And I take my hat off to him that he is attempting such a complex xover. I think if you can do/understand this all other manipulations will be a piece of cake for you
Use ricky then byrtt.dk should work also when files are huge but it can sometimes be a problem that modern smtp servers don't allow you to transmit if its huge, then suggest divide measurement one at a time for each mdat, for example if you want send me tweeter and woofer response then highlight one of them in most left column and go to "File" and "Save measurement" with a renamed name after that do same for the other and send one at a time to above pop3 account.
The reflected sound adds to the direct sound, I've not read that it is ever louder
are you sure?
Don't you think it will work
well no matter where we end for his speaker we tried a online cooperation and hope he got some clues and good advices that hes self confidence is raised so to finalize system down the road, if system ever will finalize when one own a DSP unit and get ideas .
Issue here is I wouldn't know good when it is staring in my face. Wife says slow and steady
You would know if you put the target curve in REW plot window and adjusted the measured via EQ and filter combo until they match. That’s the only way to do it if you are not familiar with what a BW4 and BS2 “Looks like by feel”. Until they match the textbook curves you are going to flail without success. So please slow down and try to implement a textbook overlay plot. It’s a must because your curves are way way off. They look like BW4 and BW4 so will naturally cancel with a deep notch when same polarity.
Use the REW EQ tab to implement the correct filters and then upload curves to miniDSP. Read up on that functionality. You can do it with 2-5 measurements with the proper technique.
And please move up away from 100Hz XO. That’s a bad spot from distortion standpoint and time delay standpoint. Try 350Hz. Move lower once you know how to do it. You can’t get BS2 on Eikona at 100Hz because it has natural falloff that will not allow you to implant a BS2 falloff.
Last edited:
Right critics and very good points and hope readers bite on here if they want a documented acoustic system response be close to perfect textbook like your own system can perform out at listening position or how my own is calibrated up front. That said lets see how far we goo here or how lucky we are things fast start shape up and go our way, say this because my own calibration didn't take hours it took probably a week or many more and in mkane77g is new to diy a DSP speaker think task is get him going and then he can develop skills and ambitions down the probably never ending new ideas DSP owner road.
The reflected sound adds to the direct sound, I've not read that it is ever louder
If can happen with low frequency and when measuring a dipole more than 60 deg off-axis. At least I have experienced that!
Good points but you probably very busy yourself and haven't noticed pages back that mid tweeter dictated XO point upped to 160Hz, below is where he acoustic is now @LR4 that when time aligned will be electric transferred to BW4 and BS2 slopes.
Measuring low frequencies that are travelling around the baffle at such a large off axis angle that are most likely not reflections off the front wall, I don't think you can be sure of the source of what you are measuring to be honest