. It lacks a little air/detail in the top 1.5 octaves when directly compared to a higher quality transducer, but in my experience most full range drivers do, and it doesn't make that much difference in typical listening. Irrelevant if you are using a tweeter anyway.

I've tested a pile of small drivers as well (SB65, TG9FD, FF85WK, bunch of the cheap Tang Band, Peerless, and Dayton 1.5-3 inchers, etc.). My top 3 in no order are the TG9FD, FF85WK, and ND64. The SB65 is pretty good too, but it costs more than ND64 and requires a larger enclosure, so that pushed me toward the ND64.

https://www.parts-express.com/Dayto...ne-Full-Range-Driver-4-Ohm-295-520?quantity=1