Remember that a TO-92 case (unless there is a special lead frame for enhanced power dissipation) has a junction-to-ambient thermal resistance of ~200C/Watt. I wouldn't operate the jfets at much higher than about 60C case temperature - choose your power dissipation accordingly.
If I were you, I would lose those fancy LM317 current sources. I've found LM317s used in that way to be hiss factories (even though the LT versions are probably quieter than 317s from the usual vendors). Depletion-mode mosfets are much quieter, and will be better current sources over a wider frequency range. If you don't go too crazy with the current, you could possibly use a TO-92 device like the Supertex DN2530N3.
If I were you, I would lose those fancy LM317 current sources. I've found LM317s used in that way to be hiss factories (even though the LT versions are probably quieter than 317s from the usual vendors). Depletion-mode mosfets are much quieter, and will be better current sources over a wider frequency range. If you don't go too crazy with the current, you could possibly use a TO-92 device like the Supertex DN2530N3.
good point
...Given ambient here recently has been sneaking its way into the mid 40's, thats not a lot of headroom 🙂
My (shallow) understanding was that a j310 was good for upto 350-400mW, so I was targeting around 200mW as an average dissipation, on the grounds that the transconductance of the jfets, according to the datasheet (as I understood it perhaps?
) is greater at a higher current. At 200C/W I can see that i'm biased way too high. Well that's easily sorted at least!
With regards to the current sources, I picked the lm317 as a convenient option (or as I read Juma recently say "to save on shoes") as I have a heap of them here and it was an easy and lazy solution. There's a thread here on diy audio containing an image comparing a variety of different current source/sinks and this solution was amongst the best in terms of accuracy.
I hadn't considered the noisiness of them though.
Depletion mode fet's aren't something I have in the parts box, but I'm sure I can come up with a slightly more complex solution easily enough using whats on hand. I'll be a pretty rough point to point effort initially anyway...
...Given ambient here recently has been sneaking its way into the mid 40's, thats not a lot of headroom 🙂
My (shallow) understanding was that a j310 was good for upto 350-400mW, so I was targeting around 200mW as an average dissipation, on the grounds that the transconductance of the jfets, according to the datasheet (as I understood it perhaps?

With regards to the current sources, I picked the lm317 as a convenient option (or as I read Juma recently say "to save on shoes") as I have a heap of them here and it was an easy and lazy solution. There's a thread here on diy audio containing an image comparing a variety of different current source/sinks and this solution was amongst the best in terms of accuracy.
I hadn't considered the noisiness of them though.
Depletion mode fet's aren't something I have in the parts box, but I'm sure I can come up with a slightly more complex solution easily enough using whats on hand. I'll be a pretty rough point to point effort initially anyway...
btw. Norman E. Thagard (Papa's Flying Pal ) had beautiful phono pre , published in Audioxpress 01 and 02/2001
title A Phono Pre-Preamplifier for the CD Era
title A Phono Pre-Preamplifier for the CD Era
Subscription access only, but it's the only version I could find on the web
Audio Xpress-August 2001
Now you've teased me here ZM - is the learning gained from buying access to this worth it?
🙂
edit - added pic of current sources and their effectiveness. I'll probably use (I) now...
Audio Xpress-August 2001
Now you've teased me here ZM - is the learning gained from buying access to this worth it?
🙂
edit - added pic of current sources and their effectiveness. I'll probably use (I) now...
Attachments
Last edited:
Yeah, but that's peeking in the back of the book... We're trying to do the design that Nelson presented at this year's Burning amp, but using more humble fets. I'm pretty happy so far with my single ended designs so far, otherwise I'd be working on this project with more enthusiasm.
The list on the current sources says nothing about their merits in audio circuits. Th most important issue is impedance over frequency, Voltage you can set somewhere else. In that respect the cascodede Jfet is a winner by a great margin.
Somewhere on Diyaudio there a link to a study of current source circuits that include Ixys and Supertex depletion mode parts. They are quite good by themselves, and even better cascoded. The tester looked at capacitance and output impedance vs. frequency. If you can't get the depletion mode parts, a bipolar-mosfet ring-of-two source could be a contender.
The depletion mosfets are good for larger currents, for smaller Jfet-s are clearly better, the major difference is the larger capacitance of the mosfets that undermines the impedance at larger frequencies.
Well I've plenty of jfets of varying flavours, so that should be fine. If I get my act together after dinner I may just knock out a pcb design...
Yeah, but that's peeking in the back of the book... .....
as sort of learning drill 😉 , not copy project
those things are made long before last year's BAF
Here's Gary Pimm's examination of several current sources, including depletion mosfets (they fare pretty well). Stray capacitance considerations for this application are relaxed comapred to Pimm's intended purpose (plate loads for vaccuum tubes), as there is no appreciable voltage swing across the current source when driving a folded cascode. However, the current source must be reasonably quiet, as any noise will be dumped straight down through the cascode transistor into the gain resistor.
Pimm CCS URL: CCS performance measurments
P.S. I'm familiar with NT's RIAA project. I thought it was a nice circuit at the time (still is), but I never felt particularly motivated to build it.
Pimm CCS URL: CCS performance measurments
P.S. I'm familiar with NT's RIAA project. I thought it was a nice circuit at the time (still is), but I never felt particularly motivated to build it.
Last edited:
That ccs analysis is quite interesting. I need to sit down and have a proper read of Walt Jung's CCS articles too. Party 2 on his site is around depletion FETs and 317's.
Well, if you insist on adding a noise source to make things lively, use the 317. I used an LM317L as a current source in one of my experimental RIAA preamps and regretted it - it hissed like a nest full of snakes...
I don't intend to now! I'm here to learn and if the learning is that there's a better solution I'm all ears.
I'm playing with the sim at the moment, but my current challenge is biasing the latfet properly.
I'm playing with the sim at the moment, but my current challenge is biasing the latfet properly.
Last edited:
And here's a follow up from Jung where he specifically apologises for not addressing the hiss in the lm317 current source and specifically states that they're not suitable for user in a line stage. http://www.waltjung.org/PDFs/Sources_101_Letter_Revisit_0409.pdf
I would but I'm very busy reading about current sources here http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/anal...-supplies-phono-line-preamps.html#post3803384
🙂
As text occasionally struggles to convey humour I thought I'd clarify that this is a joke - the thread referenced is wrenchone's CCS analysis post 🙂
🙂
As text occasionally struggles to convey humour I thought I'd clarify that this is a joke - the thread referenced is wrenchone's CCS analysis post 🙂
Last edited:
DN2540 is acceptable in 40dB gain levels, around 60dB gain I think it may just start being detectable for hiss contribution as an input stage CCS.
And here's a follow up from Jung where he specifically apologises for not addressing the hiss in the lm317 current source and specifically states that they're not suitable for user in a line stage. http://www.waltjung.org/PDFs/Sources_101_Letter_Revisit_0409.pdf
Interesting, I did not search he had revisited the 317 issue. I remember I had built that hybrid CCS and when I tried it as anode load in a line preamp it was hissing. I might actually still have that module somewhere in a parts box.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Source & Line
- Analogue Source
- RIAA Preamp/Line Amp Using Variant of NP LSK170/LSJ74 Folded Cascode Circuit